Interesting! Both my partner and i felt that Leonardo DiCaprio (while we consider him a pretty good actor in general) didn't quite fit that "timeless" label for

Interesting! Both my partner and i felt that Leonardo DiCaprio (while we consider him a pretty good actor in general) didn't quite fit that "timeless" label for the Gatsby role....while we felt that both Carey Mulligan and Tobey Maguire did indeed feel right at home in such roles...at least to our eyes. Also, while we do love the original film with Robert Redford, we did also really like the modern (and quite different!) take of the Gatsby film created by Baz Lurhman. :-)