15 ms·
PC obsolescence is obsolete
- TylerE 14y agoYep, seems pretty accurate to me. In fact, my home system is pretty much identical to their hypothetical 2008 i7-920 system. I have made a couple of upgrades over the years (Replaced the original Radeon 4870x2 with a GeForce 560 about 9 months ago when the ATI card died, recently upgraded from the original 6GB of RAM to 24GB. Looking at what's other there now there's nothing that makes sense to upgrade to.
- dman 14y agoRaytraced games probably come closest to what would cause people to upgrade. But even Intel seems to be backing away from raytraced games off late.
- sp332 14y agoIntel backed off because its futuristic hardware platform was too futuristic to make a good GPU. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larrabee_(microarchitecture) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Larrabee_(microarchitecture)
- fein 14y agoI'd say that this is even more valid for home servers. Of the 7 spare boxes I have, five are 5+ years old while two are 2 year old shit home laptops (Inspiron yay!). These were all under $50 a piece when you factor in that 3 were free. All of these guys sit on ubuntu server or archlinux and never have problems. Hell, you can go buy surplus/ old 620's from corporate shops for < $100 and build yourself a full Beowulf cluster for under $500.
- tomflack 14y agoHome servers? I've always used incredibly out-of-date machines as home servers. There has never really been a market for powerful home servers. I had a Pentium 166 with 80MB of EDO ram and a 1GB hard disk (bought new in 1996 as a P120 with 16MB of ram) until the end of 2005 as a home server, running Windows 2000.
- freehunter 14y agoThere is a valid case for "powerful" home servers. Centrally backing up all the PCs in the house and streaming media to computers/TVs/consoles/tablets are two things I do in my house with my server. Granted it's not a brand new system, but it's a Core 2 Quad with 8GB of RAM, 20TB of hard drive space, and a Radeon 5700. Streaming and storing HD video isn't cheap. This centralized server is more cost-effective and convenient than all of my roommates having the media stored locally, though.
- rogerbinns 14y agoYou don't need need memory or CPU power for streaming or backups, unless you are doing on the fly transcoding. You do need storage connectivity but even USB2 has a theoretical throughput of 60 megabytes per second while you'll get practical throughput of ~35 megabytes per second on gigabit ethernet. The only time I saw my ~2005 era system have non-trivial CPU usage was when doing encryption, and even then it would peak at around 25% of CPU.
- freehunter 14y agoEncryption and compression are what the CPU and memory are for. The video card is for transcoding to deliver to the target system. It's mainly just a re-used system, but you wouldn't be able to do it with a PII and 64MB of RAM.
- jewel 14y agoWhat's the power usage of old PCs like that? I've been using a sheeva plug as my server at home because it only uses something like 5 watts. It seems like ARM servers are the best choice for home servers. They have adequate processing power and are cheap.
- fein 14y agoNone of these have over 350W PSU's, and I don't think any of these rigs will draw anywhere close to that power. All I have is anecdotal evidence that my electric bill has increased by maybe $14-$20 a year. Running my stereo for a day probably eats more power than these things take all year. Plus, my livingroom in my apartment stays nice and warm during the midwest winters. I'm pretty happy with spaceheaters with processing power :) edit: the real issue is that I can't get a cable connection in my neighborhood with higher than .7mbit up, so it's not like I 'm serving loads of content. I use these for running different tasks usually. Two are dedicated DB servers and the other 3 run whatever projects I'm consulting on this/ that week.
- icefox 14y agoI also have a sheeva plug as my server, but if i did it over I would choose to grab an mac mini. My big jump to the sheeva was the power usage, but then I found out the mini only uses 12W! Along with the 12W you get a x86, with hd, cd drive, wifi, etc on a box that I can easily load linux (upgrading the sheeva's kernel isn't the easiest...) and in a few years when done with it I can easily sell the mini unlike the sheeva.
- aidenn0 14y agoI use a VIA x86 system for my server. 18W peak from the wall, no fan (which is one less moving part to fail). Since it replaced an old P4 system (200W from the wall), I shaved $30/month off my electric bill
- monkeyfacebag 14y agoNo doubt it has been replaced by device obsolescence, where the screen, camera, wireless radio, etc. are bundled together and improvements in any one component compels the purchase of a whole new unit.
