4 ms·

A while ago I uninstalled that horribly annoying GitLens and have been using external tools ever since. I don't want ads in my IDE and I'll uninstall the whole

A while ago I uninstalled that horribly annoying GitLens and have been using external tools ever since. I don't want ads in my IDE and I'll uninstall the whole IDE if that's what it takes. Maybe Edamagit will make me use git from within VSCode again.

anonzzzies 1y ago
Yep. Gitlens is a very annoying thing. Not sure why people put up with it.
- budding2141 1y ago
  Probably just got used to it. It was IMO very good plugin 5 years ago or so before all the ads etc.
- nsonha 1y ago
  It makes selectively stash/peeking/applying etc easier. Their flagship feature, the hover popup to reveal original commit/PR that you can click on is usefe for investigation. Maybe vscode has these built-in by now? Using the Gitless fork so not that annoying.
  - RaoulP 1y ago
    > Maybe vscode has these built-in by now? Yes, the blame feature is built-in now, with pop-up and all.
    - pinoy420 1y ago
      [dead]
- WorldMaker 1y ago
  A lot of it was first-mover advantage. It was the first VS Code plugin to provide a lot of the in-place information that it did, and at first it was unobtrusive and just did the one job well. It only started becoming truly annoying when it became a GitKraken product designed to sell more GitKraken products. Now that VS Code has more of those features built in and there are alternatives the first mover advantage keeps the extension sticky because people don't feel pressure to learn about the built-in features or because people don't want to learn about alternative extensions because "the tool I already know is annoying but is fine".
nextaccountic 1y ago
Well it's free software and open source, right? https://github.com/gitkraken/vscode-gitlens/blob/main/LICENSE https://github.com/gitkraken/vscode-gitlens/blob/main/LICENS... Eventually someone will fork it just to remove the ads
- artemisart 1y ago
  Gitless is this fork https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=maattdd.gitless https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=maattdd.... it's not updated but still works well.
RaoulP 1y ago
Funny, I just uninstalled it yesterday. I only used it for the automatic blame behind the cursor, but I just learned that that is built-in to VS Code (something like “toggle blame decorator”). The built-in one is faster too.
- norman784 1y ago
  TIL blame is builtin in VS Code, thanks for sharing, I had GitLens just for the blame, never used another feature.
- SketchySeaBeast 1y ago
  I just found it - it's "Git > Blame > Editor Decoration: Enabled" and holy is it so much faster. I love every time I can replace an extension with native functionality.
- lbussell 1y ago
  The “compare references” feature is nice.
- deleted 1y ago
  [deleted]
- oldandboring 1y ago
  Interesting. I've been using Gitlens for years without issue. Today I tried the built-in blame decorations and I found they were so responsive and fast that they were distracting. With Gitlens there's a delay before the decoration appears on a line, so if you're moving your cursor quickly around between lines you don't actually get a blame decoration until you've rested there for a few seconds; with the built-in functionality it pops right up as soon as the line focuses so if you go from line to line, there's a lot of activity in your field of view which makes it harder for me to concentrate on the code. As an adjustment, for now, I'm sticking with the built-in functionality but enabling only the status bar display, whose template I modified to include the commit message and date.
  - Iwan-Zotow 1y ago
baxuz 1y ago
Is there any plugin that has worktree support like gitlens?

anonzzzies 1y ago

Yep. Gitlens is a very annoying thing. Not sure why people put up with it.

budding2141 1y ago
Probably just got used to it. It was IMO very good plugin 5 years ago or so before all the ads etc.
nsonha 1y ago
It makes selectively stash/peeking/applying etc easier. Their flagship feature, the hover popup to reveal original commit/PR that you can click on is usefe for investigation. Maybe vscode has these built-in by now? Using the Gitless fork so not that annoying.
- RaoulP 1y ago
  > Maybe vscode has these built-in by now? Yes, the blame feature is built-in now, with pop-up and all.
  - pinoy420 1y ago
    [dead]
WorldMaker 1y ago
A lot of it was first-mover advantage. It was the first VS Code plugin to provide a lot of the in-place information that it did, and at first it was unobtrusive and just did the one job well. It only started becoming truly annoying when it became a GitKraken product designed to sell more GitKraken products. Now that VS Code has more of those features built in and there are alternatives the first mover advantage keeps the extension sticky because people don't feel pressure to learn about the built-in features or because people don't want to learn about alternative extensions because "the tool I already know is annoying but is fine".

nextaccountic 1y ago

Well it's free software and open source, right? https://github.com/gitkraken/vscode-gitlens/blob/main/LICENSE https://github.com/gitkraken/vscode-gitlens/blob/main/LICENS... Eventually someone will fork it just to remove the ads

artemisart 1y ago
Gitless is this fork https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=maattdd.gitless https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=maattdd.... it's not updated but still works well.

RaoulP 1y ago

Funny, I just uninstalled it yesterday. I only used it for the automatic blame behind the cursor, but I just learned that that is built-in to VS Code (something like “toggle blame decorator”). The built-in one is faster too.

norman784 1y ago
TIL blame is builtin in VS Code, thanks for sharing, I had GitLens just for the blame, never used another feature.
SketchySeaBeast 1y ago
I just found it - it's "Git > Blame > Editor Decoration: Enabled" and holy is it so much faster. I love every time I can replace an extension with native functionality.
lbussell 1y ago
The “compare references” feature is nice.
deleted 1y ago
[deleted]
oldandboring 1y ago
Interesting. I've been using Gitlens for years without issue. Today I tried the built-in blame decorations and I found they were so responsive and fast that they were distracting. With Gitlens there's a delay before the decoration appears on a line, so if you're moving your cursor quickly around between lines you don't actually get a blame decoration until you've rested there for a few seconds; with the built-in functionality it pops right up as soon as the line focuses so if you go from line to line, there's a lot of activity in your field of view which makes it harder for me to concentrate on the code. As an adjustment, for now, I'm sticking with the built-in functionality but enabling only the status bar display, whose template I modified to include the commit message and date.
- Iwan-Zotow 1y ago

baxuz 1y ago

Is there any plugin that has worktree support like gitlens?