3 ms·
> The absence of a neocortex does not appear to preclude an organism from experiencing affective states. There's no basis for falsification, the claim revolves
by lutusp 14y ago
> The absence of a neocortex does not appear to preclude an organism from experiencing affective states.
There's no basis for falsification, the claim revolves around denying a negative, there's no testable positive claim, therefore it's not science. And saying "it's official", apart from replacing evidence with authority, adds nothing except to sound like law or politics rather than science.
- vacri 14y agoIt's denying a positive, not a negative. "Previously, it was thought you had to have a neocortex. Now, we see evidence that you don't". Corvids and Eastern Grey Parrots don't have a neocortex, and they still perform well on experiments we apply to other animals around the concept of consciousness. The sentence you're quoting is a triple negative, not a double negative, perhaps that's the problem.
- lutusp 14y ago> The sentence you're quoting is a triple negative, not a double negative, perhaps that's the problem. I see a double negative: "The absence of a neocortex does not appear to preclude an organism from experiencing affective states." The above relies on the negation of a negative state -- the absence of a neocortex. In any case, to refute the claim would require some heavy lifting -- an objective definition of consciousness, an objective measure of consciousness that somehow evades issues like the Turing test, and a handful of other obstacles. And consensus -- general agreement on the meaning of these terms. That's why it's philosophy.
- vacri 14y agopreclude is the third negative. edit: There are testable positive claims - things like the mirror test. Yes, it is hard to define consciousness, but dealing with things that are hard to define doesn't mean something 'is not science'. Like I said above, we worked for a century with a model of the atom that we knew was wrong, yet we did a lot of good science with it. People didn't run around saying 'oh, the atom is just philosophy', they accepted that there were shortcomings and took that in as part of their work.
- lutusp 14y ago> There are testable positive claims - things like the mirror test. Yes, but the problem with the mirror test (and all similar tests) is not the observation but the conclusion -- one in principle could program a computer to recognize itself in a mirror, but have no other properties we assume define "consciousness". On could in principle create a list of properties of consciousness, then have a devil's advocate program a robot to display all the required properties -- just to prove a point. In DARPA road races, robot cars manage to avoid each other and fixed obstacles, mimicking the behavior of human drivers. It's only a matter of time before a car will pass a sort of "Turing test" and be indistinguishable from a (sober) human driver, i.e. be "conscious". > dealing with things that are hard to define doesn't mean something 'is not science'. In fact, yes, that is a legitimate argument for calling something non-science. If independent observers cannot agree on their terms, if similarly equipped observers cannot draw the same conclusion from a given observation, this prevents the consensus on which science depends. Science is, after all, ultimately a shared, falsifiable theory about the world, therefore deconstructive post-modernism (the idea that all observations are subjective) cancels science. > People didn't run around saying 'oh, the atom is just philosophy' ... They had the right to do that until there were unambiguous observations, and testable theories about the observations, on which different observers could agree. Until then, atoms were philosophy. Aristotle once claimed that women were inferior to men because they had fewer teeth -- hard to believe but true. It remained philosophy until someone started counting teeth.