5 ms·
'Turbocharged' Mitochondria Power Birds' Epic Migratory Journeys
- parpfish 1y agoIt’s interesting how “turbo” has had so much semantic drift that people don’t even know it’s a specific component in an engine. They just think it means “fast”. Wouldn’t be surprised to eventually see a “turbo” trim levels for EVs someday.
- neogodless 1y agohttps://finder.porsche.com/us/en-US/details/porsche-macan-turbo-electric-new-EPMOE0 https://finder.porsche.com/us/en-US/details/porsche-macan-tu... Too late.
- tim333 1y agoAlthough that is an electric equivalent of an actual turbo car rather than just trim.
- neogodless 1y agoWell, the Taycan is electric only, and has a Turbo trim! https://www.porsche.com/usa/models/taycan/taycan-models/taycan-turbo-s/ https://www.porsche.com/usa/models/taycan/taycan-models/tayc...
- m3kw9 1y agoWas gonna say, do they know how turbos work?
- CGMthrowaway 1y agoIn fairness, they put "turbocharged" in quotes.
- 762236 1y agoWith the right level of abstraction, we can say that there's only one of four fundamental forces generating the birds' and engine work, electromagnetism, and so maybe can work a relationship about turbos in that way.
- kridsdale1 1y agoFlight relies on gravity. And I wouldn’t want to be a bird experiencing a sudden loss of the Strong or Weak force.
- jchw 1y agoUsing "turbocharged" as a metaphor for something being made faster seems reasonable enough to me. Not all engines have turbochargers, installing one makes it perform better by improving combustion, profit? Of course I'm not a car person so my understanding of an ICE is pretty surface level, but it seems like a decent metaphor. I'm not sure most people knew what a turbocharger was to begin with.
- nh23423fefe 1y agobut thats the semantic drift right? imagine if i said something like, "after removing all extraneous weight and safety features, my car has been turbocharged." kinda nonsensical imo, if someone said this i'd just assume they lacked a thesaurus
- neogodless 1y ago> The scientists found that birds experiencing the “migration” condition had more mitochondria, and that those mitochondria had a greater capacity to make energy (opens a new tab), compared to those in the “nonmigratory” birds. This suggested that during migration, the birds’ mitochondria are “turbocharged,” Coulson said. So this isn't too terrible. It's a bit more like overclocking than turbocharging. A typical ICE turbocharger is a recycler - the exhaust gases are used to spin the turbo which in turn forces air/oxygen into the combustion chamber (cylinder) at a faster rate, which can be tuned alongside fuel intake for increased power. Of course, this tends to be harder on the engine and must be accounted for in engine design. It's not free, and you don't want every engine to be turbo. And rather than be good for endurance it's really good for bursts of power.
- hinkley 1y agoRocket engines have turbochargers that run before primary combustion. Just to make things more confusing.
- neogodless 1y agoPresumably not off exhaust? In automobiles, if they are powered by something other than exhaust (e.g. electricity) are called "superchargers." Ah quick web search, I believe they do run off exhaust using "pre-burners" that burn before the burn.
- nh23423fefe 1y agokinda double weird when ATP synthase is said to be a molecular turbine. we put a turbo in your turbo
- hinkley 1y agoNot enough people are old enough to get the more accurate analogy which would be multiple carburetors.
- kridsdale1 1y agoOne of my all time favorite molecules. Up there with Actin and DNA itself. Biology is crazy, man.
- nh23423fefe 1y agocollagen!
- SoleilAbsolu 1y agoHaha as a car enthusiast, whenever I see "turbo" my next thought is always the inherent downside, "turbo lag" (the non-zero time it takes for the turbo to actually kick in)!
- hinkley 1y agoI’m a little surprised we don’t have mild hybrids with blowers on them. Split the turbocharger into a recovery unit, genset, a supercharger and a battery and no more lag.
- MadnessASAP 1y agoWeight, size, cost, and loss of efficiency. There are better things you could do to increase engine performance that are lighter, smaller, and cheaper. Also of you really really want to defeat turbo lag. The easiest way is to seriously delay ignition timing so the fuel is still burning as it enters the turbine leaving more energy for it to extract and therefore staying spooled up. edit: Not to say your idea wouldn't work, indeed I'd love to see it. Its just not a practical solution. Not that In ever let practicality stop me. Edit to the edit: https://dieselnet.com/tech/engine_whr_turbocompound.php https://dieselnet.com/tech/engine_whr_turbocompound.php https://www.eere.energy.gov/vehiclesandfuels/pdfs/deer_2004/session4/2004_deer_hopmann.pdf https://www.eere.energy.gov/vehiclesandfuels/pdfs/deer_2004/... So, ya know, disregard everything above.