- Silhouette 14y agoSad, but true. Faced with the reality that well-designed, flexible, modular systems have simply become too good, manufacturers are now effectively building in forced obsolescence, either tying components together (the Apple way) or arbitrarily declaring that only certain combinations are permitted (which also works with consumables, like the way my HP colour printer refused to print a black and white document the other day until I replaced an empty colour toner cartridge). Software seems to be going the same way. SaaS is a fairly transparent rip-off in many cases. Certain big-ticket professional software vendors restrict sales to a network of resellers they can control, who dutifully pull last year's version as soon as this year's is available, so if you want to buy an extra copy to go with the 10 you already have, you can't (unless you upgrade your entire organisation to maintain compatibility). Bridging the gap nicely are drivers. Here we see a range of dubious techniques. One popular one seems to be releasing equipment with drivers for certian specific operating systems that are available at the time, but then conveniently not releasing any drivers to support new operating systems released within what would otherwise be the normal lifetime of the device, thus artificially shortening its life often by many years. Another good trick (I'm looking at you nVidia) is to take essentially the same hardware, but sell one version with nerfed drivers and another premium (sorry, "workstation") version with "certified" drivers that actually use the hardware to its full capabilities. I'm a little surprised that we haven't yet seen more people pushing back against these obviously customer-hostile trends, because a lot of people are spending a lot more money and suffering a lot more hassle than they should have to. Certainly some rip-off merchants do come unstuck; I've heard about what would have been extremely lucrative sales of very expensive specialist equipment that got flushed when the prospective customer discovered some form of artificial nerfing in software and took their cash to someone else who didn't do that. But it seems that everyday hardware and software are in one big race to the bottom. Even premium products, like those high-end graphics cards and professional software installations with their multi-thousand price tags per unit, seem to be tolerated because almost everyone is doing it now. Perhaps this is partly because the more honest competition mostly comes from smaller organisations in the hardware field or in software's case via independent software houses and open source communities, and these kinds of suppliers are (rightly or wrongly, probably a bit of both) regarded as not being up to the job of supplying Serious Business Customers(TM). What I haven't yet figured out is why this is still happening. Do you know anyone who, in either a personal or a professional capacity, actually thinks any of this stuff is done to help them, or that spending money on these things is a good deal? In a logical market, we would expect competition to spring up and exploit that vulnerability, promoting brands based on honest dealings and good quality, almost certainly charging a higher price for it, but with a greater perceived value that justifies that price. And yet, this doesn't seem to be happening, which suggests that many of the markets in technology industries are not effectively competitive, or some of the big name players are in practice dominant or outright monopolies even if they're not formally recognised as such.
- mhurron 14y agoI am absolutely amazed, that picture at the beginning of the article seems to have taken on a life of it's own. More on topic, quick PC obsolescence was always something of a myth. Parts were only really obsolete if you absolutely had to run the latest shooter at the absolute highest settings known to man. So it wasn't that it was obsolete, it was that the user needed to justify their desire to buy the latest for bragging rights.
- HCIdivision17 14y agoLess on topic, but more on the picture: I was wondering about that image. Something struck me as off. And then I realized that the computer had a steering wheel. So for those interested, yes, it _is_ odd for a computer to have a steering wheel that large. http://www.snopes.com/inboxer/hoaxes/computer.asp http://www.snopes.com/inboxer/hoaxes/computer.asp
- keithpeter 14y ago"Many a prognosticator who has tried to envision the future has been tripped up by a failure to correctly anticipate the direction of technological change." I straight away thought of Kubrik's 2001. The complete failure to imagine mobile phones. Floyd uses a fixed video phone to phone home from the space ship. Personal mobile technology is the thing. Back nearer the topic: When I can hook my phone up to a monitor and keyboard I'm done. http://www.ubuntu.com/devices/android http://www.ubuntu.com/devices/android
- russell 14y agoIf you remember "Stranger in a Strange Land" (1960s) set around the year 2000, one of the characters, a reporter I believe, had a mobile phone that was the size of a briefcase. Another character marveled that he must be rather well off because mobile phones were so expensive.
