3 ms·
Nuclear is so expensive the only reason anyone builds them is governments wants a source of nuclear trained people around for military purposes (either bombs or
by bluGill 1y ago
Nuclear is so expensive the only reason anyone builds them is governments wants a source of nuclear trained people around for military purposes (either bombs or navy ships).
Battery backup isn't a needed as much as many thing in the real world. Those gas power plants we already have are not going anywhere, so we still use them when there isn't much wind. Though battery is something we should be building instead (and are).
- xattt 1y agoWait, what? There are also a number of countries that operate nuclear plants purely for civilian electricity production. Military applications are not the primary motivator. Instead, civilian energy demands and energy independence are the motivating factors. Look at how Ontario leveraged its electricity supply in the early days of the trade war.
- bluGill 1y agoI said build not operate. The world situation has changed, 50 years ago nuclear power was a good idea to build. If you have a working nuclear power plant I'd generally keep operating it, and do small upgrades over time. However building a new one is something you should only do if you have military needs. (note that showing off is sometimes a military need)
- xattt 1y agoCANDU 9 and Advanced CANDU reactors were developed and built during a time when Canada had no active military nuclear program.
- cyberax 1y agoIn most of Europe, nuclear is cheaper than anything else but coal, natgas, and classic hydro. When you also add the cost of battery backup. Spain and Portugal have just experienced the first taste of that fact.
- laurencerowe 1y agoMost of the cost of nuclear is in construction so extending the life of existing nuclear power stations as long as possible makes sense. However new nuclear in Europe has been much more expensive and even France has lost the ability to build new nuclear capacity cheaply.
- mndgs 1y agoNonsense, by that logic Lithuania should have been a #2 military power long time ago (having built nukes from a civil nuclear reactor) (it used to operate #2 largest nuclear reactor in the world, now it would be #4).
- laurencerowe 1y agoI mean Lithuania's nuclear reactors were built while it was part of the #2 military power in the world and have since been shut down. https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/countries-g-n/lithuania https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profil...
- natmaka 1y agoWe even know how to feed gas turbine with hydrogen, and how to make hydrogen thanks to renewables' overproduction ("green hydrogen").