3 ms·
If it's your long term dream of fully replicating humans, it would be helpful to read Kant and similar philosophers to have a clear understanding of what consci
by dmix 14y ago
If it's your long term dream of fully replicating humans, it would be helpful to read Kant and similar philosophers to have a clear understanding of what consciousness is.
If it's not and the goal is just replicating and accelerating certain cognitive abilities, then it might not be super helpful and possibly disheartening (disheartening because of how much we lack full understanding of consciousness due to limitations of only being able to understand it via our own consciousness).
- rosser 14y agoMy undergraduate degree was in philosophy, with a concentration in philosophy of mind, and while I can't recommend highly enough taking the time to read through and learn from the sundry perspectives and takes we've had on consciousness throughout history, be warned that that way lies confusion and dragons. Kant certainly didn't know what consciousness was. He had some instructive things to say, and massively helped frame the debate for people who came later, but even present-day philosophers who have the benefit of modern science and technology to help in their investigation are no closer to pinning down how it is that meat can feel.
- aba_sababa 14y agoAbsolutely not. After 2500 years, Western philosophy has yet to achieve broad consensus on anything at all. Philosophers don't have a clue what consciousness is - they can barely even describe it without using utterly ambiguous words like "qualia" or "sense datum". The only way we'll ever be able to know anything about consciousness besides what's going on inside our own heads is for us to directly experience what's going on inside someone else's (or some animal's). Not until the Singularity, basically. I'm not going to hold my breath for that one.
- lutusp 14y ago> If it's your long term dream of fully replicating humans, it would be helpful to read Kant and similar philosophers to have a clear understanding of what consciousness is. From a scientific perspective, this elevates philosophy beyond anything reasonable. Philosophers have many things to say, but they tend not to be the kind of people who are trained to ask, "Is there an empirical, falsifiable test of my claim?"