- ZoFreX 14y ago> Now, compare an early Core i7 system (Nehalem) against what’s shipping today (Ivy Bridge). Clock speeds are up a bit, and there are cheaper/lower-end options available, but the Core i7-920 that launched at 2.67GHz with four cores and eight threads is still absolutely capable of powering the latest games and applications. A big, big factor in the slowdown of obsolecense is that the current generation of consoles has stretched out far longer than is normal. Because the consoles have fairly PC-esque capabilities (arguably more parity than there has ever been before), many games released today are released on consoles and PC, often on a single code-base, at the very least on a single asset base. Once the next generation of consoles is out, we will see games taking advantage of that extra power, and in turn PC requirements for new games will start to climb again.
- icefox 14y agoIn a way the article yells out trouble for Microsoft and friends. If their customers hardware from the last five years is "good enough" they wont go looking for an upgrade. (They will go looking for a _new_ toy with the ipad though). If next generation consoles really did drive desktop sales it would have been in Microsoft's interests to get out the next generation xbox sooner right?
- rodly 14y agoI don't think it's easy to see Microsoft profiting by leveraging its Xbox division to boost PC sales (Windows license sales). I can't find a source for this, but I doubt Microsoft made much money if at all on the Xbox 360. The money is in Xbox live subscriptions and taking a percentage from sales on the marketplace. This is similar to how Amazon sells its Kindle line at a negative profit but makes a killing in Prime memberships and eBook %'s.
- podperson 14y agoThe irony here is that Microsoft cannibalized the PC gaming market to create the XBox market (and kill its one true enemy at the time: Sony). The result is -- arguably -- stagnation of the desktop PC market which was always -- I contend -- driven largely by gaming. The problem is that the desktop market made Microsoft money whereas consoles... not so much. It seems to me that problem here isn't cannibalization -- if Microsoft hadn't done it, someone else (Sony?) would have -- but the "let's leverage our monopoly-driven money tree" mindset. XBox was dumped on the market at a loss, subsidized by Office/Windows and leveraged by Microsoft's dominance of desktop gaming, APIs, and developer mindshare. Microsoft doesn't even try to play fair in new markets and eventually it had to bite them, and it did.
- swalsh 14y agoI used to do a lot of server work. Mostly virtualization in a lab environment. We created an elaborate test rig which literally the more computers you threw at the problem the faster you could iterate. About 4 years ago I left, but looked back at hardware a few weeks ago. It blew my mind how things have doubled since then. I think servers for real work are still important, and they're not done at getting better faster.
- greedo 14y agoThe server market is almost as stagnant though. Multicore CPUs are important because of server virtualization, and it's always nice to be able to put 1/4TB of memory into a system, but there's a dearth of reasons to upgrade short of EOL or support being discontinued.
- donpdonp 14y agoCore i7? PC Hardware hit a usability plateau with the Core 2 Duo. For modest tasks, my 4.5 year old thinkpad and home desktop are both Core 2 Duo and perform most tasks fabulously. I do look forward to an upgrade but I have thought the same thing that this article states - that PCs are lasting much much longer than they used to. What is more interesting is smaller hardware. Mini-ITX systems, The RaspberryPi, and ATMEL/Arduino systems. Writing C code for a 16k ATMEL is a great way to appreciate the hardware in an 'older' PC.
- estel 14y agoI agree that there was a plateau slightly earlier, but I imagine Nehalem was used as an example because it's consistent with the 4 year cycle mentioned earlier.
- freehunter 14y agoIt is funny that hardware has taken a turn towards slower/lower-end. Appliance computing, I guess. There was a mad dash to make everything as fast as possible, then when it was faster than really required, attention shifted to making computers that are specifically designed for various tasks. Why have one computer that's not really good at anything (but does it fast enough to not care) when you can have a half dozen tiny and power-efficient computers that are great at their job (so good that you don't notice how slow they really are)?
