7 ms·
Behavior of young children in a situation simulating entrapment in refrigerators
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoa higher rate of success being associated with fewer years of education attained by mother and father combined. Tell me more - is that statistically significant? Causes? Related to Reading age? The bit that worries me is the percentage of children who locked in the fridge just waited and cried.
- troels 14y agoIf they cry loud enough, it may not be the worst strategy.
- JonnieCache 14y agoAren't fridges pretty airtight though? Isn't that the whole point here? If so, then crying loud and long is at best a hell of a bet. I'd be willing to bet that fridges are pretty good sound insulators. The inside is sort of suspended IIRC.
- ColinWright 14y agoAirtight does not imply soundproof. Well-insulated is better correlated, and fridges do tend to be that as well.
- JonnieCache 14y agoI was thinking more along the lines of screaming being a great way to use up all your oxygen. That too is an assumption though...
- vacri 14y agoNot soundproof, but certainly sound-dampening. Quality speakers have an airhole to allow movement of air in and out of the box, for example.
- nitrogen 14y agoThough this is straying a bit from the topic at hand, I must point out that quality speakers employ a range of designs, from simple sealed designs, to the ported designs you mention, on up to folded or full-scale (built with cinder block walls[0]) subwoofer horns. The purpose of the port in ported designs is not just to allow movement of air, but to control the resonant frequency and Q-factor of the speaker. The individual dimensions, size, shape, and materials of quality speaker enclosures are all tuned to control resonance. To sum up, there's a lot more to it than "an airhole to allow movement of air." [0] I can't find the actual system I recall, but here is an older system with a similar design: http://www.burwenaudio.com/images/20000_WATT_HOME_HI-FI_0476.pdf http://www.burwenaudio.com/images/20000_WATT_HOME_HI-FI_0476...
- cellularmitosis 14y agoPut a microphone inside and outside the fridge. If the noise coming from inside the fridge is louder than the noise from outside the fridge, pop the hatch automatically. Not a viable solution for 1958x but today we are talking about a few dollars in electronics and an electromagnet.
- troels 14y agoI know the upvote is for this, but can I just say that that's a brilliant idea!
- nitrogen 14y agoYou could probably use a single mic and a volume threshold, rather than a volume comparison with the outside, unless enough sound from the outside of the fridge gets to the internal microphone to set it off (e.g. during an earthquake or extremely loud party).
- davidw 14y agoNot a viable solution today: the problem is not fridges in active use in houses, it's fridges in people's backyards/dumps/barns/whatever where they are no longer plugged into anything. More information on the problem: http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2586/is-it-impossible-to-open-a-refrigerator-door-from-the-inside http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2586/is-it-impossib...
- troels 14y agoA battery could presumably power it long after being unplugged. But you're right - That article basically states that the problem was solved in 1958, by replacing the mechanical latch with a magnetic door. Coincidentally this research was from 1958, so I assume there is a connection there. Thanks for posting that - It puts thing into perspective.
- slurgfest 14y agoCrying loud is a pretty good mammal trick for most situations other than an imminent predator-grabbing - being trapped in an airtight refrigerator is definitely an evolutionary edge case.
- 46Bit 14y agoAgreed. Although one option would be to require all two year old children to escape a refrigerator or die trying, in order to evolve out of this problem.
- slurgfest 14y agoPure speculation: could be that poor kids were more likely to have dealt with similar problems or even just to have dealt with similar levels of suffering, and therefore respond with a little more short-term resilience. Not like anyone can do follow-ups on this research any more.
- JonnieCache 14y agoMore idle speculation: self-reliance and/or initiative are inversely correlated with social class/socioeconomic status/whatever.
- berntb 14y ago>>Not like anyone can do follow-ups on this research any more. A modest proposal: Places like Syria seems to not only torture dissidents but also their children -- and the regime need cash because of all the sanctions. The Syrian Bath party was even inspired by the nazis, so there is precedent for getting experimental data. (Sorry about this, sometimes my humor disgusts me too.)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pygy_ 14y agoThe generalization of statistics is relatively recent development in science. AFAIK, it happened during the 50's and 60's, probably at a different pace in different disciplines.
- DEinspanjer 14y agoYeah, that was the big thing that made me wonder WTF. Really wish there was more data on that part of it. Wonder if any of the original experiment data or executors are still around.. :)
- JonnieCache 14y agoSomebody here must be able to get us the pdf... Or at least have a look at it and give us the lowdown.
- qohen 14y agoQuick FYI, if it matters: this is from 1958.
- nitrogen 14y agoIt would be good to add (1958) to the title -- I doubt such an experiment would fly today, and this presents a fascinating look back in history both at the state of experimental ethics and the development of modern refrigerator doors. The only experience I have with fridges so old is the one that my grandfather rotated 90 degrees and buried in his yard, to serve as a root cellar. I think the door may have had an actual lock on it, but can't recall; if so, this experiment studying door release mechanisms would make much more sense. Edit to add: It's possible the invention of magnetic weatherstripping has saved many lives.
- ColinWright 14y ago> It would be good to add (1958) to the title Won't fit in the 80 character limit.
- nitrogen 14y agoGet rid of the word "young", perhaps?
- ColinWright 14y agoNow too late, but even so, given the moderators' tendencies to change titles so they match exactly the article, even when the supplied title is significantly more informative, I've stopped trying to be helpful with titles.
