3 ms·
Shall we stop there, or shall we test my claim? You're missing my point. It's not about 'stopping there'. It's about robust observation. The best observations
by vacri 14y ago
Shall we stop there, or shall we test my claim?
You're missing my point. It's not about 'stopping there'. It's about robust observation. The best observations we can make are treated as correct until we can come up with something better. We used the known wrong model of the atom for a long time, but it was the best we had, and we learned a lot in doing so. Your "shall we stop there" argument is utter strawman nonsense, and not what I am arguing. Robust observation allows someone coming along later with better info, because it makes the observation more robust. I have no idea where you pulled this "stop as soon as a claim is made" crap from.
So you're saying that classification like taxonomy, the periodic table, and even SI units are 'not science', because these things are not due to a tested claim? If they're pseudoscience (as you are implying they must be, since they're all just 'claims') then isn't all science that uses them inherently suspect as a result?
Ideas must be compared to reality, and if reality disagrees, they must be discarded.
Which doesn't contradict what I said. Robust observation agrees with this sentiment exactly.
You're trying to paint me as a crazy pseudoscientist, but you're working from a faulty perception of what science is.
Here's another example: in medicine, there's a lot of work done on case studies for diseases with a low number of victims. It's just not viable to run double-blind studies with such low n, and repeat those studies until you find an answer. Case studies are a way of doing robust observation: "In previously similar situations, this was done, and this happened". It's not perfect, but it's a hell of a lot better than nothing. It's following scientific principles of do something, observe, report faithfully.
Similarly, the Mars exploration robots are out there looking at stuff for the first time. They are exploratory science. What would you have them do to make them fit your narrow vision of science - launch a robot into empty space to provide a control group representing the 'null hypothesis'?
- ars 14y agoCorrect, taxonomy and SI units are not science, but they are not psudo-science either. The periodic table is though - it has an actual testable criteria: That this is the full list of elements, and there are no "in between" ones. Observations are part of science, but they are not science in and of themself. Just because you used one doesn't make your science "tainted" as you seem to think. But to declare that the observation is the complete package is wrong. Those case studies are called "case studies" for a very good reason: They are not science. If they were science then the exact cause of the disease would be known, instead only correlations can be found - this can lead to science, so it's part of science, but it's not the end result, it's a lower level category. (I hate using the word science this way, but I guess it makes my distinction clear.) There is no such thing as "exploratory science" unless you mean the science of how to design an exploration. What the rover is doing is called cataloging. From a catalog you can gain scientific conclusions, but not directly. For example you can see that this type of rock is found in this situation - then you find another location and predict the type of rock. We want to know "what is on mars". Just because that's not a science in and of itself doesn't make it bad. If it were science you could develop rules and laws from it. And maybe we will - like ideas on planetary formation. But right now the rover is doing history - we want to know "what happened" not "what fundamental rule can we learn". Again, this isn't a bad thing. But it's not at the same level as hard science.
- vacri 14y agoIf they were science then the exact cause of the disease would be known, instead only correlations can be found Again, your definition of science is too strict. Do you really think the known faulty model of the atom was 'not science'? We didn't exactly know how the atom was pieced together, yet we had a theory that was best fit. The idea that a theory has to be an absolutely perfect fit for it to be 'science' is garbage. Case studies do form part of science in that properly done, they represent our best informed knowledge on the matter. Also, cataloguing is definitely science. Science is about trying to collect information that is as true as humanly possible, and catalogues definitely fall into that basket. But in particular, I find it weird that you consider taxonomy as 'not science', but the periodic table as 'science'. These two things are one and the same: a human-ordered list of natural phenomenon. We chose the way we arranged the elements in the periodic table, just like we choose the way we arrange species in taxonomy - each list being grouped in a way that makes the information more digestible to us.
- lutusp 14y ago>> If they were science then the exact cause of the disease would be known, instead only correlations can be found > Again, your definition of science is too strict. Unless that level of strictness exists, then astrology becomes science. Here's my proof -- I have a cure for the common cold. My cure is to shake a dried gourd over the patient until he gets better. My cure always works, so it's science. I deserve a Nobel Prize for my breakthrough. A real scientist would identify the flaw in my thinking (confusion of a simple correlation with a cause-effect relationship), but isn't he being, in your words, "too strict"?. > Do you really think the known faulty model of the atom was 'not science'? You're clouding the issue. A faulty model is science if it can be tested and potentially falsified. A faulty model that cannot be tested and falsified isn't. > The idea that a theory has to be an absolutely perfect fit for it to be 'science' is garbage. Be that as it may, no one has said this. In fact, science never produces truth, only tentative survivors of falsification. > Also, cataloguing is definitely science. No, observation -- description -- is not science. The science threshold is crossed when someone offers a testable explanation for the description.
- ars 14y ago
- lutusp 14y ago> Robust observation agrees with this sentiment exactly. Observation, robust or not, isn't science. If it was, I could say that there are brights spots in the night sky and that observation would count as science. It isn't science until I try to explain what the spots are, and accept a possible falsification of my explanation. All observations are preliminaries to science. All untested explanations are also preliminaries to science. Science is when an explanation for observations collides with reality, with an attempt to validate an explanation. > You're trying to paint me as a crazy pseudoscientist, Not at all -- your words, not mine. > you're working from a faulty perception of what science is. I didn't invent the definition of science, and I'm simply repeating the definition that has come to be accepted, by consensus, among scientists, and in courts of law. Guess how society keeps pseudoscience out of classrooms, for example, "Creation Science"? They do it by asking scientists what science is, discovering that untested claims and observations don't count, and acting accordingly. In McLean v. Arkansas Board of Education (http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/mclean-v-arkansas.html http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/mclean-v-arkansas.html), Creation Science was determined not to be science because it failed to meet these scientific requirements: "It is guided by natural law; It has to be explanatory by reference to natural law; It is testable against the empirical world; Its conclusions are tentative, i.e. are not necessarily the final word; and It is falsifiable." Observation doesn't meet these requirements (one cannot falsify an observation). Attempting to explain observations, and accepting falsifications, does. > So you're saying that classification like taxonomy, the periodic table, and even SI units are 'not science', because these things are not due to a tested claim? No, they aren't science because they only describe, they don't explain, and descriptions cannot be falsified -- that's reserved to explanations. This, by the way, is why there is so little science in psychology -- it's mostly description, with rare attempts to explain. For example, Asperger's was accepted as a real mental illness based only on description. It's now being abandoned, again based only on description (i.e. the earlier description described far too many people). But at no point did anyone try to explain Asperger's in scientific terms.
- vacri 14y agoAll of the things in your 'courts of law' routine work with case studies. Ironically, the major caveat with case studies is that they are not considered the 'final word' (#4 in your court requirements), yet you're demanding that science doesn't exist until the final word is known. Case studies are falsifiable (which I presume is your sticking point) because later observations can counter them. The context of your court points is that creationism does not allow later observations to counter it. Your own court-appointed words are not as strict as you think. This, by the way, is why there is so little science in psychology You're also showing prejudice here, and with a profoundly unscientific single anecdotal point used to tarnish an entire field. Psychology is a vast field and yes, there is a lot of shoddy science in some areas, but to say that there's little [good] science in it is just plain wrong. There are thousands of explainable, testable theories in psychology.