3 ms·
Why not pipe it over the internet? A few redundant ISPs at the endpoints should be as reliable as a private run of fiber or T1 lines or whatever bespoke solutio
by SoftTalker 1y ago
Why not pipe it over the internet? A few redundant ISPs at the endpoints should be as reliable as a private run of fiber or T1 lines or whatever bespoke solution they think they need?
- mschuster91 1y agoAs soon as it's on the general Internet, any ill-meaning enemy can just force the VPN endpoints offline by blasting them with junk traffic.
- stevenhuang 1y agoThat can be mitigated effectively in this case using an IP whitelist. All unrecognized traffic can simply be dropped.
- icehawk 1y ago...Until they switch to a bandwidth exhaustion attack.
- stevenhuang 1y agoTrue, saturating all routes to a host is quite feasible, but with sufficient redundancy (say with multiple PTP wireless links, which can be done quite cheaply) you'd have to knock the Internet out in such a huge area we'd be talking about WW3. There's no argument that a private line is ideal for critical infrastructure, but if they must make do, there are ways to make it work.
- mschuster91 1y agoPeople managed to shoot Wikipedia off the Internet as recently as 2019. Anyone not behind one of the major CDNs can be targeted and taken down. And bandwidth-exhausting a few routers in front of the target is certainly possible, it's just not profitable for cybercriminals - but for a nation-state? No problem at all to muster a few terabit/s of capacity for them.
- K0balt 1y agoDoing so sticks billions of transistors between A and B, all of which have to work perfectly billions of times a second. If you just run fiber, you need to put an amplifier in every 50km or so, other than that it’s all just buried glass. The fiber is already there, and it gives you guaranteed capacity, even during a major power outage. And it guarantees no one is changing out a switch or a router at a bad time, etc. It’s just a lot less to control and to go wrong.