3 ms·
> since GitHub may not respect the terms of licensed code that is hosted on their servers, not uploading the code of others there is, in fact, a deeply ethical
by bigyabai 1y ago
> since GitHub may not respect the terms of licensed code that is hosted on their servers, not uploading the code of others there is, in fact, a deeply ethical choice.
Feels like a moot point, this goes for anything you upload anywhere (as reprehensible as it is). Perhaps all music and movie clips should be taken off YouTube lest someone train an AI on them? Analog video makes a return to stop the evil consequences of digital training?
- andrepd 1y agoThe right answer would be regulation and enforcement with teeth, but wishing for that seems as far fetched as wishing for a unicorn.
- bediger4000 1y agoI feel extremely cynical about "intellectual property" enforcement. In some circumstances (recorded music ca 1995-2015), IP laws are extremely punitive, and enthusiastically enforced. There's even some folklore around copyright, too. It's easy to get dogpiled on social media if you say copyright on books is too long, or too strictly enforced, or that fair use as enshrined in law and not enforced isn't really fit for purpose. But as far as The Web goes, apparently all content is very loosely owned, copyright is gauzy and difficult to discern, and oligarchs want to do away with it altogether. It's not hard to figure out that the "hidden variable" here is that already wealthy people typically held music, movie and book content, while plebes without the money to sue hold web content copyright.
- guube 1y agoI think the main point of the argument is that you should not upload other people’s code to GitHub. Whether you upload your own code is your choice to make. Same goes with uploading to YouTube. You should not upload an entire film to YouTube if you do not have the right to distribute the film
- bonki 1y agoThe huge difference being that you do have the right to upload to GitHub if the code is released under an OSS license. If a project asks you nicely not to it would be equally nice to honor that, but there is no legal obligation to do so. Putting a copyrighted movie on Youtube to which you have no distribution rights is comparing apples to oranges and not the same thing.
- johnea 1y ago> you do have the right to upload to GitHub if the code is released under an OSS license This assumes that uploading to github does not involve granting other rights to M$ that would violate the original license, such as attribution or copyright.
- bonki 1y agoIANAL but I'm pretty sure that's not how it works. If MS chooses to violate the original license that is between the original author and MS. You as the uploader do not and cannot grant rights to MS which you did not receive in the first place. You upload the code under its original license and if MS does not honor the license that is not on you. Not defending MS here in any way, btw, I do firmly believe in opt-out.