- cupwithyourname 14y agoMaybe I live in a different universe, but I feel like computers are so slow these days. How is everyone claiming that are sufficiently fast? Starting up Outlook takes 10 full seconds (just the splash screen consumes half of that time). When I open up a web browser or click a link in an email, it takes about 5 seconds to fully load. Even distilling a file to pdf or loading Facebook takes almost 5 seconds. I don't think it's an issue of my computer being particularly slow. Everyone at work with their quad core processors and 6gb of ram seem to just sit and wait without noticing. Have you ever been in someone's office while they search for an email? It takes minutes! And don't even try doing any work while Adobe is trying to update or the Antivirus scanner is running... I spend so much time waiting for a computer. Waiting for IDEs to redraw, waiting for my computer to let me disconnect my usb drive, waiting for splash screens. What is going on?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pasbesoin 14y agoTwo (well, three) things have helped me extend the effective life of a few machines for self and family. 1. (Particularly for laptops,) Purchase top-end discreet graphics processing.); 2. Max out the RAM before it becomes terribly expensive (as its form factor is passed by); 3. When storage space becomes constrained, throw a new hard drive in there. Particularly the graphics processing on laptops. Inevitably, this ends up making the difference between a machine becoming "a little slow" versus it becoming "unusable", for general, day-to-day use. In the next ten years, who knows? But I'm betting that going with the best graphics processing available (again, particularly in laptops, where this is often un-upgradable) is going to be a good investment in terms of extending a unit's effective lifespan.
- leviathant 14y agoIt really depends on what you do with your computer. I had a Core 2 Quad system that was perfectly fine for me in 2008, but as I dabble further in HD video editing, I dropped money on a new system a month or two ago. Now I can preview effects in real-time, and the rendering time is so much faster. Likewise, working with photos from my Canon T2i. The ability to chuck 24gb of memory in the system doesn't hurt either, and SSDs? I actually put my 4-year old computer on Craigslist for free because it seemed pretty useless to me after upgrading to this new system. I'm looking forward to what kind of technology will be available in 2016.
- MattRogish 14y agoI think this pretty well reflects Microsoft's long-term consumer risk, too. More than half of MSFT's revenue (http://www.tannerhelland.com/4273/microsoft-money-updated-2012/ http://www.tannerhelland.com/4273/microsoft-money-updated-20...) comes from Windows and Office (and over half the profit, Windows http://news.yahoo.com/microsoft-defer-revenue-windows-upgrade-offer-140940839--finance.html http://news.yahoo.com/microsoft-defer-revenue-windows-upgrad...). Back in the 90s and early 00s, the rate of change in the PC market was amazing. The hardware you could buy in 1998 basically didn't exist in 1996, so there always was something new and exciting to spur new hardware sales. New hardware sales represent the bulk of Microsoft's Windows licensing (the so-called "Microsoft Tax") revenue and so a large part of MSFT's profits. All MS had to do was be the default OS and their profit would grow without lifting a finger (obviously that's greatly simplified, MS had to do a lot of things). Now that this hardware revolution is no longer taking place, MS' Windows licensing rev (and thus the huge profits) are threatened. Competition in the PC market have driven hardware profits to zero. MS and their clone makers have painted themselves into a corner. Contrast this with Apple's strategy - produce desirable hardware that people buy for non-technical reasons (design, fashion, software, etc.) instead of raw figures (CPU, Memory, etc.). Folks will upgrade because they want to, not because they need to. That's a lot harder to pull off, but Apple seems to be doing a great job of it. Ultimately, I think Apple's strategy is going to make a lot more sense in the long run. Drive the cost of the operating system upgrades to zero (I'd be shocked if the next OSX upgrade costs anything; I was quite surprised that Mountain Lion was {edit: not} a fee upgrade), limit the age of device that can run it, and create products that people want.
- tonyedgecombe 14y agoApple's strategy makes sense for Apple, driving down the cost of software makes their hardware more attractive. This doesn't make a great deal of sense for Microsoft, what does is driving down the price of hardware. Their strategy has always been to treat the hardware as a commodity because it is in their interest to do so.
- MattRogish 14y agoI think it made sense in the 90s-00s rapid innovation space. Microsoft needed a computer on every desk/laptop/car/whatever in order to push Windows and Office licenses. Dramatic advances in hardware drove high turnover and more OEM licensing rev/profit. Now that folks aren't upgrading very often, the cost of the Windows license is starting to be a much bigger proportion of the total cost, basically creating a price floor of PCs. This sucks if you're an OEM - you have a baked-in cost you don't control (aka MS Tax). Microsoft must naturally drop the licensing price to OEMS in order for OEMs to eek out some profit. Long run Windows OEM license fees tend to zero. It's already happening with Windows 8 upgrade pricing (Mac OS X has already started this trend) and I expect it to continue. MSFT knows this which is the primary reason to making their Surface Tablet (and Office online, to get SaaS recurring rev). I don't believe for a minute that they are only doing this as a "reference" implementation.
