2 ms·
My argument is more "if you can't solidly define the thought process, you can't definitively state that LLMs can NOT think". That doesn't mean I think they can
by simonw 1y ago
My argument is more "if you can't solidly define the thought process, you can't definitively state that LLMs can NOT think".
That doesn't mean I think they can think myself. I just get frustrated at the quality of discussion every time this topic comes up.
- keybored 1y agoIf you can’t solidly define your love for your wife/husband, you can’t definitely state that you couldn’t hypothetically love this bonobo that I have in my lab on the same level. If you zoom out enough they are virtually indistinguishable. > That doesn't mean I think they can think myself. I just get frustrated at the quality of discussion every time this topic comes up. You’re arguing for the potential of a ghost in a machine based on people not being able to answer hard philosophical questions behind human behavior and properties.[1] That’s a kind of Vulgar Theism quality of argumentation. [1] Not exclusively human. I’m sure killer whales can think.
- whilenot-dev 1y agoIsn't the thought process currently understood as a blend of deterministic & probabilistic decision-making and free will? So if LLMs lack the "free will" part, isn't that enough deductive reasoning to satisfy the argument "LLMs don't think"?