2 ms·
> So, is there some way of controlling the gain? In engineering, yes, always. In the social sciences, not always. > How about, limiting the visibility of comm
by lutusp 14y ago
> So, is there some way of controlling the gain?
In engineering, yes, always. In the social sciences, not always.
> How about, limiting the visibility of comments to a subset of the community.
That would mean the system isn't a single system any more. Apart from making the system two or more systems, it's undemocratic and probably counterproductive.
Consider the classic example -- astrophysicist Jim Peebles had an idea about the Big Bang, that there should be a residual "echo" of the original event, "audible" in the present universe, in the form of a background radiation with a specific temperature that was relatively easy to compute. Peebles realized the radiation should appear in the microwave region of the electromagnetic spectrum, and it should seem to be coming from everywhere (highly uniform).
Meanwhile, physicists Penzias & Wilson over at Bell Labs had a microwave dish with an annoying noise they couldn't get rid of. They scrubbed away bird droppings, they adjusted the front end amplifier, nothing helped, and it didn't matter which way they pointed the dish -- the signal seemed to be coming from everywhere.
Penzias & Wilson called Peebles and asked hum what he though the noise might be. Peebles told them, hung up the phone, and said, "We've been scooped." Penzias & Wilson won the Nobel Prize.
Now that's feedback. And it only happened because there were no communications barriers.