4 ms·
Startup enables 100-year bridges with corrosion-resistant steel
- bell-cot 1y agoI might take the article seriously if it openly admitted that anti-rust coatings on rebar have been a thing for a century-ish, then talked honestly about which applications this new tech was actually better for. One clear downside to stainless-coated rebar: During construction, rebar is very commonly welded. Welding stainless ain't just the same tools & techniques as welding conventional rebar. Plus, welding stainless gets you into chromium hazmat territory.
- garbagewoman 1y agoNot sure why it would be any different when welding - the stainless coating isn’t the weight bearing part
- bagels 1y agoDifferent welding chemistry, different welding requirements (filler, temperature, possibly process). As the GP points out, the chromium when vaporized is a lot worse for you than what's typically in plain steel. Not just that, but, if you weld it, now you have exposed the plain steel and have invited rust inside the coating.
- garbagewoman 1y agoYou wouldn’t be welding the stainless
- bagels 1y agoHave you done much welding? I'd like to know how you imagine this is achieved.
- dylan604 1y agoif you're only welding the stainless coating, i doubt that would be as strong as if you were to weld the inner rebar directly. do you expect them to re-coat with stainless after these welds?
- garbagewoman 1y agoThat’s my point, you would not be welding the stainless part
- brendoelfrendo 1y agoIf your welding disturbs the coating and leaves gaps or cracks in the stainless coating, it will allow air and moisture to contact and corrode the carbon steel core. And once the core corrodes, the stainless coating becomes the weight bearing part, and you have a massive problem. Assembling this would presumably require some care and expertise beyond normal rebar.
- garbagewoman 1y agoOk sure yes that does sound bad, so any welded parts would need to be protected
- brudgers 1y agoStainless steel rebar is uncommon for the same reasons galvanized rebar and epoxy coated rebar are not common. As materials they are massively more expensive than carbon steel and first cost matters because public infrastructure is financed with bonds and financial markets dictate bond terms of 30-40 years. To put it another way, any belief that construction markets are inefficient is statistically a dunning-kruger to too many sigmas. Construction goes back at least as far as anything we call as civilization.
- chongli 1y agoThere is a big inefficiency in construction markets but it's not in materials, it's in labour. Immigration laws starve construction companies of workers. With unfettered immigration it would be much easier to build simply due to a large availability of unskilled labour. The other side of the coin is of course planning, zoning approval, codes, bylaws, and other regulations that slow down construction projects and discourage development. We've made it very hard to build because we really don't want to build. Homeowners are mostly interested in protecting their investment which means keeping housing demand high.
- epicureanideal 1y ago“With unfettered immigration...” Or use well paid skilled labor and machines?
- chongli 1y agoConstruction sites need unskilled labour to haul things around, clean up the jobsite, hold heavy objects in place until they’re fastened, and the like. There aren’t any construction site robots that I know of which can replace all the jobs an untrained but otherwise strong and healthy human can do.
- brudgers 1y agoA strong trained human can do all the things you mention with less supervision and in less time. In other words if there is a lot of work for untrained workers, it is a poorly run construction site. In a well run construction project, trained workers clean up after themselves and installers don’t need additional people holding up heavy objects during placement because they bring proper tools, staff, and falsework with them.
- entangledqubit 1y agoStill waiting for basalt rebar to become more of a thing. This version plays to the steel industry at least?
- londons_explore 1y ago5% stainless by weight is going to add quite a decent chunk to the costs...
- bagels 1y agoI'm sure the governments buying bridges don't care, but 5% increased cost for a multiple in longevity seems like a good investment.
- londons_explore 1y agoWhen one rolls dissimilar metals together, they tend not to bond. If the bond breaks in the end product, the building falls down as the carbon steel inner core slides out of the stainless coating. How is that solved?
- idiotsecant 1y agoOh no! Use of dissimilar metals in a load-carrying application is bound to result in structural failure?!?! Quick, someone get started on replacing the gazillion miles of Aluminum Conductor Steel–Reinforced (ACSR) cable that run our power networks!!! While you're at it make sure to get rid of all the Titanium-clad carbon steel pressure vessels used in marine applications,Zinc-Aluminum 'Galfan' rebar, steel-aluminum galvanic isolation ship hull transitions, and any of the other bazillion places we do this! Quick!!!
- mmooss 1y agoThe technological innovation is to solve the problem of why this wasn't done previously - preventing corrosion with stainless steel coating seems obvious, so what held people back? Unfortunately, the article doesn't describe the problem or how they solved it - does anyone know?
- abakker 1y agothis is costly and difficult. The reason they didn't do this before is that it is only necessary in some construction, and because rebar has to be as cheap as possible.