- hinkley 1y agoThere’s been talk for years of just scavenging energy from the exhaust for hybrid drivetrains. To power the peripherals if nothing else. Part of it is that there’s another reason besides a turbo to have a little extra energy left in the exhaust: thermal catalysis of noxious chemicals in the exhaust flow. So there’s a bit of unburned fuel going to the cat for emissions control and people have wondered if we can take some of it back after the converter. For a while every time there was a breakthrough in solid state heat recovery someone mentioned vehicle exhaust.
- xeonmc 1y ago
- gherkinnn 1y agoYou're behind the times, turbo has drifted (heh) far in to meaning 'fast' of sorts: - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbo_Pascal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbo_Pascal - https://www.specialized.com/il/en/turbo-levo-4-pro/p/4218703?color=5363218-4218703 https://www.specialized.com/il/en/turbo-levo-4-pro/p/4218703... - https://turbo.hotwired.dev https://turbo.hotwired.dev (Drifts right back to turbo charger, but using one as the logo) Or it can be used to amplify as in "Turbo Clippy": https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42865194 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42865194
- hinkley 1y agoDon’t forget the turbo button, which is almost as old as turbo pascal.
- jonplackett 1y agoI’m curious did anyone here have a turbo button that actually did speed up performance? My 386SX had a turbo button but all it did was turn on a light.
- acdha 1y agoIt varied but the older ones definitely had a visible impact if you had something CPU bound running. There was an old helicopter-themed game my dad had which would start running impossibly fast because everything was based on cycle counts rather than actual time.
- hinkley 1y agoI was disappointed to discover that the screen scrolling in Warcraft III was too fast to make large maps usable. I was so excited to find that game used and I couldn’t play it in the early 00’s.
- hinkley 1y agoFor most of us it was a misnomer because it was a lag button not a turbo button. It defaulted to on. If you turned it off it would make the machine slower, allowing certain programs to run properly instead of too fast for humans. But we all have stories of a friend whose machine was slow because they hit the button not understanding what it does. For them it did become the turbo button.
- ajb 1y agoIt seems like mitochondria research is going to have a lot of impact over the next decades. For example, apparently some people with fatigue diseases have damaged mitochondria (eg, Dianna Cowern aka ThePhysicsGirl who has had a terrible long COVID illness)
- parpfish 1y agomitochondria is the powerhouse of the fatigue research
- Aurornis 1y ago> apparently some people with fatigue diseases have damaged mitochondria (eg, Dianna Cowern aka ThePhysicsGirl who has had a terrible long COVID illness) In these conditions it’s more likely that mitochondrial dysfunction is part of the chain of events leading to the fatigue, not necessarily the root cause of the condition. Also I have to tread very lightly on this topic to avoid giving the wrong idea: Be a little cautious when taking statements about Long COVID and ME/CFS from individuals, as it’s not uncommon for people to present hypotheses as more concrete than the research suggests. With all due respect to Dianna Cowern, some of her past updates on the topic have blurred the lines between conjecture and fact and she’s collaborated with at least one Long COVID / ME/CFS organization that is known for having members that are sometimes less than scientific about their personal theories. It’s a very difficult and complex topic and it can be hard for patients to stay on top of all the different directions the research is looking.
- loa_in_ 1y agoIn these conditions it’s more likely that mitochondrial dysfunction is part of the chain of events leading to the fatigue, not necessarily the root cause of the condition. Can you elaborate, what is this based on?
- treyd 1y agoTo rephrase, it's possible she already had an underlying mitochondrial dysfunction that was not caused by COVID, but then when she caught the virus it triggered some symptomatic metabolic dysfunction that's persisting even after she cleared the virus. This kind of thing is known to happen in some people with some viral diseases, but it's poorly understood.
- aurizon 1y agoSome longevity researchers could investigate the DNA sequence of the mitochondrial DNA(a discrete object) to see if there is a length of life correlation = CRISPR edit towards longer life. It would be easily explored in mice and then there could be some edits in an egg very soon after fertilisation to replace that mitochondrial DNA in that egg to see the result. Might be a hard task to find/replace all these mitochondria and maintain life? In a single mouse egg = how many are there? A search finds this interesting paper = a good rabbit hole indeed. It is an area of intense research. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4684129/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4684129/
- reubenswartz 1y agoThere are ~100,000 mitochondria in a human egg cell-- I think that's a pretty tall order.
