3 ms·
> just looking at what is happening in the US right now, where the country is objectively become a profoundly corrupt, banana-republic level idiocracy, Half th
by SoftTalker 1y ago
> just looking at what is happening in the US right now, where the country is objectively become a profoundly corrupt, banana-republic level idiocracy,
Half the population, or perhaps slightly more, doesn't agree with that.
- llm_nerd 1y agoBy what measure do you come up with that? Nationwide, Trump's approval rating is somewhere around 42-46%. And just to be clear, early in a term presidential approval rating is in a honeymoon period where the public is trying to make the best of the next four years and sees it with rose coloured glasses. Obama had a 65% approval rating. Biden had a 57% approval rating. Both at the same stage in their presidency. On every single issue, the public disagrees with how Trump has acted. From immigration to trade and tariffs to education to health. And he's currently in the "lie about everything and promise the world" stage, but much like his first term that has an expiry date when people realize that he is incredibly stupid and lies with every breath. There will be no trillion dollar windfall from tariffs "paid for by the other country" (though there is the most regressive, largest tax hike in US history), everything is going to get more expensive, and the "Golden age" is going to be a dire descent to a fallen empire. There will be no $5000 DOGE savings cheques or elimination of taxes on tips or overtime, egg prices haven't dropped 95%, gas isn't $1.99, and the Ukraine war keeps going on. He isn't going to eliminate the debt or even the massively exploding deficit with his magical crypto scam shitcoin. But Trump will self-enrich himself and everyone who pays his extortion racket. His trade war grift seems mostly targeted at getting various Trump co projects going, along with fellating his pal Elon's various companies. But regardless, I'm not talking about the US as a whole. No one in Canada wants Kentucky or Texas or Florida joining us, and those people can herald their orange idol however much they want. But on the West Coast Trump has a 30% approval rating. In much of New England and New York he's mid-30s. Again, despite this being the honeymoon period. Yeah, the areas I talked about hugely disagree with this government. So do something about it. Again, red people and states talk about this all the time. https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/marjorie-taylor-greene-states-consider-seceding-from-the-union-1234822567/ https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/marjorie... https://www.newsweek.com/texas-secession-closer-anyone-thinks-1884088 https://www.newsweek.com/texas-secession-closer-anyone-think... If the so-called Blue states don't want to be dragged back a hundred years into this growing anti-science, corrupt idiocracy, start taking the same tact. Somehow it's only incomprehensible when the better states broach it.
- krapp 1y ago>Half the population, or perhaps slightly more, doesn't agree with that. If you're implying that half the population or perhaps slightly more voted for Donald Trump, perhaps as extrapolation from Trump having "won the popular vote," you would be incorrect. Only about 63% of the eligible voting populace voted in 2024, and of those, marginally more voted for Trump than Harris (49.9% vs 48.4%). So a more realistic estimate of the total pro-Trump populace would be closer to 30%. While the narrative that Trump voters command half, or over half, of the entire US population is common it has never actually been true. And this doesn't even take into account the number of Trump voters who are currently dissatisfied with the regime's behavior - the ones who despite all evidence to the contrary saw absolutely nothing wrong with Trump, trusted his motives and integrity, and just thought he would bring the price of eggs down. Also, who cares? They're wrong. Donald Trump is objectively the most corrupt and least competent President in living memory.
- SoftTalker 1y agoThe people who vote are the only ones that matter, in this context.
- krapp 1y agoThe people who voted for Trump are a subset of the people who voted, and that set does not contain "half the population" in any meaningful context.
- toomanyrichies 1y ago> the country is objectively become a profoundly corrupt, banana-republic level idiocracy >> Half the population, or perhaps slightly more, doesn't agree with that. Trump just publicly accepted a $400 million Boeing 747 from one of Hamas's largest financial benefactors [1]. His meme coin operation is tantamount to a political donation machine without the corresponding financial disclosures [2]. And he's shaking down law firms with executive orders unless they donate tens of millions in pro bono legal work to his administration and its pet causes. [3]. This is a non-exhaustive list of just his corruption scandals from just the last month. If Biden had done any one of these things, Fox News would have his supporters frothing at the mouth and (literally) picking up arms. But when Trump does all 3 and more, they don't even bat an eyelash. At this point, it seems less likely that they don't agree he's corrupt, and more likely that they just don't care, as long as its their guy at the helm. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qatari_support_for_Hamas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qatari_support_for_Hamas 2. https://www.binance.com/en/square/post/23938695868353 https://www.binance.com/en/square/post/23938695868353 3. https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/trump-administration/legal-community-shaken-powerful-law-firm-paul-weiss-trump-rcna197490 https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/trump-administration/legal-...
- dragonwriter 1y ago> Half the population, or perhaps slightly more, doesn't agree with that. You seem to be mistaking Trump's support as a share of the vote in the last election for a measure of current beliefs aboht his Administration as a share of the entire population. That involves many errors. And, on top of that, you are mistaking popularity as a measure of truth of a claim about facts, not popular opinion.