7 ms·
NASA Proposal to Revive Nuclear Thermal Space Propulsion Development
- wazoox 14y agoIt's not clear that this proposal is actually coming from NASA. That would be great news nonetheless.
- pjscott 14y agoThe part of this that surprised me is that the amount of radioactive fission products in the reactor is fairly insignificant for the first part of a mission -- a nuclear thermal rocket can be well out of Earth's orbit before it's as radioactive as the RTG that powers the Curiosity rover.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoGood luck explaining that to people.
- jlgreco 14y agoHonestly the best way to handle that would probably be to simply not mention it. If directly asked about it, just start spewing jargon at them until they get bored and walk away. Just don't give them something that would make a good soundbite.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoThat sounds like it would backfire horribly. Honestly, it's a lose-lose situation. If you didn't mention it, they'd spin it as some sort of cover-up; if you spewed jargon at them, they'd just take whatever snippet sounded good to them and spin it into something unrecognizable that fits their agenda. Journalists never let truth get in the way of a good story.
- jlgreco 14y agoYou would need to pick your jargon carefully. The words that tend to set people off are pretty particular. Just avoid words like "radioactive", "isotope", any element name, "nuclear", etc. Don't call it a "reactor", call it a "thermal generator". Be honest and open about everything, but don't brag about it on twitter or in press releases. The idea is to act like it is nothing special to give off the impression that it is nothing special. Make it all seem very routine and boring. Hyping actually boring aspects of the mission could also help. Do lots of things like making twitter accounts for rocks: https://twitter.com/N165Mars https://twitter.com/N165Mars
- Wingman4l7 14y agoWell, just look at the kerfuffle over the Cassini RTG back in 1997: Reporter: "Could this probe fail on launch, re-enter the atmosphere, and explode, showering the U.S. with radioactive particles?" Scientist: "Yes, but there's a one-in-a-million chance of that happening, and we have safeguards against that..." Headline: "SPACE PROBE COULD EXPLODE AND SHOWER RADIATION EVERYWHERE!" The key here is the "Yes, but..." -- if a reporter wants a sensational story, they'll find a way to get it, even if they have to play fast and loose with the truth to do it. (Thanks for that Twitter account link -- I love NASA's sense of humor.)
- jlgreco 14y agoYeah, they really botched Cassini. However with the experiance they gained from that, and a healthy awareness that PR issues like that can happen in the first place, I think they could overcome any issues they might run into. The answer they gave was correct, and they were correct to not be concerned. They know RTGs are safe, but they forgot that the public doesn't know that. (and yeah, I love NASA's twitter accounts :D)
- sliverstorm 14y agoAn excellent summary of what you describe, in comic form http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=1623 http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=1623
- DeepDuh 14y agoCan someone ELI5 how that works?
- johngalt 14y agoThe fuel that goes into the reactor isn't that dangerous, but the spent fuel is very dangerous.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoUranium or Plutonium isn't that dangerous, it's fission byproducts that are super dangerous, and they only build up over time.
- arethuza 14y agoI'm not sure I'd call plutonium metal "not that dangerous" - it is pretty toxic, can catch fire spontaneously and once if does catch fire you have to be really careful trying to put the fire out. There is an excellent book on the history of the Rocky Flats nuclear weapons plant near Denver that describes some of the problems with handling plutonium on an industrial scale: http://www.amazon.com/Making-Real-Killing-Rocky-Nuclear/dp/0826327982 http://www.amazon.com/Making-Real-Killing-Rocky-Nuclear/dp/0... Edit: Of course these things are relative. I guess compared to chemicals like chlorine trifluoride or FOOF it is pretty tame from a chemical perspective: http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2008/02/26/sand_wont_save_you_this_time.php http://pipeline.corante.com/archives/2008/02/26/sand_wont_sa...
- InclinedPlane 14y agoWell yes. What I meant to say was that in trace amounts in the atmosphere Plutonium isn't terribly dangerous. When you're working with bulk metal there are heavy metal toxicity and radioactivity concerns, of course, and if you're working with powder or fines then that can be particularly dangerous in terms of radioactivity exposure (because Plutonium in your lungs is pretty much where it can do the most damage). But compared to fission byproducts like I-131 or Sr-90 which are both crazy radioactive and eagerly taken up by your body and placed into your bones and your thyroid, Plutonium barely registers.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoOne of the best ways to take advantage of an NTR is to use it as an upper stage where it will only ever operate outside of the atmosphere.
