4 ms·
Why console makers can legally brick your game console
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- dtagames 1y agoYou will own nothing and be happy, as the saying goes. You can only license a console's underlying software, not own it.
- izzydata 1y agoYou don't own the software's intellectual property, but you own the hardware and it is expected to work under normal operating conditions. If you bought a camera and the manufacturer arbitrarily decided to make the software stop functioning soon after purchase the product would be considered malfunctioning. Nintendo turning off your software should fall under some kind of consumer protection law.
- _aavaa_ 1y ago> You don't own the software's intellectual property I don't own the intellectual property of a physical book I purchase, but I do own a copy of the book and the copyright owner can't just show up at my house and redact the whole book or just take it from me. But somehow if they do it with software it's different.
- EA-3167 1y agoThey can, but if they do the consequences for their business wouldn't be small. If Nintendo thinks piracy of their products is a problem now, try teaching people that investing in their hardware is a gamble and a potential waste of money and see how it goes.
- jerojero 1y agoNintendo is not really a company whose target audience is people who care about homebrew and device ownership. I think although it would make a very vocal segment of the consumers angry, it's not something that ultimately would hurt Nintendo. It's kind of sad imo but it's the reality of it, Nintendo is one of the most litigious and protective companies in the world when it comes to their intellectual property and this isn't a new thing.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- DocTomoe 1y agoYes, and no. That vocal part of the consumers are those that grew up with the old 'you buy it, you get to play it' approach. And those consumers are now the ones who will decide what their children get to play. Needless to say, I do not see Nintendo in my household anymore after the switch2 announcement.
- rchaud 1y agoNintendo's focus is on the generation that came after you. Same as Reddit after the whole API and 3rd party app extinction event. The vocal types are the ones that reminisce about the pre-DMCA days and whine about corporate greed and "you'll own nothing, just what the WEF wants". There is an entire generation of consumers that grew up with Wii U, Switch 1, Netflix and Spotify and don't know or care about ownership and future preservation. That's where the money is. You may refuse to buy one for your kids but there're many more parents who don't play video games or care enough to keep them from getting one for their kids.
- iteria 1y agoThe problem with that idea is that you need evangelists. It's not something that Nintendo will feel now, but I have successfully converted 6 families into PC gaming with my kid. I caught them at kindergarten and now they are in Valve's garden. My sister's family and her circle is all Playstation. Her kids have never touched Nintendo. Sure there are people who don't care, but those people don't bring people into the fold. It's a slow erosion. It's how Microsoft is losing ground to Chromebooks and Macs. People who don't know aren't hearing that they need a windows machine as much. They hear they need a Mac for security/ease of use or all they need is a Chromebook because they just surf the web anyway. Microsoft of course will be fine because they have business on lock, but they used to have consumers as well.
- voidUpdate 1y agoI miss the days of when you buy something, you own it
- dominicrose 1y agoYou can still buy the console that can read physical games and buy the physical games and never plug it on the internet, right? But I guess most people, like me bought a numerical version and plugged it to the internet. Then you're a few clicks away from a monthly subscription or from buying new games. They really don't have any incentive to brick your console except if you pirate the games. They don't earn money on the console by itself.
- jsheard 1y ago> You can still buy the console that can read physical games and buy the physical games and never plug it on the internet, right? Not always. Many games don't get physical releases, or only get an expensive limited-run physical collectors edition, and when they do get a physical release it doesn't necessarily even contain all of the game data so part of it may still have to be downloaded. The latter is apparently going to be even more common with the Switch 2 due to the high cost of its faster storage. Nintendo is now giving publishers the option of releasing "game key carts" which contain zero game data and are essentially just DRM dongles that grant permission to download and play the game.
- sseagull 1y ago> You can still buy the console that can read physical games and buy the physical games and never plug it on the internet, right? I'm not positive this is possible. I seem to remember times when trying to play a newer game on the Switch required a system update, even though I had the physical card. I might be misremembering, though.
- jsheard 1y agoGames can require a firmware update to play, but AIUI the physical carts are supposed to have their required firmware bundled alongside the game so you can update without an internet connection.
- racl101 1y agoYeah, not sure I wanna buy the Switch 2. So far, have no plans. But they could tempt me if they put out a new big Zelda title, especially, if they don't do open world and go back to dungeon-centric design like Twilight Princes or OOT. Then I'm gonna have to buy the damn glorified Zelda playing machine against my better instincts.
- __s 1y agoOcarina of Time was peak. Come play Ship of Harkinian randomizer. I've been trying to add fun stuff like shuffling the ability to use crawlspaces & randomizing how doors connect in dungeons
- pmx 1y agoI have a hard time accepting that this would fly in the UK. We have strong consumer protection laws in the Consumer Rights Act 2015 that I think this would run afoul of. Terms can't be unfair, and are deemed so if "contrary to the requirement of good faith, it causes a significant imbalance in the parties' rights and obligations under the contract to the detriment of the consumer." and a product must be fit for purpose for 6 years - if this ceased to be the case the consumer is entitled to a full refund or replacement.
- 3836293648 1y agoYes, this is super illegal under EU laws the UK hasn't repealed
- Mindwipe 1y agoI think it's very unlikely they would be a problem for the manufacturer in the event of the consumer making modifications which the packaging is very clear that you should not make, or for the facilitation of illegal acts. Put it this way - it's pretty common for devices to have their DRM keys downgraded in the video industry if they are leaked, and that has never presented any issues for manufacturers under the CRA.