- AznHisoka 14y agoWhen I first read this, I thought this said "PG obsolescence is obsolete"
- pjmlp 14y agoThis is quite true. My parents are still using a desktop system from 2002 for all their stuff, and it still working quite well. This is the problem most OEMs are facing nowadays, as there this no need to upgrade every few years like it used to be.
- farinasa 14y agoSoftware and games have traditionally driven obsolescence. Now that software is shifting toward efficiency, remote processing, and web based interfaces, we don't need the power as much anymore. It was easy to double the processing requirements of software when we were at a low exponent of moore's law, but now that is looked at as poor development. We're able to do more with less code. Also, since facebook and other web services have diluted the demographic with people who mostly browse the web, the demand for power has waned. However, I am annoyed with all the posts asserting that desktops are dead. This is far from true. Gamers will not give up their desktops. For power uses, a laptop just won't support 4 1080p monitors. I personally prefer having a desktop so I don't have to mess with docking/plugging in my laptop to a ton of cables when the desktop does a better job anyway. The desktop as serves as my media consumption station and is connected to the TV.
- keithpeter 14y agoLet's turn this thread on its head Does anyone think a desktop PC with a 20 year life is possible now? What kind of design?
- duaneb 14y ago> Does anyone think a desktop PC with a 20 year life is possible now? What kind of design? Probably not, I think hardware still moves too fast for it. A current PC might serve as a media center for that long, though.
- JackC 14y agoIf nothing else, I think power consumption is a dealbreaker for a 20-year desktop PC. In (say) five years, there will be an iPhone with the same specs, and then you'll be running a desktop PC for 15 years at 100 times the power consumption for no reason. A good analogy is the way otherwise perfectly-good CRTs disappeared so quickly in favor of relatively expensive and low-contrast flat-panels. I'm using extreme numbers, but at that timescale even small efficiency increases will make it worth upgrading, and efficiency increases are a huge focus right now. The place to look for a 20-year computer is probably the same place they are now -- embedded systems with minimal power consumption and ample specs for the limited job they're designed for. E.g., cars.
- keithpeter 14y agoInteresting view which I had not thought of previously in quite that way. Devil's advocate: My old workstation has a 440w power supply but uses much less than that most of the time. A small percentage of the total electrical power that my house uses. What pressure is there to switch the workstation for a more efficient PC?
- greedo 14y agoDepends on OS developments. My 2006 Mac Pro is not supported under Mountain Lion, but it's still an excellent machine; 4 cores @ 2.66Ghz, 32GB of memory, and 6TB of disk. GigE, FireWire, USB, DVD/CDRom. I see no reason other than PC envy to upgrade to a different system. Eventually Apple will stop releasing security updates for Lion, and then I'll have to consider moving to a Linux distro. Short of a hardware failure I figure I'll get another 4-6 years out of it. Replacement parts for Mac Pros suck in price, but I bet I can find what I need on eBay. Heck, my system appears to be worth less than $500 according to my last search.
- __alexs 14y agoAccording to cpubenchmark.net the Nehalem Core i7-920 in (from November 2008) mentioned in the article has about half the performance of the Ivy Bridge Core i7-3770K released in April. In 2004 the best we had was Pentium 4's which were around 8x slower than the i7-920 that came 4 years later.
- FilterJoe 14y agoFor those who don't game or edit videos, this has been true for about 8 years. I retired my 2004 1GB RAM Dell desktop in 2012 and still keep it as a backup. The ever increasing speed of browsers and the shift of my work from the desktop to the cloud kept my system operating at the same speed it did 8 years ago - not blazing fast, but good enough. I expect my Sandy Bridge replacement system to go another 7-10 years before I replace it.
- adsr 14y agoI'm not sure I agree with this fully. There are compromises made in software as a result of lacking resources, with these resources now available some of these compromises can be avoided. For example, lets keep more resources in memory at all times, lets use more resource hungry algorithms that just was not feasible before, etc.
