13 ms·
Why don't they just..?
- alexchamberlain 14y agoI think it's the conservative part people have a problem with. Someone at some point in NASA's life had to take the plunge and develop the components and algorithms to use, so it isn't unreasonable to expect some new components and algorithms on new projects.
- nicholassmith 14y agoI imagine they build the new components and algorithms for less dicey missions, get as much data back as possible and then look at reusing them in another area. NASA is basic a giant engine of risk mitigation, a lower priority mission with a lower cost is much more suitable for something new that isn't tried and tested out.
- Sanddancer 14y agoComputers are something that NASA has always been conservative with. By the time Apollo flew, the technology for the Apollo Guidance Computer -- RTL ICs -- was a few generations obsolete. The shuttle's main computers started out as designs derived from the IBM S/360. It takes time to design a radiation hardened board, and from there, it takes time to integrate that board into new designs. Thus, progress seems slow, but it's about as slow as it ever was in hardware. Integrating a newer core late in the game means a lot of needless regression testing for questionable benefit. Because of how orbits work, the deadlines are a lot more set in stone, and if your change breaks something, it could mean that you miss your launch window, and are sitting on your butt for a couple years until it comes around again. The algorithm part is equally simple to explain. Most of these algorithms aren't broke, so there's no real impetus to fix them. The equations are pretty well known, so between missions, there's really not a need to change them up.
- antr 14y ago"Annoying because the underlying thought is "Those NASA/JPL guys are so dumb"" I have to disagree with this statement and the article. I've asked some of these questions in the past, and the reason I ask is because I'm curious, not because I'm trying to call anyone "dumb". The fact that people try to understand the underlying technology of such a complex mission, and later followup with a "why" question, simply shows how the general public is interested in these events. I'd be more worried if people didn't ask any questions at all, implying that they do not care for such scientific and technological breakthroughs. Indifference can be a dangerous thing.
- stereo 14y agoI had the same reaction. "Why don't they just" questions are essential to understanding engineering, and we should, if anything, encourage them.
- TomasSedovic 14y agoWhich happens to be the point of this article.
- emil0r 14y agoFairly big difference between asking "Why don't they...?" and "Why don't they just...?". The 'just' tacked onto the end of the beginning of the question implies it should be totally obvious.
- antr 14y agoregardless of semantics, it is ignorance--not knowledge--that is the true engine of science
- thaumaturgy 14y agoNo. It is the desire for knowledge. I loathe semantic games in arguments as much as anyone, but I too often see "ignorance" being given some kind of special place in science, where it doesn't belong. There's a reason why NASA didn't just dedicate 8 years, $2.5 billion, and a tremendous amount of human effort to land a rover called "Ignorance" on another planet. Curiosity: in this glorious age of Google, Wikipedia, Wolfram-Alpha, and so many other free and readily available resources, it doesn't start with the words, "Why don't they just..."
- antr 14y agoread ignorance as a lack of knowledge - not the voluntarily action to ignore.
- rangibaby 14y agoGreat post. I'm sure at least one person is going to say "But I don't have a billion dollar budget to spend on my Earth-rover!" though.
- jayfuerstenberg 14y agoVxWorks was chosen because it does what it says on the tin.
- tikhonj 14y agoThere are perfectly valid reasons to ask questions like this: you may be genuinely curious or confused about the issue. If something seems obviously odd to me it usually means I'm missing some piece of information needed to understand. Having somebody explain what circumstance I'm unaware of is extremely useful and enlightening. If I ask a question like this it's to get a better feel for the problem space rather than to imply any sort of incompetence on the part of whomever I'm asking about. The real problem is that it's hard to tell the people asking questions like this out of truly interest apart from the people being undeservedly condescending. I suppose the most important thing is to phrase questions like this carefully and to be polite. I think it's also useful for the answerer not to assume bad faith unless it's very overt. A presumption of reasonableness from everyone would markedly improve discussions about projects like the Mars rover which generally contain very useful information and insight but can get side-tracked by the very issues this article talks about.
