6 ms·
"Paying $12 to store a gigabyte of data for 100 years" I'm not sure what kind of organisation I'd actually trust to store data for that length of time - a comm
by arethuza 14y ago
"Paying $12 to store a gigabyte of data for 100 years"
I'm not sure what kind of organisation I'd actually trust to store data for that length of time - a commercial organisation is probably going to be more effective at providing service but what commercial organisation would you trust to provide consistent service for 100 years? A Swiss bank perhaps? Governments of stable countries are obviously capable of this (clearly they store data for much longer times) but aren't set up to provide customer service.
- sspiff 14y agoExactly. I doubt Amazon will be around for another century, but even if they do survive, their services won't be the same for that long...
- zach 14y agoYeah, I'm kind of wondering the same thing. It's certainly the kind of timeframe that changes your perspective. Maybe a tiny bit of Danny Hillis rubbed off on me from working at Applied Minds (man, I sure hope so!) Because as we answer issues of cost and availability, a logical thing to wonder is "how long can I really depend on it though?" As quickly as cloud services (where "lifetimes" are measured at six years) have entered our economy, that's a question begging to be answered. Amazon at least seems to be an "eventually durable" datastore, though. Meaning that if you are told in the future that it will go offline, you have an excellent chance to make other suitable arrangements. Say there's a 0.01% chance of this product being discontinued next year, up to a 10% chance 5 years from now. I have to think there will almost certainly be other services you can move your data to, on similar terms, for a long time. That's assuming you're around at all, and nothing reeeeeally bad happens even so. Making data last after your death (or even after you stop paying!) is a lot harder in this environment, and achieving true 100-year durability is a tough nut indeed. I like your bank idea, since the preservation of a bank account is just a specialized simple case of data preservation. Data preservation seems rather more reliable when the data is directly attached to money. Then again, maybe banks themselves are on their way out for this purpose — Dropbox could become the new safety-deposit box. But there are 100-year domain registrations, after all. Maybe we're ready for organizations to at least offer 100-year storage, too.
- ghshephard 14y agoAnd, since you mentioned Danny Hills, it's also worth mentioning that (ironically?) Jeff Bezos is one of the principle supporters of http://longnow.org/clock/ http://longnow.org/clock/.
- arethuza 14y agoAnd that makes me think of Anathem and the potential issues around long-term data storage that is capable of surviving through falls of civilisations and/or sacks of storage areas.
- duskwuff 14y agoThat's no coincidence -- Anathem was inspired by the Long Now Foundation and their 10,000 Year Clock project.
- arethuza 14y agoProbably what would be required is an array of arrays of separate storage providers and services providing "RAID" on top of these storage providers - and you won't want to trust any of these you'll want a few of them... (hence the array of arrays).
- thebigshane 14y agoWow, does any service offer something like that? RAID6 would be pretty interesting across s3, google drive, (hrmm, what else? skydrive? rsync.net?)
- wvs 14y agohttps://tahoe-lafs.org/ https://tahoe-lafs.org/
- rsync 14y agoleastauthority.com (the Tahoe LAFS folks) are trying to promote the concept of "RAIC" (C=Cloud). I'm not sure what the status of the project is, though... FWIW, we are happy to support this kind of use, and see our customers doing it in an ad-hoc way every day. We have s3cmd in our environment, and support it. As soon as their is a glacier complement to s3cmd we will put that into place as well, although with the strange traffic and retrieval pricing, I'm not sure how useful folks will find it ...
- wheels 14y ago> Governments of stable countries are obviously capable of this I don't consider that obvious. I live in Berlin, the capital of what most would consider a stable country, but my apartment (which is even older) has been a part of 5 different countries in the last 100 years (German Empire, Weinmar Republic, Nazi Germany, East Germany and finally, the Federal Republic of Germany).
- arethuza 14y agoSorry, what I meant by "stable" there is countries that have been relatively stable for a few hundred years and seem reasonably likely to continue that integrity for at least a century or so. Of course, predicting future stability is complete guesswork!
- bobsy 14y agoWe are straying a bit off topic here. I don't think any country has been stable for a "few" hundred years. A few is 3. This is before the US was founded. I would say a stable country is one which has had a legit democracy for 70 or so years and doesn't share a border with a non-democratic / non-legit-democratic state. These two points suggests its unlikely to have a revolution or be invaded any time soon. Of course, if you look at the UK governments track record with IT.. you wouldn't trust it. I would say the same with the US, especially in concern with data security.
