6 ms·
> Gemini 2.5 Pro is incredible at coding, so we’re excited to bring it to Google AI Studio’s native code editor. It’s tightly optimized with our Gen AI SDK so i
by pjmlp 2y ago
> Gemini 2.5 Pro is incredible at coding, so we’re excited to bring it to Google AI Studio’s native code editor. It’s tightly optimized with our Gen AI SDK so it’s easier to generate apps with a simple text, image, or video prompt. The new Build tab is now your gateway to quickly build and deploy AI-powered web apps. We’ve also launched new showcase examples to experiment with new models and more.
This is exactly what I see coming, between the marketing and reality of what the tool is actually able to deliver, eventually we will reach the next stage of compiler evolution, directly from AI tools into applications.
We are living through a development jump like when Assembly developers got to witness the adoption of FORTRAN.
Language flamewars are going to be a thing of the past, replaced by model wars.
It migth take a few cycles, it will come nonetheless.
- xnx 2y agoI agree. Until about 2005 it was code-on-device and run-on-device. The tools and languages were limited in absolute capabilities, but easy to understand and use. For about the past 20 years we've been in a total mess of code-on-device -> (nightmare of deployment complexity) -> run-on-cloud. We are finally entering the code-on-cloud and run-on-cloud stage. I'm hoping this will allow domain experts to more easily create valuable tools instead of having to go through technicians with arcane knowledge of languages and deployment stacks.
- cjbgkagh 2y agoHaving worked on expert systems the difficulty in creating them is often the technical limitations of the end users. The sophistication of tooling needed to bridge that gap is immense and often insurmountable. I see the AI as the bridge to that gap. That said it seems like both domain expertise and the ability to create expert systems will be commoditized at roughly the same time. While domain experts may be happy that they don’t need devs they’ll find themselves competing against other domain experts who don’t need devs either.
- glitchc 2y agoAI as the bridge to fix expert systems. Now I've heard it all! Obligatory video (sound familiar?): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLHc7rlac2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLHc7rlac2s
- cjbgkagh 2y agoI think I’m missing your point. Perhaps we don’t share the same understanding of what I mean by AI and Expert Systems. I wouldn’t call expert systems AI even though the early use of AI referred to symbolic reasoners used in expert systems. If you are capturing domain knowledge from an expert and creating a system around it, what would you call that? I think modern AI will help deliver on the promise of expert systems, and I don’t think modern AI obviates the utility of such systems. Instead of a decision support system for human users it’s a decision support system for an AI agent. The same AI agent can interface with human users with a more familiar chat interface - hence acting as a bridge. Most users will not be able to write Multidimensional Expressions or SPARQL queries and with an AI intermediary they won’t need to.
- glitchc 2y agoExpert Systems (TM) was trademarked (abandoned now) way way back in 1982. It was a licensed term that meant something very specific to those with a long background in technology. You sound new to the space and thus want to reinvent the term for your own purposes, which is a fine thing really, but an understanding of the history behind it may save you a great deal of grief. tl;dr, expert systems as a concept was hot! As an actual implementation, it was a colossal failure. The new AI hype train has always contained echoes of expert systems, and I was giddy with excitement to see someone complete the loop. The serpent eats its own tail after all. Which just goes to show that folks would be considerably more enlightened if they just read a bit more history.
- cjbgkagh 2y agoI’m not new to the space, I’ve been working in tech for a very long time. I was into ontologies since the late 90s. And I agree they were in general a colossal failure, or at least didn’t live up to the general hype, they did find success in various niches and did have a big impact on the world. Tim Bernes-Lee was coming out with the semantic web stuff in 99, OWL ontologies is 2004. I did some interesting things with Freebase. I built out huge entity models and created an entirety extraction system to a help power a search engine for large scale cataloging which saw real world use. While not my work Bing and Wolfram Alpha did use such systems to improve their search/utility. Google bought Freebase and incorporated its functionality. The DoD did have success with it, and for a while Boeing had an interesting system but AFAIK they lost a lot of expertise and it atrophied somewhat. It was in general a library science thing, like search engines were, even today I wish I could disambiguate my search queries to be able to specify which word overloading I’m referring to, be it Java the language, the city, or the coffee. I’ve spent a decent amount of time trying to introduce these concepts to regular people and have long considered it generally hopeless. I went on to work in ML and I’ve long thought it would be easier to teach a computer to use these systems than regular people. At least AI is at a point now where it can act as a bridge.
- suddenlybananas 2y ago>We are finally entering the code-on-cloud and run-on-cloud stage. Sounds like an absolute nightmare for freedom and autonomy.
- Keyframe 2y agobut only because it is
- bdangubic 2y agoSWE will be renamed to AIOps :)
- pjmlp 2y agoYou joke, but it is already here you only got the name wrong, MLOps.