- ErrantX 14y agoRegarding #4; it would be nice to see someone pursuing a project to put a set of comms satellites in orbit around Mars to significantly improve this coverage. If we are going to be making these efforts at Mars in the future (whether autonomous or manned) it seems worth the investment :)
- masklinn 14y ago> it would be nice to see someone pursuing a project to put a set of comms satellites in orbit around Mars to significantly improve this coverage. Would that really change anything? A higher bandwidth between the rover and Mars's lower orbit will not make the link between Mars and Earth much faster, and that's the true bottleneck. Not to mention wireless communications are not "free" as any smartphone owner probably knows and the rover's daily energy budget is pretty much fixed, the more the rover stays in contact with Mars's lower orbit, the less energy it has to drive around or fire its lasers. And finally, for what it's worth, the MRO is already "significant improve[ment of] coverage".
- ZoFreX 14y ago> Would that really change anything? Yes. The rover is only in communication with its satellite for a limited time frame each day, and the satellite <-> earth link is wider than the satellite <-> rover link. With more satellites we could have around the clock high speed link up, and improve the bandwidth - future missions are likely to be loaded with more and/or higher bandwidth sensors.
- ErrantX 14y ago> and that's the true bottleneck. Are you sure? My understanding was that the biggest bottleneck lay in the fact that the orbiters could only communicated with the lander for 8 minutes per day. Fairly crippling :) > Not to mention wireless communications are not "free" as any smartphone owner probably knows and the rover's daily energy budget is pretty much fixed I understood the energy source gave a fixed output - it's not a daily budger per se. So 2 hours communications (rather than 8 minutes) wouldn't leave it unable to move for the rest of the day. I could be wrong. However; if it takes a week to send it an update - or to receive big pictures - that implies delays in its work anyway. I agree that the MRO is a significant improvement. I was just idly pointing out that if the aim is to go to Mars more it would be worth investing in infrastructure as much as science.
- ajankovic 14y agoWell, "Why don't they just..?" question is not specific to this case. It's a very common question in many other areas of life. In my opinion it's because of general curiosity found in humans. And except mild annoyance it can be a very good way to introspect your position. For example if others haven't been asking this question we wouldn't got this explanation. And now that I got this explanation of NASA's process I would like to know "Why don't they just make all this process more agile?" For example why have only one launch in 7 years with expensive hardware? Why not multiple launches with cheaper technology?
- lovskogen 14y agoWhy is tech so unreliable? Why does testing and building take so long time that tech is outdated?
- ZoFreX 14y agoJust to play devil's advocate here, is it really /that/ "outdated"? Yes, the camera is modest by 2004 standards, but by 1994 standards it's out of this world! To me, eight years to build and test equipment to fly to Mars and wander around on another planet's surface is a pretty reasonable turnaround time.
- thaumaturgy 14y agoI used to wonder that too. Well, I wondered why nobody could seem to make simple products that worked reliably without any duds and without a lot of cost. Then I got a job with a company that manufactures sensors used by a huge number of companies and governmental departments, including NASA and Boeing. And my job was Output Smoothness Technician -- which meant that I was the one guy who was responsible for verifying the electrical specifications of every single part that left the plant. (The next two steps were QA -- which tested things like watertightness -- and then shipping.) I learned a lot from that job. I learned that there are a lot of decisions behind every single little thing. For example, let's take the tiny little linear potentiometers that Disney uses in its animatronics. Someone at Disney decided they needed them; one team of engineers came up with a spec; another team of engineers figured out how to turn the spec into something that could be made; another team figured out how to make it. Then someone decided what kind of metal to use. Someone else decided how to tune the potentiometer to provide the desired output. Someone else decided what kind of grease to use. And then during manufacturing, someone decided whether or not the housing was good enough, someone decided whether or not everything fit together right, someone decided whether or not the weld was good enough, and so on. By the time that little thing got to me, there were thousands of little decisions stored in it. Some good, some not. Then I had to test it and decide whether or not it would do what the customer wanted. Should I throw it out, wasting the company a lot of money? Or should I ship it, and let the customer decide, and hope the QA on their end is better than me? I pretty quickly developed a reputation as one of the toughest OS techs they'd ever had. I threw back a lot of parts. The sales manager (who basically ran that location) hated my guts. But we still had defective parts come back every month! Now imagine that you're trying to build something that you can't service, and you can't fix. You get only one shot to get it right, and a lot of money and a lot of people are riding on you. Best of all, you're building it to survive in an environment that you just can't really create here on Earth, so you don't get to test it the way that you'd test a lot of things. That's why it takes 8 years and a lot of money: because it's very, very hard. I think that one day sending things to Mars will become something that we're used to, and at that point, it will get a lot faster and a lot cheaper and a lot more reliable. But, right now, we're still trying to do things that we don't really know how to do. That's hard, and it takes time.
