3 ms·

> This is an article about ML research, and the emphasis on branding and marketing your paper wouldn't fly in any of the fields people think of as scientific T

> This is an article about ML research, and the emphasis on branding and marketing your paper wouldn't fly in any of the fields people think of as scientific The number of accepted papers is absolutely currency and measure of worth in academia.

whatshisface 1y ago
That's true as a zeroth-order approximation, but even sticking to trivially quantified values your citation count is more important (that's maybe first-order), and on the level of your reputation the question you need to ask is, "will people feel like my work actually benefits them?"
Fomite 1y ago
Interestingly, one of the pieces of advice, about having a punchy title, is a double edged sword. There's some data suggesting papers with "clever" titles have an easier time getting published, but accumulate fewer lifetime citations. Both of which are currency.
- karmakurtisaani 1y ago
  The reason could be that clever titles add "novelty", but not much substance. Publishable, but not citable.
  - Majromax 1y ago
    > The reason could be that clever titles add "novelty", but not much substance. Another reason might be that clever titles stand out as bold claims, working counter to the common practice of academic humility. If a paper seems to be downplaying its own significance, then why should a casual reader (or reviewer, at first impression) give it the benefit of the doubt? That's not to say that papers should over-claim, and I suspect that doing so might lead to a harsh counter-reaction from reviewers who feel like they've been set up to have their time wasted. Nonetheless, "project confidence" might be good practice in academia as well as one's social life.
- eru 1y ago
  I suspect there's a selection bias here. Silly example: if I ever find out a prove saying that "P=NP", that will also be the title of my paper. No cleverness required to grab attention. If I have a more pedestrian result, I'll think up some clever title.
- spookie 1y ago
  As someone doing a literature review I can safely concur with this. Fancy titles often do not include the most obvious terms of what you are searching for, leading to fewer results from your query.

whatshisface 1y ago

That's true as a zeroth-order approximation, but even sticking to trivially quantified values your citation count is more important (that's maybe first-order), and on the level of your reputation the question you need to ask is, "will people feel like my work actually benefits them?"

Fomite 1y ago

Interestingly, one of the pieces of advice, about having a punchy title, is a double edged sword. There's some data suggesting papers with "clever" titles have an easier time getting published, but accumulate fewer lifetime citations. Both of which are currency.

karmakurtisaani 1y ago
The reason could be that clever titles add "novelty", but not much substance. Publishable, but not citable.
- Majromax 1y ago
  > The reason could be that clever titles add "novelty", but not much substance. Another reason might be that clever titles stand out as bold claims, working counter to the common practice of academic humility. If a paper seems to be downplaying its own significance, then why should a casual reader (or reviewer, at first impression) give it the benefit of the doubt? That's not to say that papers should over-claim, and I suspect that doing so might lead to a harsh counter-reaction from reviewers who feel like they've been set up to have their time wasted. Nonetheless, "project confidence" might be good practice in academia as well as one's social life.
eru 1y ago
I suspect there's a selection bias here. Silly example: if I ever find out a prove saying that "P=NP", that will also be the title of my paper. No cleverness required to grab attention. If I have a more pedestrian result, I'll think up some clever title.
spookie 1y ago
As someone doing a literature review I can safely concur with this. Fancy titles often do not include the most obvious terms of what you are searching for, leading to fewer results from your query.