3 ms·
How does a shameless "knock-off" hurt consumers? I own a knock-off Rolex and I enjoy it just fine.
by guelo 14y ago
How does a shameless "knock-off" hurt consumers? I own a knock-off Rolex and I enjoy it just fine.
- moskie 14y agoIt can hurt you if you were conned into paying a Rolex-level price, and/or thought you were buying an actual Rolex. And maybe you weren't, but I imagine plenty of people are.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoI think this (intentionally or not) points out some of why people want Apple to beat Samsung. Not just win, but beat Samsung. It ties in precisely with what the grandparent is saying. People want to choose sides and, for whatever god-forsaken reason, there are still people who haven't used it since 2.0 convinced that Android is massively inferior, and thus they see this as Apple beating a knock-off. But it's not, and anyone whose seen Samsung's sales figures knows that.
- moskie 14y agoI agree. And I think another issue here is that it isn't the case that Samsung attempts to con people into thinking they're buying an Apple device. Even if you get up in arms saying that Samsung/Android copied certain features from Apple, it would an entirely separate can of worms if people regularly bought Samsung devices, thinking they were buying an Apple one.
- ars 14y ago> or thought you were buying an actual Rolex He said Knock-off, not counterfeit. A knock-off looks like the original but does not falsely advertise itself as actually being the original.
- moskie 14y agoI guess this is just semantics, but look where this redirects to: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knock-off http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knock-off "Counterfeit consumer goods, commonly called knock-offs, are counterfeit or imitation products offered for sale."
- ars 14y agoI've seen that too, but it's sloppy writing. Knock-off: A copy, but doesn't use the name of the original. Counterfeit: A copy, that uses the name of the original. Fake: Doesn't work properly, or is copied only partly (for example using brass instead of gold), but claims to be original. Imitation: Uses cheaper materials, but is upfront about it. There are two attributes: Deception and Accuracy. Each combination of those two gets a name.
- aneth4 14y agoIf you value the status symbol of a Rolex (not I - I think they are tacky and ugly - sorry) fakes diminish that both for the producer and consumer. As another said, they also introduce the chance of fraud by intention or mistake. That said, I think overall fakes provide excellent advertising for the real thing and probably increase profits. Anything widely faked implies the real thing must be valuable.
- mikeash 14y agoFakes are only a problem if they're falsely advertised. If something says "Rolex" but it is not, then that's a major problem. This is why trademark laws exist. But if something looks like a Rolex but says something other than "Rolex" on it, that's fine. Samsung has never done anything remotely like appropriating Apple's trademarks, so it's all rather silly. There's huge difference between a knock-off and an outright fake.