- fsniper 14y agoThe questions will be dumb. they will repeat again and again. That's because not everybody is an expert on Mars robotics. Everybody has daily tech and they just use these tech as comparison points. For instance, people have everyday technology in hands and they believe, if the ordinary Jane/John Doe has a multi core processor smart phone costing them 1000$ with manufacturer margin, NASA/ESA/JPL whatever guys with millions of dollars of funding has to use better and faster and fancier hardware. And by being ordinary John/Jane Doe, fancier does not mean "radiation hardened", "autonomous in hostile environment", "updatable on slow and relayed links". Because these are not their daily problem. They do not know about them. Also if Apple/Samsung/Motorola heck even Nokia guys could design and mass manufacture, and distribute any smart phone in a few months to be held on john's or jane's hands, NASA must be a fricking snail fast. How distant could Mars be? I can transport from continent to continent in a few hours? Don't be harsh on them. Some of the questions may seem dumb, but may be really good questions if they are worked on. For example, I believe radiation hardening is needed because while transportation to Mars there is massive amounts of radiation to be moved through. If the Curiosity would not be operated in the journey, and Mars radiation levels are not that massive. Could Curiosity use multiple (with spares of course) faster and cheaper ordinary processors with small energy footprint, if the transportation was inside a radiation hardened armor that would be gotten rid off on the Mars surface?
- ctrlaltesc 14y agoJust to answer the example: Mars does not have a magnetic field of significant strength. Curiosity needs shielding on the surface. Perfectly reasonable question though.
- acabal 14y agoWhen I first started in corporate programming and had to pick up on big projects that someone else had left off, I often found myself saying the same thing a lot. "Man, they did this in such a dumb way. Why didn't they do it this way? They must not have been very smart." So I would go in and "fix" things... only to find out a month later that the code was the way it was because of some obscure edge case that I had never thought of. It turns out that in my arrogance I was the dummy all along. After that happened a couple of times, I stopped approaching strange code with that attitude. Programmers are in general pretty clever, and if you see something strange in some code, don't assume it's because they're dumb. At first assume it's because you're dumb, and only change your mind if careful and deliberate analysis--and talking to someone else with history in the organization--proves otherwise.
- FuzzyDunlop 14y agoAfter the recent discussion about code-comments, that sort of code is exactly the sort that requires an explanatory comment. Then all of a sudden, you don't need to waste time on careful and deliberate analysis, and hunting down people who might know about it, and making assumptions, because the 2 minutes it would take to write a few lines of explanation would save you all of that. At which point, the real question is: why did they choose not to document this non-obvious solution, and the edge case that required it?
- davidw 14y agoComments, and, one would hope, some tests showing how the obscure edge case interacts with everything else.
- tedunangst 14y agoSometimes you don't know what the edge cases are because you don't know what the everything else is. If you return something sorted, somebody will write a consumer that depends on the sorting. If you change backends and return things in a different order, you've broken their code. Sure, their code was broken from the start, but it used to work, now it doesn't, and you're the guy who changed something. The only way to prevent this, randomly sorting every unsorted collection you export, isn't feasible to reliably maintain.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- alan_cx 14y agoThe problem is how the reader chooses to interpret the phrase, and usually such phrases aren't made in a clear context. From what I see, it looks like most readers interpret that phrase as an arrogant arm chair expert assuming NASA, or who ever, are full of really stupid people and the person "asking" is essentially suggesting he knows better. The simpler interpretation that a person who knows they don't know is simply asking is often the secondary thought, if that thought occurs at all. I think that has a lot to do with the combat nature of on-line "debate". People now are sort of trained to expect confrontation rather than a mellow old chat. Kinda ties in to a recent thread here about , er, negative and harsh replied to Show HN articles. This is one of the things I'm beginning to really not like about on-line discussions. I end up spending more time trying to make sure I'm not misinterpreted than making my actual point.
