9 ms·
"It’s only a matter of time before robotic cars outperform their human-driven counterparts." How much time are we talking? I don't agree with this statement i
by protomyth 14y ago
"It’s only a matter of time before robotic cars outperform their human-driven counterparts."
How much time are we talking? I don't agree with this statement in anything like the near (decades) term, particularly if we are talking actual races and not timed run events.
- politician 14y agoReally? I'd expect that robotic cars will dominate closed-course races sooner rather than later simply due to the fact that the course is known, can be mapped down to the millimeter, and can be simulated offline. AI cars don't get bored, distracted, suffer fatigue, or need the physical stamina to drive an optimal line rain or shine hundreds of times in a row.
- protomyth 14y agoThere is a lot to racing, particularly interaction with other, drafting, rubber on road, etc. I don't think it is going to be that easy.
- malkia 14y agoNot a racing fan at all, but from friends I know there are certain strategies involved if each team consist of two or more members. One member can stall other racers, helping his team-mate advance. Again, this is just from talking to them.
- protomyth 14y agoYep, happens in open wheel and drafting with teammates in stock car (although that isn't even totally true). It seems like it is much more prevalent where one sponsor sponsors multiple cars.
- Empedocles99 14y agoMapping down to the millimeter is great, but the conditions on track are continually changing. Weather (rain, sun, track surface temperature, air temperature), debris (dirt, grass, marbles, spectator thrown shoes), rubber being laid down on the track, changing condition of the driver's vehicle and other vehicles are all things that need to be contended with. Simulation helps, assuredly, and is used in human based efforts extensively, but you can't exactly just play back your simulation on a real track and expect the car to stay on course at race speed.
- politician 14y agoThat's a good point, for instance, Google's car has both on-board sensors and annotated route information. I wasn't suggesting that offline simulations be replayed, but simply that the problem space is to some extent a more perfect knowledge environment than the open road will ever be. Cheers.
- protomyth 14y agoProbably easier than open road, but the surface is a constant problem. NASCAR for example runs multiple races at some venues where the spring and summer races act totally different. Some of the differences are heat, rain between practice and race (rubber on track difference), different tire formula, possible resurfacing, and changes to rules (aero or engine). Restrictor plate racing with a computer car mixed in would be extremely interesting. NASCAR does not allow telemetry, speedometers, or fuel gauges. This would make for an interesting computer car in these parameters.
- adrianpike 14y agoActually, in some aspects, we're already there! :) Computers can run a car at the limits of its traction circle much better than humans can, even with nothing more than an accelerometer. I've done some hacking around this, and it turns out that you can go about it fairly naïvely, code-wise, and do way better than even good amateur racers. Unfortunately, I don't have access to any top F1 drivers to datalog them side by side with my software, but maybe someday. In terms of the quickest path around a given course, computers are _way_ better than humans at that. There's the official "racing line", which is a generally accepted fastest line, but as you can create more acceleration, the line actually flattens out towards the shortest route through a given section. Take a look at something like Spec Miata vs an AWD time attack car for a great demonstration of this. Humans still have the edge on understanding & interpreting the environment. There's a lot of work being done in this area, though - I suspect we'll get some fairly robust stuff that's available to us on the open market in a few years. Then there's the fatigue factor. Heck, if nothing else, having to cart around 150-180lbs of meat with fairly tall packaging and some weird requirements about having to see and what kind of forces you can exert on it is a bit of a drag to making the quickest possible wheeled vehicle. Sorry for the wall of text - this is something I've been hacking around a bunch for the last while, as it's the intersection of a bunch of my interests. Drop me a line if you want to chat more about it sometime.
- protomyth 14y ago"Heck, if nothing else, having to cart around 150-180lbs of meat with fairly tall packaging and some weird requirements about having to see and what kind of forces you can exert on it is a bit of a drag to making the quickest possible wheeled vehicle." I think I should have gone into more detail, as I believe that the statement from the article refers to entering a computer controlled car into a race with humans. The interaction is serious important, and knowing the fastest line doesn't mean your car will get to take the fastest line if someone is already there. Pitting is going to be interesting. Some race series, NASCAR, only allow for a limited group of sensors. I would guess something like F-1 or Indy would be easier since they have more allowed telemetry. I would imagine a NASCAR driver robot is going to have a tough time telling the pit what exactly is wrong.