- scarmig 14y agoThat (informal?) policy drives me fucking nuts. I had one submission awhile back with a fairly informative title for an article about the legal issues AirBnB was running into. The mods, in their everlasting wisdom, decided to change the title to match the article's. What was it? "DIY B&B" Oh, yeah, that's descriptive. I wouldn't say I have a huge flair for titles or anything, but mine was (a) not terrible and (b) definitely more useful in getting the point across. Rage.
- 14y ago
- dminor14 14y agoPretty disgusting, maybe we should drown them and burn them also to see how they react.
- melling 14y agoSomeone was trying to solve a real problem in 1958. In fact, children still die in refrigerators. I imagine in 54 years, people will look back at some of the stuff we do as primitive and barbaric.
- humbledrone 14y ago> Instead, the scientists designed a very small, rather dense, playhouse. It looked just like a normal kid's playhouse, except that it was the exact dimensions of the average home fridge. Not only that, the house was equipped with an infrared camera on the top, which took videos of the kid while they were inside, while at the same time keeping it dark, like it would be in a fridge with the door shut. It should also be noted that the scientists teamed up with a psychiatrist, a child psychologist, and the parents to agree on the length of time the child would be allowed to cry before they helped it out. Three minutes. [1] Hmm, three minutes of discomfort in a dark playhouse doesn't seem quite as bad as drowning or being burned alive. Especially when you consider the deaths that might be avoided as a result of the research. [1] http://scientopia.org/blogs/scicurious/2009/07/17/friday-weird-science-refridgerator-mothers-vs-refridgerator-kids/ http://scientopia.org/blogs/scicurious/2009/07/17/friday-wei...
- sp332 14y agoReplace "discomfort" with "trauma", especially once they find out that their parents heard them crying but decided not to come.
- pessimizer 14y agoNot quite the Tuskegee Experiment.
- 14y ago
- gjm11 14y agoHN article title should probably have (1958) appended to it. Incidentally, see http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2586/is-it-impossible-to-open-a-refrigerator-door-from-the-inside http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/2586/is-it-impossib... for a bit more on the subject.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoInteresting, that article claims that magnetic seals were invented well before 1958 but not adopted until 1958 when it was mandated by legislation.
- catastrophe 14y agoAnyone who can flag this submission, should.
- robotmay 14y agoFor what?
- robinhouston 14y agoThe paper is behind a paywall, but this 2009 Scientopia post has some more interesting details: http://scientopia.org/blogs/scicurious/2009/07/17/friday-weird-science-refridgerator-mothers-vs-refridgerator-kids/ http://scientopia.org/blogs/scicurious/2009/07/17/friday-wei... It sounds as though the ethical aspects of the experiment were considered pretty carefully, for example.
- rotskoff 14y ago201 children from 157 families. Ages 2,3,4,5. The "enclosure" was meant to look like a playhouse; some children were lured into it, but many wandered in on their own. It was 40x18X25 in. It was outfitted with a number of recording devices: video camera, infrared, sound.
- gregtour 14y agoAs someone who has lived in Fukushima Prefecture, I am going to dare and ask, can nuclear energy, fertilizer, and reverse osmosis save our souls? Shutting down computer, opening window, sitting outside.
- gregtour 14y agoJesus Christ, philosoraptor, hydrochronics, manana, pbr, manzanas, after apple picking, eclipse.
- afitnerd 14y ago"It was also influenced by the educational level of the parents, a higher rate of success being associated with fewer years of education attained by mother and father combined." This seems counterintuitive to me. A LOWER educational level of the parents correlated to a HIGHER rate of success of escape, it seems.
- pessimizer 14y agoLet it change your intuition. It will make you look at people differently.
- trentlott 14y agoIt's interesting how science works like that, right?
- egiva 14y agoI wonder how that statement is influenced by investigator bias - in the 1950's where "street smarts" (working class parents, working class background) somehow viewed socially as superior in these situations when compared with educated families?
- K2h 14y agoThis was the section of the article that caught my attention as well. My guess is when a child is use to being rescued or cared for after a very very short time, they learn quickly to do (or try) things themselves and not rely on parents, care givers, or others. I struggle with this notion in raising my own child. I want her to learn - be self sufficient and resourceful, but I don't want her to suffer for it, or not trust people.
- saalweachter 14y agoIt's also possible that some of the lower income children had already been stuck in a refrigerator while playing outside, and had practice at the task. Ten seconds to escape is pretty impressive!
- maked00 14y agoSince it was in the 50's we really have no idea just how statistically accurate this study is. For example, they may not have had a equal spread of income levels. Most of the participants may have been poor and there may have been only one or two high income families involved. Such a small sample would not give reliable results. However if the study did have an accurate cross sample of incomes, then perhaps the results indicate that some sort of education program is in order for children in well to do families.
- robotresearcher 14y ago> "Since it was in the 50's" Plenty of first-class science and engineering was done in the 1950s and before. The 50s produced hydrogen bombs, supersonic aircraft, and great advances in chemotherapy and computer science, for example. They were quite capable of doing an empirical study to a standard we would recognize.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- zuralski 14y agoI am very surprised nobody has picked up this line for discussion: " Success in escaping [..] was also influenced by the educational level of the parents, a higher rate of success being associated with fewer years of education attained by mother and father combined. " There's no attempt at explanation for this in the article itself.. Would it be safe to deduce that the more educated "you" are, the more passive (or "inactive") you are in the face of danger?