- 16s 14y agoThe attitude of I know better than they do is really strong in technology and programming in general. Most people who make those claims know not of what they speak.
- incision 14y agoI'd say it's really strong everywhere, particularly technology and programming. Thing is, unlike the average folks with lofty ideas of self-serving "fixes" for every irritation in their lives, people in technology aren't just consumers from a distance - they're builders, maintainers and influencers. It's a dangerous problem when these "active" people don't understand context, concessions, dependencies and just generally what it takes to actually create things in the real world. I believe it's one of the roots of various stifling attitudes of conformance and covering your ass above real, forward homegrown engineering. Apologies if that doesn't make sense. I had a hard time trying to articulate my ideas there.
- sandis 14y agoInternational politics (and to some extent politics in general) is another topic where this happens a lot
- todayiamme 14y agoAn even cooler project would be proving once and for all that a swarm of small, rugged drones can indeed cover a larger area in harsh conditions and are a much more sensible strategy in exploration than a large single drone. Iff you have ten, twenty expendable machines then you don't need the same level of QA, thus opening up a lot of interesting possibilities. If we can get equivalent amounts of exploration done in just half (or maybe quarter) the cost then it opens up room for an arms race of sorts where each generation can be rapidly iterated upon and we can plan such missions within a one or two year timeframe instead of an eight year one. Of course, this is easier said than done... ;)
- deeringc 14y agoWell, surely for a certain type of scientific mission (e.g. something like spectral analysis via ChemCam) you cannot just shrink down the components and instruments indefinitely. The size of Curiosity is directly related to the fact that it is bristling with scientific instruments like no other probe before it. Sure you could make a swarm of toaster sized drones that just go off and cover ground, but the purpose of this mission is not just to take some pictures but to do some very detailed scientific analysis.
- todayiamme 14y agoWhat you could do is have dedicated drones which are essentially movable instruments, so you can have co-operation on tasks and say teams of 3 or 4 (one vaporises, the other has the spectrometer. One drills, the other has the reagents and so on) If you enter this paradigm then you can eliminate costs such as that long arm which you need to position the instrument package. That arm in of itself is an engineering marvel and it requires a lot of careful design to make sure that it doesn't malfunction. (remember you have a not so light weight at the end, the torque due to that is huge and you have a complex assembly consisting linkages to transfer torque and so on...) The idea of this is to see how simple and redundant you can make things. If for the cost of that arm we could have one small team of rovers wouldn't it be worth it? Wouldn't it jump start exploration?
- 14y ago
- bootload 14y ago"... You need to be a bit conservative. The thing you're sending to Mars is going to be on its own and unrepairable. ..." Hardware is hard to fix but software is do-able. There is a lot of explanations how this was done with Pathfinder: http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/mbj/mars_pathfinder/mars_pathfinder.html http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/um/people/mbj/mars_pathf... http://chronicle.augusta.com/stories/2004/02/16/liv_404763.shtml http://chronicle.augusta.com/stories/2004/02/16/liv_404763.s... http://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=1035610 http://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=1035610 there was also some reconfiguring of Curiosity on-going/completed ~ http://blog.chron.com/techblog/2012/08/nasa-about-to-perform-the-ultimate-software-upgrade-on-mars/ http://blog.chron.com/techblog/2012/08/nasa-about-to-perform... there is also a lot of work done on 'self healing' software systems ~ http://www.zdnet.com/blog/emergingtech/self-healing-computers-for-nasa-spacecraft/903 http://www.zdnet.com/blog/emergingtech/self-healing-computer...
