4 ms·
Does anyone in their right mind believe that this is NOT politically motivated? Take a look at how many policemen are standing guard in that picture. In a nor
by btilly 14y ago
Does anyone in their right mind believe that this is NOT politically motivated?
Take a look at how many policemen are standing guard in that picture. In a normal sexual assault extradition case, you would never get that level of response from local police. No matter how much Sweden might have begged for it.
- cup 14y agoI'm more intrigued by the complete lack of information about the two women involved in the case. You would think journalists would be trying to speak to them or trying to get their side of the story but theres been complete radio silence. It's very suspect.
- citricsquid 14y agoWhat do you mean by "their side of the story"? The claims they made are their side of the story, what more is there that they could say? I believe their identities are not released because that's Swedish law. Julian Assange always seemed quite paranoid to me -- maybe rightfully -- so it seems strange that he would have sex with 2 women he met at a conference (I think that's what happened, I'm not 100% sure of the case details as I can't find a detailed summary) if he believed there would be attempts to set him up for crimes, it seems more the behaviour of someone that lives care free.
- Natsu 14y agoTheir identities are public and have been publicly reported in international media: http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2010-12-09/us/28247531_1_wikileaks-founder-julian-assange-swedish-women-condom http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2010-12-09/us/28...
- hammersend 14y ago"The claims they made are their side of the story, what more is there that they could say?" Then what's the point of having them witness in a trial? They've already gave "their side of the story" right? Wrong.
- citricsquid 14y agoI'll rephrase: What more can they say that will change what people will think; sure they can clarify details and what led up to events (what they would do as a witness at trial) but none of that really matters to the public. Their "side of the story" is: we were sexually assaulted by Julian Assange. minor details are of little consequence in public opinion.
- hammersend 14y ago"What more can they say that will change what people will think; sure they can clarify details and what led up to events (what they would do as a witness at trial) but none of that really matters to the public. Their "side of the story" is: we were sexually assaulted by Julian Assange. minor details are of little consequence in public opinion." Your cynicism here is way overboard and borders on intellectual laziness. There have been many instances in the past of details coming out and changing public perception of a sexual assault case. The supposed Duke rape case a few years back is a prime example. Initially everybody and their dog just "knew" those boys were guilty of raping that stripper. But as details began to trickle out and she changed her story multiple times, the whole thing ultimately culminated in the disbarment of the prosecuting attorney Mike Nifong and subsequent jail time (albeit 1 day). Obviously that was a judicial decision but to pretend that the "minor details" didn't adjust public perception is absolutely untrue.
- kevinprince 14y agoMost countries prohibit this prior to trial otherwise it will influence the jury pool.
- objclxt 14y agoIt's not suspect at all: it's called contempt of court. Journalists really aren't allowed to go around interviewing either plaintiffs or defendants in criminal trials for fairly obvious reasons. Cases all across the world have been undone by press coverage that has contaminated the jury pool. In many countries victims of sexual assault and rape cases are also entitled to have their identities withheld, again for fairly obvious reasons. It is not for the court of public opinion to decide the outcome of a criminal case, although that is certainly how this particular one seems to be playing out (unfortunately).
- rjsamson 14y agoThere was actually quite a bit written about them, and their stories, when all this first came out. Some googling should turn up a few stories.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- citricsquid 14y ago> In a normal sexual assault extradition case, you would never get that level of response from local police. because no "normal" sexual assault case would have this level of media surrounding it.
- objclxt 14y agoExactly - you get this sort of level of response from police in high profile cases in the UK, such as those involving murderers or child abuse, where public tension might be high. The key difference is that normally in those cases the media scrum is between the prison and the court. The accused is not normally seeking refuge in an embassy.
- arrrg 14y agoI do not believe that this is politically motivated. I just see no evidence for that. Justice systems are allergic to public disrespect. That alone can completely explain the behavior of the police in Sweden and the UK. Assange is a self-importent prick, cowardly on the run from pretty serious allegations. He exploits his involvement with Wikileaks to sow doubt. I really think it's as simple as that.
- Natsu 14y ago> I do not believe that this is politically motivated. > Justice systems are allergic to public disrespect. For some definitions of "politically motivated," you would have contradicted yourself.
- arrrg 14y agoSigh. I knew someone would say something stupid like that. We all know what was meant with politically motivated in the comment I was responding to. Don't be a pedantic ass when I was perfectly understandable.
- Natsu 14y agoIt's going to be hard to understand what you mean if your definition of "politically motivated" does not include pissing off the authorities.
- arrrg 14y agoPolitically motivated in this context clearly means related to Wikileaks and nothing else. All I want to say that it isn't. That's why comments like yours are pedantic self-importance that only want to derail the discussion.
- Natsu 14y agoWikileaks itself was flagrant disrespect for the political system, whose secrets it exposed. I don't see how you can say it's this kind of politically motivated but not that. I see that you've retreated with that "and nothing else" part though, admitting that it is, in fact, a factor.
- objclxt 14y agoA 'normal' extradition case? Most European Arrest Warrants don't end with the suspect fleeing into a foreign embassy. This case wouldn't be 'normal' regardless of Assange's background. Assange has finished his speech now - he talks about making a stand for the justice system, but doesn't mention at all anything to do with the rape charges* and how he's depriving the women accusing him of seeing due process. He said "Wikileaks stands under threat" - that's not true at all, at least not in the way he thinks. Wikileaks is not Assange. Assange is under threat. He is conflating the two. * And yes, I'm calling it rape: what he is accused of is rape under Sweden's law, and contrary to what many people are saying, it would be rape under English law as well.
- tgasson 14y agoPlease watch this[1]. It's not a rape charge, it's sexual molestation. And it's not being pursued by the victims but by a prosecutor. [1] http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/stories/2012/07/19/3549280.htm http://www.abc.net.au/4corners/stories/2012/07/19/3549280.ht...
- objclxt 14y agoIf you actually bothered to read the papers Assange's own legal team lodged with the English courts you'd know that both the defence and prosecution accepted what he was accused of would be rape under English law. @tgasson - unfortunately I can't reply to your next message, but with regards to links: you can view most of the case literature at BAILII and the Supreme Court website. Because Assange made numerous appeals his legal filings are numerous. Link here: http://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/sino_search_1.cgi?sort=rank&query=assange&method=boolean&highlight=0&mask_path=/ http://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/sino_search_1.cgi?sort=rank... A more succint summary can be found at David Allen Green's blog - Assange's legal team did at first try to argue it wouldn't count as rape, but this was rejected by two courts, and when they subsequently appealed to the UK Supreme Court his defence accepted the point and dropped the argument: http://jackofkent.com/2012/06/assange-would-the-rape-allegation-also-be-rape-under-english-law/ http://jackofkent.com/2012/06/assange-would-the-rape-allegat... Assange's legal defence against the extradition was primarily on a matter of procedural law regarding whether Sweden had the judicial authority to extradite him in the first place. I hope you will forgive my rather blunt tone - I am not a lawyer, but I have the pleasure (perhaps?!) of living with one. As I've said in other posts here, I'm more than happy to believe Assange is the victim of a conspiracy, but I don't think that is an outright certainty. I perhaps naively hold the English legal system in some regard, although I accept others may not!
- waterlesscloud 14y agoWhatever the case about the political motivations, the police presence has nothing to do with it. They're there to manage the crowds.