3 ms·
> At one point, that kitchen light automation reached over 700 lines of YAML Now you know why it's broken > If I had to count, I’d guess I have maybe 15 worki
by Aurornis 2y ago
> At one point, that kitchen light automation reached over 700 lines of YAML Now you know why it's broken
> If I had to count, I’d guess I have maybe 15 working automations across all my half-baked instances. That's it.
There is a big home automation channel in one of the Slacks I’m in.
It has been a running theme for years that people get Home Assistant, start trying to automate everything, frustrate their families, and then get forced to de-automate parts of the house because everyone around them is so fed up with it.
The endless debugging and tinkering is only fun for the person doing it, not the test subjects dealing with it. Even the tinkering gets old after a while and people end up with half-baked automations that they just live with, vowing to get back to it some day when the spark returns.
- iforgotpassword 2y agoImo that's people trying to be too clever with the automation, inevitably resulting in situations where you'd want different behavior to your "smart" automation. I did that too in the very beginning but soon realized that you need subtle, non-intrusive rules that make your day ever so slightly more comfortable but don't get in your way if you do something unexpected. The problem is that HA gives you a million possibilities while Google and apple don't, and most techies just fall for it and start over engineering the shit out of it only to annoy the rest of their family to no end and then getting rid of everything again.
- nasmorn 2y agoAt least Apple Home is so limited it is basically useless. It has not gained any new features in the last 3 years. I really don’t want to do much but you can’t do real life heating control with it.
- somat 2y ago700 lines of yaml! The inner platform effect strikes again. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inner-platform_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inner-platform_effect