- TomGullen 14y agoI don't see any problem with the "Why don't they just..." questions. People are curious. I don't really like the tone of the post, it comes off as a little elitist to me and is going to discourage question asking in the future if people are answered with that sort of tone. Also "Why don't they just" has multiple meanings in my opinion. You explained one of them, a sort of incredulous question querying the stupidity of the people who made those decisions. But it's also used far more innocently as well. I and a lot of my friends will ask questions in that format but as a genuine query not meaning to tread on anyones toes or insult anyone. (I'm having trouble articulating this!) This sort of question asking isn't the exclusive domain of Mars rovers either, it's everything. Politics, economics, business etc etc. It's just natural human curiosity, people trying to understand things that seem counter intuitive at first.
- biot 14y ago> But rather than explaining all this stuff, I think there's a > better way: build, land and operate a rover here on Earth. Is this implying that building a rover here would provide an explanation for their technical choices? With a 2kg payload limit for a balloon-launched rover, you might be better off with the latest technology. GPS on a chip rather than separate components making up GPS circuitry. Or a tiny, power-efficient mobile chip rather than some power-hungry chip from a decade ago.
- deeringc 14y agoI agree, especially because many of the reasons for the older, less cutting edge technology used in space boil down to high levels of radiation. Building a small 2kg probe, launching via a weather balloon and then exploring a desert on earth would certainly be hugely educational (not to mention fun) but the constraints would be very different to those on a Mars mission and so the end result would look VERY different.
- simias 14y agoWell, I wrote one of those "why don't they just" comments on an article posted by jgrahamc[1] two weeks ago, so I feel the need to justify myself here. Of course, as you point out I didn't mean to say that I know better than the guys at NASA. It's meant as "The way they do it seems strange and non-intuitive, how come they do this?". I agree that I could've worded that better. That being said, I disagree when you say "It doesn't take much research to find the answer". Case in point, my comment: "Why don't they just put a camera filming downwards to determine the ground speed? Wouldn't it be simpler and more reliable?" I don't think any of your "answers" addresses this specific question. So it boils down to "Because it's on friggin' Mars, doofus". When I posted the comment, I hoped someone around here had an explanation for this (after all, determining a ground speed is something even non-space exploring robots need, I'm sure :). But again, I agree the wording is awkward and comes off as pretentious, but do believe that it wasn't anything but genuine curiosity (sic). [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4345126 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4345126
- K2h 14y agoThis last year I have made a conscious effort that whenever I use the word 'just' in communicating at work I stop. It has taken some time and introspection but for me personally when I prefface a statement with "... just do.." it follows with a statement I have put about 10 seconds of thought into and isn't really valuable. I now listen for the word 'just' when other people are pitching ideas, or forming repsonses and tend to ignore what is said next as I suspect they too have put little thought into the statement they are about to make. I'm not sure this is a great general case recomendation, but it has helped me in my parsing language for possible stupidity.
- Evbn 14y agoJust is a four letter word. Discourse is almost always improved when you remove that word from a sentence.
- huggyface 14y agoThis is overly cynical. When people say "Why don't they just...", it is a sincere question, not a rhetorical statement. "Oh radiation...that makes sense". "Oh they had to bake the tech for 8 years". Etc. Sidenote - "Why don't they just" shield the electronics rather than making the electronics itself radiation proof? I ask that knowing that there is a legitimate reason (shielding weight?), but it is something I have sincerely often wondered.
- Retric 14y ago'Radiation' is not a single unified thing. You can shield some things chicken wire with multi inch holes in it. Other can travel though the earth before hitting you. On of the basic problems is some of the things that help you vs one type of radiation makes other things worse. Also, Mars missions are multi year affairs so even at background radiation levels on earth you are going to have problems. PS: If you added up the entire mass of everything ever put into orbit you would not be able to make a shield to guarantee normal equipment would be able to stand a 5 year mission in space.
- natep 14y agoThe problem is that you can't fully control the meaning that someone takes from your statement. As a spacecraft enginner that knows many of the possible justifications for these "why don't they just"s, it's the negative connotation that springs to mind first, even without the "just". I think it is because that phrase is often used in the imperative sense, and not in a knowledge-seeking sense. Google autocomplete for "why don't you" suggests "stay", "get a job", "love me", and "do right" and if someone were to ask me any of those questions, I would not assume they were sincerely wondering anything. Now, if you're wondering how better to phrase your questions of this sort, I'm afraid I don't have any specifics, because I'm not sure if I'm just as guilty of this, or if I've successfully rephrased my questions of this sort. What I do is try to imagine that I've spent years designing, building, and debugging the thing in question, and gone through multiple reviews by outside organizations where every design decision was scrutinized, and had many meetings with coworkers (formal and informal) to discuss the thing in question. And then I ask my question in the affirmative, rather than in the negative, such as: "Why did you do X, would Y also work?" "I would have done Y. What is it about X or Y that I am missing?"