- cyberax 1y agoStainless steel is not _completely_ stainless. It corrodes just fine if it doesn't have access to oxygen to form a protective oxide film (crevasse corrosion). But the bigger problem is that stainless steel has significantly worse mechanical characteristics, _and_ it's significantly more expensive. Regular steel can also be protected from corrosion using paint, zinc coating, cathodic protection, etc. Engineering is always an exercise in trade-offs. And it's almost always better to build four bridges that can stand for 100 years, instead of one bridge that can stand for 500 years.
- amluto 1y ago> But the bigger problem is that stainless steel has significantly worse mechanical characteristics This is a common claim, but I’m not sure I really believe it. Even for applications that require especially good mechanical characteristics, e.g. tool steels, good stainless alloys can be very good. I would believe that the stainless alloys that are widely available in large quantities at somewhat reasonable prices for structural use (e.g. 304 and 316 stainless steel) have mediocre mechanical properties.
- cyberax 1y ago??? Tool steels are not stainless, as anyone who forgot to stow away tools properly can confirm.
- gitroom 1y ago[dead]
- burnt-resistor 1y agoThere are a couple of ways to prevent corrosion of bare metal even in the absence corrosion inhibitors: keep the humidity low and the Ph high. Coatings, inhibitors, and additional barriers to water/moisture intrusion help too.
- pmarreck 1y agoInstead of stainless steel coated rebar, someone needs to start a startup that rediscovers the Roman "self-healing cement" formula that uses lime or something
- 0xbadcafebee 1y agoThey already did. It's just a more expensive formulation of concrete. In general you use a mix of concrete that's as cheap as you can afford, and tuned to the specific engineering requirements of that concrete structure. (We mostly use concrete because it's cheaper than alternatives)
- guywithahat 1y agoI’m pretty sure the secret to that was not inventing 4-ton vehicles. Plus there were some benefits to saltwater for construction near the ocean and some of the local soil/volcanic ash had beneficial properties, but vehicle weight was the biggest factor as far as I’m aware
- amluto 1y agoI doubt that the magical Roman concrete has any appreciable tensile strength. Sometimes reinforcement is not optional.
- 0xbadcafebee 1y ago> Allium adds a thin protective layer of stainless steel on top of traditional steel rebar to make it more resistant to corrosion So it's like galvanizing but with stainless steel. Thing is, stainless steel still rusts; just how much depends on a number of factors. And if you slightly nick the stainless coating to expose the iron rebar, now the whole rebar rusts. Maybe it will reduce the amount of corrosion, and that's great. But I highly doubt it would double the life of bridges.
- fastball 1y agoThe claim is that it will reduce corrosion by 3x. If corrosion of rebar is the primary bottleneck to bridge longevity, a 3x longer life seems like a reasonable claim. Of course in practice if this rebar is used in a bridge you might start to discover other things become the bottleneck, but that remains to be seen.
- h4ck_th3_pl4n3t 1y agoAnd the acidic rain is contributing to the problem. The reason infrastructure rusts so quickly in those areas is the pollution through gasoline and diesel based engines. The rain collects the gases and binds them, leading to to an acidic solution that attacks the metal and concrete. In Europe there is a startup that tries to combat this with embedded bacteria and limestone plates that are put into the concrete. If the concrete gets a crack, the rain gets into the crack and activates the bacteria which is producing limestone to fill in the gaps. [1] [2] That approach has a much better chance to improve infrastructure lifespan in my opinion, because just putting more steel into it is not something that's affordable. Iron as a resource is way too rare as it is already. [1] https://www.epo.org/en/news-events/european-inventor-award/meet-the-finalists/hendrik-marius-jonkers https://www.epo.org/en/news-events/european-inventor-award/m... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacillus_pseudofirmus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bacillus_pseudofirmus
- telotortium 1y agoCan someone tell me why rebar isn’t more often cathodically protected with electric current? I don’t think much power is required to resist corrosion, and it shouldn’t be too hard to test for electric continuity in the field.
- ta988 1y agoHow do you do it at scale and without major transformations of the production lines. Now you need to handle liquids and electricity and your process is not as continuous.
- conradev 1y agoCan you do it with magnets?
- amluto 1y agoI can guess a few reasons: Cost. This may not be cheap. Rebar is often part of a structure’s electrical ground. Any protective current supplied might end up exiting through other connected grounds and doing little good. How do you do this on a bridge? The rebar is one electrode. Where’s the other? Even if you get it working, I would be a bit nervous about the reaction products. If there’s any current flow, then something is being reduced. If the medium is moist concrete, then it might well be water that gets reduced to hydrogen gas and hydroxide ions. The hydroxide ions may be harmless, but the hydrogen could be problematic.