3 ms·

I don't mind your rebuttal of the article, but to suggest that this particular article is AI generated is foolish. The style the author presents is vivid, uses

I don't mind your rebuttal of the article, but to suggest that this particular article is AI generated is foolish. The style the author presents is vivid, uses powerful imagery and metaphor and finally, at times, is genuinely funny. More qualitatively, the author incorporates a unique identity that persists throughout the entirety of a long form essay. All of that is still difficult to get an LLM to do. This isn't AI generated. It's just good writing. Whether you buy the premise or not.

boxed 1y ago
Maybe he meant it was long. Some people seem to think that long walls of text is how you spot AI slop.
- nozzlegear 1y ago
  And god forbid you use an emdash these days.
  - xigoi 1y ago
    I’ve recently been accused of using ChatGPT because I wrote a message with formal language and bullet points.
  - MrVandemar 1y ago
    I'm unapologetic about using em-dashes. They're in my toolbox, and I reach for them. I can and do manually type em-dashes manually in both Linux and Microsoft Windows using the key-codes. Anyone who is basing their opinion of the provenance of a piece of writing on whether em-dashes are used, then that opinion is emminently discardable lemming-babble.
aozgaa 1y ago
[flagged]
- cedric_h 1y ago
  [flagged]
queenkjuul 1y ago
I got slightly LLM vibes for the first few paragraphs ngl. It became very clear it wasn't very fast, though.
chrismorgan 1y ago
Yeah, it feels a very different style of unhinged to LLMs. I can’t yet imagine an LLM producing such a beautiful and contextually-appropriate sentence as “They’ll be out there trying to duct-tape horses to an engine block, wondering why it doesn’t fly.”
- nick3443 1y ago
  This brought tears to my eyes: But you—at your most frazzled, sleep-deprived, raccoon-eyed best—you can try. You can squint at the layers of abstraction and see through them. Peel back the nice ergonomic type-safe, pure, lazy, immutable syntactic sugar and imagine the mess of assembly the compiler pukes up. Amazing
a0123 1y ago
> The style the author presents is vivid, uses powerful imagery and metaphor and finally, at times, is genuinely funny. More qualitatively, the author incorporates a unique identity that persists throughout the entirety of a long form essay. This is incredible you would say that because you'll never guess what it reads like.
- petemir 1y ago
  I'm glad I'm not the only one to have thought that...
yerushalayim 1y ago
This rebuttal of the rebuttal does feel earily AI. Perhaps an injection of cynicism?

boxed 1y ago

Maybe he meant it was long. Some people seem to think that long walls of text is how you spot AI slop.

nozzlegear 1y ago
And god forbid you use an emdash these days.
- xigoi 1y ago
  I’ve recently been accused of using ChatGPT because I wrote a message with formal language and bullet points.
- MrVandemar 1y ago
  I'm unapologetic about using em-dashes. They're in my toolbox, and I reach for them. I can and do manually type em-dashes manually in both Linux and Microsoft Windows using the key-codes. Anyone who is basing their opinion of the provenance of a piece of writing on whether em-dashes are used, then that opinion is emminently discardable lemming-babble.

aozgaa 1y ago

[flagged]

cedric_h 1y ago
[flagged]

queenkjuul 1y ago

I got slightly LLM vibes for the first few paragraphs ngl. It became very clear it wasn't very fast, though.

chrismorgan 1y ago

Yeah, it feels a very different style of unhinged to LLMs. I can’t yet imagine an LLM producing such a beautiful and contextually-appropriate sentence as “They’ll be out there trying to duct-tape horses to an engine block, wondering why it doesn’t fly.”

nick3443 1y ago
This brought tears to my eyes: But you—at your most frazzled, sleep-deprived, raccoon-eyed best—you can try. You can squint at the layers of abstraction and see through them. Peel back the nice ergonomic type-safe, pure, lazy, immutable syntactic sugar and imagine the mess of assembly the compiler pukes up. Amazing

a0123 1y ago

> The style the author presents is vivid, uses powerful imagery and metaphor and finally, at times, is genuinely funny. More qualitatively, the author incorporates a unique identity that persists throughout the entirety of a long form essay. This is incredible you would say that because you'll never guess what it reads like.

petemir 1y ago
I'm glad I'm not the only one to have thought that...

yerushalayim 1y ago

This rebuttal of the rebuttal does feel earily AI. Perhaps an injection of cynicism?