- delfinom 2y agoSWE will be renamed to whatever the abbreviation is in an overseas language when AI can just be made to replace domestic experts with the cheapest college grads overseas. The problem doing so was always a lack of solid technical ability and experience for the cost cutting being done, but now? They just need to know basic english and block diagrams. I have never seen an entire profession race to make itself entirely unemployable and celebrate it. Too many people are hoping they'll be one of the lucky ones still employed and doing little work while talking to a LLM ;)
- Anon1096 2y agoHow so? It's already status quo at companies with massive monorepos like Google and Meta. Your IDE connects to a remote computer and you write and run code on it. No more fiddling around with arcane dev env setup processes it's honestly really refreshing and doesn't feel restrictive at all. On the contrary I can nuke my cloud dev environment and bring it up again in minutes without worrying about losing anything.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hooverd 2y agoFinally, companies can wrench back control from those pesky users. Only Google should have root; any other interaction should be routed through their AI! You wouldn't want to own your own device anyways, just rent it!
- neom 2y agoThis is why I think Rabbit is one of the most interesting startups around. If I could wave a wand and go pick any startup to go work at, it would be Rabbit.
- matt3D 2y agoWhich Rabbit are you meaning? When I search for Rabbit AI I get a few hits and none of them seem like the most interesting startup around.
- neom 2y agohttps://www.rabbit.tech/ https://www.rabbit.tech/ They're developing some super interesting ways of the os developing itself as you use the device, apps building themselves, stuff like that. Super early days, but I have a really really good feeling about them (I know, everyone else doesn't and I'm sure thinks I'm nuts saying this).
- nwienert 2y agoYou're not explaining why you have such a good feeling - is their team uniquely good, far ahead? Is there something specific in how they architected it? I think a lot of people are headed in this direction, they have a bad brand, the need to totally restructure their team, and probably bad equity structure now and a need for a down round, it'll be hard to get good talent.
- com2kid 2y agoThe rabbit OS project is literally the only correct path forward for AI. Hopefully they go for local on device inference, as they removes cloud costs, solving the burning pile of cash problem most AI companies have. Directly driving a user's device (or a device hooked up to a user's account at least) means an AI can do any task that a user can do, tearing down walled gardens. No more "my car doesn't allow programmatic access so I can't heat it up in the morning without opening the app." Suddenly telling an agent "if it is below 50 outside preheat my car so it is warm when I leave at 8am" becomes a simple to solve problem.
- magicalist 2y ago> This is exactly what I see coming, between the marketing and reality of what the tool is actually able to deliver, eventually we will reach the next stage of compiler evolution, directly from AI tools into applications. Is this different from other recent models trained eg for tool calling? Sounds like they fine tuned on their SDK. Maybe someday, but it's still going to be limited in what it can zero shot without you needing to edit the code. > Language flamewars are going to be a thing of the past, replaced by model wars. This does seem funny coming from you. I feel like you'll still find a way :P
- bgwalter 2y agoGemini 2.5 will write a whole Linux kernel from scratch! We are seeing a paradigm shift! This is bigger than the invention of electricity! Awesome times to be alive!
- candiddevmike 2y agoI think there will still need to be some kind of translation layer besides natural language. It's just not succinct enough (especially English, ew), especially where it matters like a rules engine. The thought of building something like an adjudication or payment system with a LLM sounds terrible.
- simonw 2y agoYou don't need to use natural language to write your rules engine. LLMs speak every language under the sun, real or made up. You could define your rules in Prolog if you wanted - that's just as effective a way to communicate them to an LLM as English. Or briefly describe some made-up DSL and then use that. For coding LLMs the goal is to have the LLM represent the logic clearly in whatever programming language it's using. You can communicate with it however you want. I've dropped in screenshots of things related to what I'm building before, that works too.
- geraneum 2y ago> describe some made-up DSL Ironically, for something like the parent suggested i.e. a rules engine, this is the main work.
- stickfigure 2y ago...as long as your application is only a few thousand lines of code. Context windows are still tiny by "real world app" standards, and this doesn't seem to be changing significantly.
- CuriouslyC 2y agoI regularly put 50k LoC codebases in gemini, it has a 1M context window and actually uses it well.
- sepositus 2y agoI've had the opposite experience. If I give it that much context it starts to hallucinate parts of the application that it very much has access to look up. This only starts happening at large context windows.
- jacob019 2y agoDepends on what you're doing. Too much context and code generation gets sloppy, but it does a decent job attending to the large context to answer questions, analyze control flow, investigate bugs, review style consistency and guideline violations, etc.
- stickfigure 2y agoLet me know when it handles 1.5M lines.
- vineyardmike 2y agoLet me know when you meet a person that can handle 1.5M lines, because most people I've worked with can't. Certainly I've never worked on something that required even reading that much... Especially when targeted search options exist to find just specific function/class implementations as needed.
- stickfigure 2y ago
- mirsadm 2y agoRemind me in a couple of years when this product is abandoned.
- NicoJuicy 2y agoIt will fail where all other tools fail. Migrating databases, scaling issues, ..