2 ms·
Long article, but the best one I've run across explaining the inputs used to choose design tolerances, the advances in those methods over the years, and where t
by _delirium 14y ago
Long article, but the best one I've run across explaining the inputs used to choose design tolerances, the advances in those methods over the years, and where the Fukushima design and later maintenance was and wasn't in accordance with best practices.
The overall conclusion is that it was known by the early 2000s that the plant's worst-case tsunami estimate, used as its design basis, was no longer sufficient, given improved understanding of tsunamis. At that time, a significant upgrade should have been initiated, since the original design-basis tsunami of 3.1 meters was no longer believed to be a good estimate of the worst case. But those reports basically got buried and nothing was acted on.
Side note: I was wary of submitting, because we've just had a big round of Fukushima and nuclear discussion/debate, and rehashing the same debate in another thread doesn't seem productive. But imo this article is quite informative and worth a read.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- alberich 14y agoI don't know Japan's geography, so, maybe it is possible for it to have tsunamis everywere. However, if there is some part of Japan's territory that is safe from tsunamis, wouldn't it be easier to just build those reactors there, and not in a place that is known to have tsunamis since, at least, the year 684 AD?
- pasbesoin 14y agoI haven't read the OP article, yet, but as I vaguely recall from past media reporting on the topic, I believe one of the reasons such sites were chosen is that the were economically fairly poor. The jobs were welcome and outweighed residents' safety concerns. (Perhaps safety concerns were also somewhat diminished by said residents having on average a lower degree of independent information and/or education.) This is from memory; feel free to correct me if and as I'm wrong. Such approaches can also be spun positively as "economic development packages/projects". Whenever such is said, the observer should look critically at who is really benefiting -- as often as not, I think, the project owners' interests come ahead of, and sometimes at the cost of, those of local residents. Ideally, all parties gain. But to do so, amongst other things someone has to keep those in power from cutting too many corners.
- ams6110 14y agoPolitics will trump public safety almost every time. Why do we keep rebuilding communities in flood areas, for example?
- _delirium 14y agoI believe due to the need for cooling water nuclear reactors are almost always built on a large body of water, either a lake or the ocean. I believe the only reactor in the world that isn't built in such a location is the Palo Verde station in Arizona, which uses (partially treated) municipal sewage for its cooling needs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palo_Verde_Nuclear_Generating_Station http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palo_Verde_Nuclear_Generating_S...
- mjvandenbergh 14y agoIn general the west coast of Japan is much less susceptible to tsunamis.