- nextbigfuture 14y agoThe presentation was made at the NASA Future on space operations workshops
- rbanffy 14y agoI'll start considering links to nextbigfuture as blogspam unless they contain links to the presentations (and referring material) from NASA servers. edit: Sorry. I mistook the first link for a cluster of tags. I'd like to offer help making the layout clearer. I made a couple observations on the Disqus discussion on the page.
- nextbigfuture 14y agoThe first link is to the 24 page presentation from the NASA FISO (future in space operations archive). What is your problem ?
- rbanffy 14y agoI'm very sorry. I mistook the first link for a cluster of tags. Can I help you with the site layout? We could make it much clearer. I think I just proved it's not idiot proof. :-(
- uvdiv 14y agoIt's the first line of the post. http://spirit.as.utexas.edu/~fiso/telecon/Borowski_6-27-12/Borowski_6-27-12.ppt http://spirit.as.utexas.edu/~fiso/telecon/Borowski_6-27-12/B...
- Wingman4l7 14y agoThe 1950s/60s NERVA program that the blog post mentions in passing: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA Project Rover: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Rover http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Rover For hard scifi buffs, check out Stephen Baxter's space-program-alt-hist novel Voyage, where (among other things) NERVA is revived for a manned Mars shot. I'm kinda surprised to see this; I thought that public acceptance of nuclear-related programs would be at a low, after Fukushima. Heck, I remember when people were kicking up a fuss over Cassini's RTG back in 1997. Are we going to revive Project Orion next? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_%28nuclear_propulsion%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_%28nuclear_propul...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- DeepDuh 14y agoAll I ever heard before was Project Orion, but after reading about Project Rover, I don't understand why you would want Orion's design. Isn't Rover superior in every way? It appears to me that Orion uses a much smaller fraction of the released nuclear energy, leading to a bigger waste of resources and smaller payload to total weight ratio. Furthermore it's harder to use Rover as a weapon, but maybe this would be a minus for some of the potential investors.
- Wingman4l7 14y agoWell, Project Orion was certainly more dramatic -- detonating hundreds of nukes to punch a rocket up into space. It was also top-secret at the time; that explains its mystique. As far as being a superior choice, I don't think it's quite apples to apples. Project Orion (nuclear pulse propulsion) was designed to get very large payloads directly into orbit. Nuclear thermal rockets like NERVA were apparently designed to be used as drop-in replacements for upper stages on conventional chemical rockets, or as space "tugs" in orbit. That might imply that it was difficult to design a nuclear thermal rocket which would deliver the high initial thrust(?) necessary to lift a payload directly out of our gravity well (but IANA rocket scientist, so I may be mistaken on this). That said, a small blurb on Wikipedia does mention that "Robert Bussard proposed the Single-Stage-To-Orbit "Aspen" vehicle using a nuclear thermal rocket for propulsion and liquid hydrogen propellant[...]" -- so maybe it would indeed have been a superior design choice in the end.
- misterfusion 14y agoNuclear propulsion will open vast horizons to the future of mankind. I think the best option will be fusion-powered plasma turbines. http://youtu.be/ro5-QYqqxzM http://youtu.be/ro5-QYqqxzM
- rektide 14y agoI was going to say it looks like a Bussard IEC (Inertial Electrostatic Containment) with a VASIMR (Variable Specific Impulse Magnetoplasma Rocket) tacked on the back, but there's a dozen things about the IEC that they're talking that seem different, and they spent little enough time detailing the thruster that comparisons v.s. VASIMR are a little tricky. Lol, wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polywell http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polywell http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VASIMR http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VASIMR
- misterfusion 14y agoSome people do not even know the difference between a carrot and a screwdriver. Please, take a closer look. The concepts have key differences. Bussard IEC has recirculation of electrons, virtual cathode. VASIMR is single phase instead of multiphase.
- misterfusion 14y agoThere are a lot of key differences. Bussard IEC can be characterized by recirculation of electrons, virtual cathode, "wiffleball" magnetic compression. VASIMR can be characterized by helicon antenna, single phase instead of multiphase.
- misterfusion 14y agoAlmost all fusion approaches have some similarities between them. For example, Polywell looks like the "Magnetic Well for Plasma Confinement". http://www.google.com/patents/US4007392?printsec=drawing http://www.google.com/patents/US4007392?printsec=drawing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polywell http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polywell Multicusp plasma containment was already previously widely used. http://www.google.com/patents?id=A9wyAAAAEBAJ http://www.google.com/patents?id=A9wyAAAAEBAJ
- comicjk 14y agoVery smart to link nuclear thermal technology to manned Mars missions. It would be wonderful if public enthusiasm after Curiosity makes further development in this area possible. I want my spaceship!