- arethuza 14y agoI think I could argue that England has been pretty stable since at least the end of the Civil War - which is 360 years ago. A lot of the institutions that form part of the current UK go back an awful lot further than that. [NB I'm not English]
- dredmorbius 14y agoI'll reject your democratic requirement out of hand, as democracies haven't proven particularly stable. There was that trial-run in Athens which lasted 501 years (508 - 7 BCE, with interruptions). Other than a few small/outlying instances (most notably the Althing in Iceland, it didn't re-emerge until the short-lived Corsican Republic (1755), and of course, the United States (1776). Japan (660 BCE) and China (221 BCE) have both had feudal / bureaucratic governments exhibiting very high levels of stability. While dynasties and eras are marked, the overall states persisted largely intact.
- andyjohnson0 14y agoThere are some pretty old commercial organisations out there. One list [1] has several that have existed for over 1000 years. Whether they would be capable of storing data (or would even be interested in doing so) is hard to say, but there have at least demonstrated that long-term organisational continuity is possible, and that presumably requires some organisational 'memory'. Having a long history obviously isn't a predictor of future stability. According to the Long Now Foundation site [2], a Japanese company that existed since 578CE went bust in 2007. [1] http://www.bizaims.com/content/the-100-oldest-companies-world http://www.bizaims.com/content/the-100-oldest-companies-worl... [2] http://blog.longnow.org/02008/06/13/the-100-oldest-companies/ http://blog.longnow.org/02008/06/13/the-100-oldest-companies...
- reddit_clone 14y agoHow about Catholic church? That has lasted a couple of Millennia!
- mturmon 14y agoBut, it has not been as stable as you might think. During the 1300s, the popes resided in France. As recently as 1870, during the Italian unification, the church was stripped of its power to govern Rome after an armed confrontation between armies at the gates of Rome ("XX Septembre"). During this period, the Pope (the ninth Pius) seriously considered fleeing Italy.
- andyjohnson0 14y agoAccording to Wikipedia the Vatican Library has existed since 1481. Doubtful that many people here would have material that would interest them though.
- brlewis 14y agoA foundation or trust. For example, the Nobel Foundation has operated since 1900 without appearing in danger of closing. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Prize#Nobel_Foundation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nobel_Prize#Nobel_Foundation You could have a foundation established to choose and pay an array of commercial organizations that do the archiving.
- peterwwillis 14y agoThe Royal Mint has existed for 1,100 years. That's pretty much the most stable government-owned business-like entity I can find. The Stora Kopparberg mining company has existed since it was granted a charter from King Magnus IV in 1347. A few banks tend to last for a long time [1]. Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena has existed for about 540 years. Beretta, the italian firearms company, has existed for 486 years (and has been family owned the entire time). East and West Jersey were owned by a land proprietorship for around 340 years starting from King Charles II bestowing the land to his brother James in 1664. [2] At first I thought multinational corporations would be more stable because they could move from land to land to avoid wars and such. But apparently they haven't lasted nearly as long as their single-nation counterparts. The Knights Templar were granted a multi-national tax exemption by Pope Innocent II in 1139, and lasted almost 200 years until most of their leadership was killed off in 1307. The Dutch East India Trading Company was one of the first [modern] multinational corporations, spanning almost 200 years from 1602-1798. However, the longest-lasting companies have been family owned and operated. [3] [4] It appears most all companies that have lasted a long time are due to two factors: dealing in basic goods and services that all humans need, and looking ahead to the future to change with the times. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_banks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_oldest_banks [2] https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:nYQU4NpfD74J:www.nj.gov/state/darm/pdf/proprietors.pdf+&hl=en&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESgS8CJzRjFAe_zifP62t-tnfWolI3pKTU6Ij3Yq4I-IfyTH36v_gb0ijdHNTVtmCWKwDlJeRCsS4agk6EAglZNAEPvLJFI05CkHU-ZA0ylLQZcopWzzRtxTQL2IGU8fV5Rb8Fny&sig=AHIEtbRmESZSQyrQ2urj7IR7FLlXWu4-DQ https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:nYQU4NpfD74J:... [3] http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2008-05-14/centuries-old-family-businesses-share-their-secretsbusinessweek-business-news-stock-market-and-financial-advice http://www.businessweek.com/stories/2008-05-14/centuries-old... [4] http://www.bizaims.com/content/the-100-oldest-companies-world http://www.bizaims.com/content/the-100-oldest-companies-worl...
- philwelch 14y agoHudson's Bay Company is 342 years old and running.
- smacktoward 14y agoIf you really want the organization to survive for a long term, you need to make it a religion. If you can figure out a way to convince a few dozen people every decade that the best way to glorify God is to isolate themselves off somewhere maintaining your archival data, you'll be set for centuries.
- philwelch 14y agoOne could say monks have historically been the ones maintaining archival data.