4 ms·
The "reverse engineering" clause of the DMCA protects reverse engineering, rather than forbidding it. Take a look at 17 USC §1201(f) (http://www.law.cornell.ed
by schoen 14y ago
The "reverse engineering" clause of the DMCA protects reverse engineering, rather than forbidding it. Take a look at 17 USC §1201(f) (http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201#f http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1201#f). The DMCA only applies in the first place if a "technological measure" "in the ordinary course of its operation" "effectively controls access to a work", which needn't always be the case for reverse engineering. The idea that the DMCA expressly forbids reverse engineering is a misconception.
Microsoft eventually changed its position on Kinect and never filed a lawsuit over the reverse engineering. So, we don't have a court decision suggesting that there was anything legally improper in any way about the Kinect reverse engineering.
Hackers should be upset about §1201 and speak out against it, but not be gratuitously scared off from doing things!