No, not really. 1) never forget Indian ingenuity to break systems. Jugaad is the proper term. 2) the data itself is being faked already. In this thread there

No, not really. 1) never forget Indian ingenuity to break systems. Jugaad is the proper term. 2) the data itself is being faked already. In this thread there is a first hand account of people going to villages and making duplicate UID cards. 2 separate cards for each hand. 3) data has already been lost and stolen 4)overlaps. The current system already has some thing like 1 million to .1 million overlaps from one set of calculations I recall. On top of that you have overlap everytime a new generation gets added to the database. Do you want to be the person with a faulty card in india? Do you want to see what happens to poor people who have no access to the net?