- smackfu 14y ago"1. The Mars Science Laboratory project was started eight years ago in 2004. So, all the technology on it is at least eight years old." This doesn't seem quite right. From watching documentaries on the past Mars missions, it seems like each piece of scientific equipment is done separately by various engineering groups around the U.S. and the world. They are only integrated at the end. And those individual pieces of equipment are getting changed right up until the deadline if they aren't working up to spec. So the requirements are eight years old, but the tech isn't necessarily. They are just very conservative in their requirements.
- dpcan 14y agoWhile I generally agree with what he says, I can't help but wonder why they would build something over the course of 10 years without assuming that by the time it would be sent into space, there would be better technology available for various aspects of their design. For example, build everything around the Camera, but make sure that when it's within a year of going up into space, the design is such that the highest resolution camera available can take the current camera's place. Of course, anyone who has worked on the project will easily be able to say that I have no clue. And I don't. But I guess that if I were included in the planning stages, and it came down to the data collection components of this machine, the first thing I would add would be that it should be capable of upgrading to the latest and greatest within a year of launch. As a final note, I understand that they DID do this with software. They can update the operating system and roll back. They can advance the software, bug fix, etc, in a VERY safe way from afar.
- jgrahamc 14y agoAnswers to this are here: http://www.dpreview.com/news/2012/08/08/Curiosity-interview-with-Malin-Space-Science-Systems-Mike-Ravine http://www.dpreview.com/news/2012/08/08/Curiosity-interview-...
- buerkle 14y agoAt least with software you can rollback, not exactly something that works with hardware. A year may seem like a long time, but to test all the ramifications of something that sounds simple like a higher resolution camera is not an easy problem. As the dpreview article highlights, a change in resolution affects multiple subsystems.
- jhuckestein 14y agoOff topic: There's a comment (http://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=4408271&whence=item%3fid%3d4406820 http://news.ycombinator.com/reply?id=4408271&whence=item...) that breaks the layout because it contains a very long word. I was trying to find an easy CSS hack to make the layout impervious to long words but it turned out to be a little tricky. Can anyone find a CSS "one-liner" (few-lineser?) that'll fix this?
- joshu 14y ago"just" is a dangerous word. if you are hearing it, prepare to be condescended to. if you are saying it, you probably don't actually understand the situation.
- hnriot 14y agoWhile I totally understand that the mission's computing power was decided a long time ago, if they'd left some 'high risk' room in the budget (mainly weight) then they could have added whatever new tech was available, say a year before launch in the hope that it works, if it doesn't then the old klunky decade old tech will still do its job, but just maybe the foil wrapped iPhone will Facetime back to Earth and work just fine. Aside from adding a little weight, it seems like a small risk to throw onboard something closer to cutting edge with a caveat that it might not work in the mission plan. I bet if NASA had had a competition to come up with the most likely to work gizmo, up to 1 lb (or whatever) we'd have seen some pretty good ideas (beyond duct taping an iphone to the antenna mast)
- RandallBrown 14y agoWhy don't they just send an iPhone to control the mars rover? Radiation? What does radiation do to electronics? Do they corrode? Will things short circuit? Would shielding an iPhone be more expensive than using outdated parts? Do we know that the iPhone isn't reliable enough? Mine seems to be fairly reliable. Any problems with it are solved by a simple reset. Certainly a small bit of old battle tested code/hardware could handle this problem. Is the benefit of having modern hardware not worth it? I'm sure all of these questions have answers, but it's not like I know where to find them.
- Evbn 14y agoUntil we lose communication with the rover because a bit of conductive dirt shorted the antenna.
- RandallBrown 14y agoI would expect the budget would include enough money for a bumper.