3 ms·
If they were science then the exact cause of the disease would be known, instead only correlations can be found Again, your definition of science is too strict
by vacri 14y ago
If they were science then the exact cause of the disease would be known, instead only correlations can be found
Again, your definition of science is too strict. Do you really think the known faulty model of the atom was 'not science'? We didn't exactly know how the atom was pieced together, yet we had a theory that was best fit. The idea that a theory has to be an absolutely perfect fit for it to be 'science' is garbage. Case studies do form part of science in that properly done, they represent our best informed knowledge on the matter.
Also, cataloguing is definitely science. Science is about trying to collect information that is as true as humanly possible, and catalogues definitely fall into that basket.
But in particular, I find it weird that you consider taxonomy as 'not science', but the periodic table as 'science'. These two things are one and the same: a human-ordered list of natural phenomenon. We chose the way we arranged the elements in the periodic table, just like we choose the way we arrange species in taxonomy - each list being grouped in a way that makes the information more digestible to us.
- lutusp 14y ago>> If they were science then the exact cause of the disease would be known, instead only correlations can be found > Again, your definition of science is too strict. Unless that level of strictness exists, then astrology becomes science. Here's my proof -- I have a cure for the common cold. My cure is to shake a dried gourd over the patient until he gets better. My cure always works, so it's science. I deserve a Nobel Prize for my breakthrough. A real scientist would identify the flaw in my thinking (confusion of a simple correlation with a cause-effect relationship), but isn't he being, in your words, "too strict"?. > Do you really think the known faulty model of the atom was 'not science'? You're clouding the issue. A faulty model is science if it can be tested and potentially falsified. A faulty model that cannot be tested and falsified isn't. > The idea that a theory has to be an absolutely perfect fit for it to be 'science' is garbage. Be that as it may, no one has said this. In fact, science never produces truth, only tentative survivors of falsification. > Also, cataloguing is definitely science. No, observation -- description -- is not science. The science threshold is crossed when someone offers a testable explanation for the description.
- ars 14y agoThe model of the atom was testable - that's how they knew it was faulty in the first place. > Science is about trying to collect information that is as true as humanly possible No, that's history. Science is about collecting reasons why things happen, or at least the exact cause effect relationship. It is NOT about collecting "what happened". Simply recording what happened in the past is history. > These two things are one and the same: a human-ordered list of natural phenomenon. Not even close. Human ordered? The periodic table is not human ordered. The periodic table is fundamental to the structure of the universe. Taxonomy simply records that this thing happens to be related to this. The relationships are historical accidents, not fundamental properties. I'm quite surprised that you think the periodic table is human ordered. That shows a very large gap in your physics knowledge. If you skipped physics it's possible you were never exposed to how science should really be done, and all your experience is with what they call "soft sciences".
- vacri 14y agoThe way the periodic table is arranged depends on choices made by humans. It could just as easily be a simple list (your first description was 'all elements nothing between') with no groupings. What distinguishes elements is the number of protons - the choice to then arrange the periodic table by other attributes is a human one, just like the choice to label creatures with six legs 'insects' is a human one. and all your experience is with what they call "soft sciences" Ah, the meat of the problem. You're prejudiced against disciplines outside of physics.
- ars 14y ago> the choice to then arrange the periodic table by other attributes is a human one No it's not. The arrangement is determined by the structure of the atom - specifically the electron orbital. I'm assuming you didn't know this? It's not arbitrary at all, elements in the same column are very similar chemically, and can take each others place in many chemical reactions. > Ah, the meat of the problem. You're prejudiced against disciplines outside of physics. Prejudiced? Really? If you are going to practice science you have to do it properly, physics does, so do many other disciplines. Some don't. It's not because they are evil - they have no other choice, they do as good a job as possible with the limitations they have. I don't hold it against them, but at the same time they don't have the same status as those that do, the results from those disciplines can never be considered definitive. And for many of them, it's not science, it's history. And you appear not to even know any physics, and so you think everything is like what you know, and have no idea how it can be when done properly. It's a form of the Dunning–Kruger effect - you don't even realize what you don't know, so you think everyone doesn't know.