2 ms·
That link says "SIDEN KAN IKKE FINDES" - "the page cannot be found." Yes, Denmark has a personal number. What are the biometrics tying that number to the perso
by dalke 14y ago
That link says "SIDEN KAN IKKE FINDES" - "the page cannot be found."
Yes, Denmark has a personal number. What are the biometrics tying that number to the person? It's a signature.
See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_document#Denmark http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_document#Denmark . "Denmark is one of few EU countries that currently do not issue national identity cards...", "National Health Insurance Card ... has no photo of the holder", "Danish drivers' licenses and passports are the only identity cards issued by the government containing both the personal identification number and a photo" but foreigners resident in the country who don't have driving skills (but notably are entitled to the social care system) can't get either one.
Then look for images of a Sundhedskort and you'll see there's only space for a signature on the back. No chip, no photo, nothing else.
Again my question to you is, what additional level of assurance do we need in order to have and maintain a democratic form of government with a strong social care system? I assert that signatures - which are a form of biometrics - and perhaps an identification number are more than sufficient for most countries.
(I again say that I know little about the situation in India. It may be that my views are only applicable to certain countries.)
Take voting as the main point. If you need to present stronger proof of the right to vote in order to vote, then what form would that be? An identity card? Then what happens if you've lost the card, or it was stolen or confiscated - have you lost the right to vote in a given election? What if you are unable to provide the needed documents to establish that stronger evidence, as is the problem of Viviette Applewhite, Wilola Lee, Grover Freeland, and others in Pennsylvania? Or should we use fingerprint and/or retina biometrics as in the linked article on India?
How much fraud and distrust in the voting system will the extra evidence remove, and what is the financial cost? Isn't existing fraud rather small, and less than to common-place problems during voting, like http://www.usatoday.com/news/politicselections/vote2004/2004-11-04-votes-lost_x.htm http://www.usatoday.com/news/politicselections/vote2004/2004... where votes were lost due to missing information about machine limitations? "Counting Votes 2012: A State by State Look at Voting Technology Preparedness" reports that "More than 300 voting machine problems were reported to election protection hotlines during the 2010 mid-term elections, and more than 1800 were reported during the 2008 general election."
I quite frankly don't see our democratic principles on shaky ground, in need of stronger assurances of citizen identification in order to stabilize it. Do you have evidence to the contrary?