3 ms·
> Calviño is the wrong choice to lead this Will Calviño be picking and choosing the grantees?
by JumpCrisscross 2y ago
> Calviño is the wrong choice to lead this
Will Calviño be picking and choosing the grantees?
- landl0rd 2y agoThis isn't the point. More knowledgeable people at lower levels can help. But when leadership lacks domain expertise it's very hard to know what to do or not do, what will help and won't. She could be smart and lean heavily on industry experts but that still makes her the wrong choice to lead it when one of them could have done so better. This is the equivalent of private equity installing someone who knows nothing but MBA material at a biotech company or a ML research company or anything else where domain expertise can actually help. The EU is actually better at bringing in bits of "technocracy" to let industry experts lend their expertise. I don't know why they are doing that here. I think it's the wrong call.
- amarcheschi 2y agoElon Musk lacks domain expertise given how he asked to rewrite Twitter stack to the devs after it was bought If you're talking about the domain of startups and companies themselves though, I'll give you that
- robertlagrant 2y ago> Elon Musk lacks domain enterprise What does this mean? I can't parse it.
- amarcheschi 2y agoSorry, I meant expertise not enterprise
- robertlagrant 2y agoAh, okay. I still don't quite know what it means. He clearly has something, as he's launched/run various successful and wildly innovative companies. I think that's different to someone allocating public funds well. In my very limited experience of that in the UK, the people involved were completely unaware of what to do, and were convinced by salespeople and partisan semi-internal contractors with a bias. If Elon Musk wants to risk his own money on an internal decision at Twitter, so be it. That's a lot better than risking somebody else's money forcibly extracted from their pockets.
- amarcheschi 2y agoKnowledge of the domain he launches company of. I'll give him that he's great at launching and probably managing companies, he's still not an expert in the technical side of the field his companies operate in I answered because the guy above me complained about lack of domain expertise
- robertlagrant 2y agoAh yes I understand. I think for me the difference isn't just domain expertise, although it is a little bit. It's more whose money you're risking. If investors want to give Elon Musk some of their money to try something, I don't care, as it's not my money to lose.
- meekaaku 2y agoHis domain expertise is running a high performance engineering team. I think he has a good record of that.
- landl0rd 2y agoI don’t remember mentioning Musk once in my comments. He’d also be a poor choice. They should stick with a european who understands the challenges of start-up high tech in europe. I am in fact talking about start-ups and tech as a domain. That’s the area at issue so they should hire euros who understand those challenges well to fix them.