- aurizon 1y agoYes, I suspect is starts with extra metabolic capability = greater need for the task it is being prepared for. Since women have all their oocytes from an early age - speculating they might mature for fallopian release, and in that maturation mitochondrial proliferation occurs? Alternatively this might occur at puberty with hormonal triggering oocytes in some sequential manner as evolutionary efficiency might be a 'just in time' process?
- koeng 1y agoIt's doable https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-33530-3 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-022-33530-3 100,000 x 6kbp == 600 million, or less than 1/5 of our genome. Difficult part is the barcoding bits, but that is not THAT hard.
- reubenswartz 1y agoreading them would be hard enough, but editing them seems pretty darn hard.
- 1y ago
- jonplackett 1y agoWould be interesting if there’s some trigger hormone or other mechanism that triggers turbo mode. It’ll be being used in the Tour de France in no time if so. (FYI I’m not a biologist and have no idea what I’m talking about)
- xg15 1y agoAlso if this is something that is specific to the birds' mitochondria or could be triggered in mitochondria of any species.
- kridsdale1 1y agoWe’ve been evolutionarily divergent for at least a hundred million years so it seems slim, but not zero. Also don’t forget that mitochondria have their own genome and that it’s undeniable that the avian mito-dna lineage would also experience Darwinian (haha, apt) forces spurring the developments of these capabilities that our ancestors didn’t go through.
- mulmen 1y ago> We’ve been evolutionarily divergent for at least a hundred million years so it seems slim, but not zero. But how much has our mitochondria differed in that time?
- sigmaisaletter 1y ago"With few exceptions, all animal mitochondrial genomes contain the same 37 genes: two for rRNAs, 13 for proteins and 22 for tRNAs. (...) the comparison of animal mitochondrial gene arrangements has become a very powerful means for inferring ancient evolutionary relationships, since rearrangements appear to be unique, generally rare events that are unlikely to arise independently in separate evolutionary lineages." Source: Boore (1999) Animal mitochondrial genomes. Nucleic Acids Res. 1999 Apr 15;27(8):1767–1780 Hyperlink: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC148383/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC148383/ i.e. mtDNA changes a lot less than our "normal" cell nucleus nDNA
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoRelated: Mitochondria Are More Than Powerhouses–They're the Motherboard of the Cell https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44052909 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44052909
- kridsdale1 1y agoOne of the interesting findings in the article’s linked paper was that vitamin E is an effective dietary antioxidant (in birds) but only if they do 2 hours of cardio per day.
- koeng 1y agoFun fact: respiration is what really caused eukaryogenesis and the ability for multicellular life to occur. If archaea (what our nuclear genomes are derived from) weren't being kinda weird in the deep ocean, we would never have existed. Bacteria and archaea (other than eukaryote ancestor) have never created multicellular life. And it's because respiration. (cross posting below from my comment on another thread) For efficient respiration, you need to have the translation/transcription of certain ATP synthase genes near to the membrane for basically JIT-ing them when ready to maintain membrane potential, and hence energy generation. Otherwise, the membrane potential falls apart. This simple need is why there are zero multicellular bacteria and multicellularity evolved 6 times in eukaryotes. By decoupling the rest of the genome from the JIT bits (ie, mitochondrial DNA), you can scale energy independently of genetic information. So if you need 1000x the energy, you need like 5% more DNA (mitochondrial DNA) instead of 1000x more DNA in your genome. Some estimates say that our eukaryotic genes are in charge of 5000x more energy than the equivalent bacterial gene. Hence, our genomes can inflate that much and its fine. And they have. All that inflation lets us have bullshit hang around in our genome, and hey, sometimes evolution figures out something to do with all that bullshit. We evolved 1000x more complexity than bacteria because we decoupled the performance code from the rest of the code.
- reubenswartz 1y agoAlso worth noting that it took hundreds of millions (~1Bish) years to go from prokaryotes to single cell eukaryotes, and then another similar interval to get to multicellular creatures.
- gcanyon 1y ago“We were just amazed and interested in how can these birds fly for thousands of miles without stopping, at a really high intensity, when most of us can barely run a 5K" On the one hand, sure, it's interesting, and the article digs in and is interesting in general -- but that phrase feels off and trite, similar to saying "We were amazed that cheetahs can run over 60mph, while most humans can't manage 10mph" or "We were amazed that sperm whales can hold their breath for 90 minutes while most humans can't manage a minute"