- rhinosix 14y agoThe desktop PC is almost obsolete. We spent a lot of time making PCs powerful. Then we spent more time to shrink them in size. Now they're just components to be combined with other hardware to make new tech. PCs, smart phones, tablets have pretty much run their course. What excites me is that it’s anyone’s game to build the next hardware. And we're not going to just seeing one new technology being built - we have the tools to branch off into all sorts of hardware - 3D printers, wearable computers, robotics, home automation, autonomous vehicles, biotechnology. Personally the only thing I need a powerful desktop PC for is video editing. For everything else - writing, drawing, communications, there’s no reason I should be chained to a desk for the sake of power. All I need is a basic HUD, LEAP motion and a virtual keyboard, which aren’t too far off. If I need to do something intensive I can just tell my desktop or a network to get to work and send me back the results. The idea of having to sit down at a desk and look at a flat panel, or being crippled by a half-assed mobile device seems antiquated.
- steveh73 14y agoI would say you're right for most cases. But not for gamers or "power users": * Game developers constantly up the ante. Try playing Battlefield 3 at 2560x1440 on Ultra on your 2008 PC and see how you go, if it even starts at all. * Virtualisation has resulted in consolidation (for me at least). Whereas I might have had to keep around a Windows box to do testing, now I just fire up a VM on my laptop.
- johngalt 14y agoCPU obsolescence OTOH everything else has been playing catch up. Disk, Network, Bus etc... Sure my CPU has hit the ceiling, but it spends 95% of its time idle anyway. Broadband five years ago was probably a 3-5Mbps link, and storage was a 7200rpm platter. Now broadband is 20mbps and storage is an SSD.
- Axsuul 14y agoYou also have to factor in that life expectancy of these machines. Usually processors last about 5 years and by the time that happens you're probably going to want to get the latest which will most likely be a different socket and require a new motherboard. Furthermore, PC enthusiasts and gamers will never be satisfied. These folk live for the next hardware releases to get even the tiniest gain on their overclocks or go from 2x AA to 4x AA. The PC enthusiast community is a force to be reckoned with. Don't believe me? Just check out the plethora of forums out there and see how active they are. I don't see that going away anytime soon.
- fjorder 14y agoThe relentless evolution of the PC was driven largely by PC gaming. In the 90's and early 2000's you could rely on the fact that a PC bought one year would struggle with games made the following year and be incapable of playing at least some games made 2-3 years later. As such, gamers eagerly adopted new hardware, overclocked, overspent by factors of 2 or 3 in the vain hope that it would buy them a few extra months (when in fact it was more sensible to buy a cheaper PC and upgrade more often). Then a funny thing happened. The video game market outgrew the movie market. It started making financial sense to invest tens of millions in the development of a single game. The cost of the content (i.e. character designs, level designs, script, voice acting, motion capture, etc.) far outstripped the cost of coding the engine. It became a complete no-brainer to port games to as many platforms as possible to maximize your audience. The corollary to this is that it became necessary to design games such that it was possible to port them to as many platforms as possible. That meant that most developers stopped exclusively developing for one platform and instead started designing for them all. While you can always tack on some superficial eye-candy on when the hardware supports it, games could not be designed to have basic gameplay requiring more resources than the slowest platform was capable of. Thus, consoles became an anchor that brought the relentless march of PC game requirements to a screeching halt. The Xbox360 and PS3, not to mention the Wii, are handily out-performed by today's desktops by a large degree. Mobile phones are poised to pass them within a couple of years! However, the games you can play on a PC are largely identical to the console versions. Sure, there are some improved graphics, additional content, etc., but these differences are superficial. In fact, if your hardware isn't the latest and greatest, most games can simply scale back the eye-candy to maintain performance. Even PC-only developers, such as Blizzard, have recognized that they must build games with conservative minimum requirements in today's market. The end result is that PC gamers can run new games with only superficial inferiority to what the latest generation of desktop hardware is capable of. They no longer need to upgrade their desktops. At least, they won't until the next generation of consoles arrive. When that happens there will be many new games designed with greatly increased resources in mind and a big wave of desktop upgrades will ensue. In the end, PC obsolescence isn't really dead. It's just quantized differently.
- ableal 14y agoDennard scaling: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_H._Dennard http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_H._Dennard It's about the shrinking of MOSFETS that happened over the 35 years since he wrote about it. My electronics textbooks mentioned the scaling, but did not make this named attribution (perhaps just a bibliographic reference).