6 ms·
Google is giving Amazon a leg up in digital book sales
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/7sUdc https://archive.ph/7sUdc
- latein 2y agonice one and thank you...
- palata 2y ago> Google said Amazon doesn’t have a special deal. The company and Amazon declined to offer specifics. > Google and Amazon say the payment options aren’t new. Google said Amazon was among a few companies that had been able to offer non-Google payment options for their existing customers, under a test program. "It's not a special deal. It's just that only a few companies can benefit from it." Who are they kidding, seriously?
- StopDisinfo910 2y agoI thank the US for voluntarily deciding to run the experiment on what decades of voluntary non enforcement of competition laws will do to companies. I suggest we have the results now and it could safely be stopped.
- bigbadfeline 2y agoYou thank Peter "Competition IsForLosers" Thiel and humbly ask him to stop "the experiment"? You know what he's gonna say, right?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- rs186 2y agoThe time comes when we need to define what "special" means. To me, if "only a few" companies can do this, among possibly millions of companies that put their apps on the store, it seems very special.
- palata 2y agoAgreed, it is obviously special treatment.
- b112 1y agoI wonder, will they release the names of all these special companies?
- bwb 2y agoYa at the very least they could extend it to all book sellers like Kobo, bookshop.org, etc
- some_random 1y agoI suspect it's something along the lines of "it's not special, you just need to be making enough money that we can justify giving you a rep specifically to manage and execute this deal".
- iLoveOncall 1y agoIt's pretty clear to me that it means they still pay the same 30% cut but just have the UX option to buy in one click.
- criddell 1y agoThe article also says: > Amazon doesn’t seem to be paying Google a fee
- iLoveOncall 1y agoIt's a supposition based on nothing at all.
- xp84 1y agoIf Amazon were happy selling books for zero or less than zero profit, as they'd have to be if this idea that they're somehow still paying Google requires, then they would have also been doing it on iOS too, wouldn't they? That's "all" Apple has been demanding this whole time.
- patmorgan23 1y agoSo is the assurance they're paying Google, unless you have a citation to provide?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- barbazoo 1y ago> Google said Amazon was among a few companies that had been able to offer non-Google payment options for their existing customers, under a test program. "Test program", what a bunch of corporate shitspeak.
- gamblor956 1y agoIt's not a special deal. Google would love to have a deal with Amazon. It's simply that Amazon is one of the few companies that can get away with not paying Google anything. Amazon is the big dog in this context. If Google were to cut off Amazon from search results, people would just do all their shopping (and searches) directly on Amazon and cut Google out of the process entirely, and Google would lose hundreds of millions in ad revenue for the ads it show sin Amazon-related google searches. Amazon could even promote competitors to Google on their website just for the hell of it (or more likely in exchange for $$$ or stock), and Google would start seeing material drops in usage (material meaning large enough for investors to care about).
- saurik 1y agoA special deal isn't somehow not a special deal just because you don't have leverage and are kind of forced to provide it...
- gamblor956 1y agoI don't think you guys understand what a "special deal" is. A deal is an agreement between two parties. Amazon and Google don't have a deal. Amazon is just doing whatever the fuck it wants and Google is going along, because Google already lost this battle in court. Notably, Amazon didn't start offering the option to buy books in the Android apps until after Google lost the court case. Amazon is very likely to do this with its Apple apps later this year as well, now that Apple has also lost this battle and may be facing civil and criminal sanctions for its continued attempts to prevent companies from doing what Amazon did on Android.
- Henchman21 1y agoThey baldfaced lie to the public because there are exactly zero consequences for doing so. One of the dilemmas of modern existence, IMO, is this general comfort with lying as if it were no big deal.
- barbazoo 2y agoI’m surprised this was authorized to be published at all given that the WaPo is owned by Lord Bezos.
- fooker 1y agoWhy would Bezos not want you to know that he has made a deal beneficial for him and his Amazon stocks?
- barbazoo 1y agoBecause that would draw attention to a practice that might possibly be anti competitive.
- Henchman21 1y agoDon’t pretend he cares to hide his behavior. He’s openly lobbying to have the NLRB declared unconstitutional.
- guywithahat 1y agoI feel like Bezos has been pretty hands-off with the wapo, excluding Arc XP
- pixelesque 1y agoOther than the Opinions section: https://apnews.com/article/washington-post-bezos-opinion-trump-market-liberty-97a7d8113d670ec6e643525fdf9f06de https://apnews.com/article/washington-post-bezos-opinion-tru...
- chucksmash 1y agoAnd nixing the endorsement in the US Presidential election: https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/media/2024/10/25/washington-post-endorsement-president/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/style/media/2024/10/25/washin...
- AdmiralAsshat 2y ago> That math is why many book apps like those from Bookshop, Kobo and Barnes & Noble’s Nook haven’t typically let you buy e-books and audiobooks from their iPhone or Android apps. Instead, you must leave the app, buy from the bookstore’s website and hop back into the app to read or listen to it. Not accurate, at least for Kobo. They accepted Google's billing system, so buying from the Kobo app on Android hooks into your Google Wallet billing method and works without an issue. It does mean you can't use Kobo gift cards towards purchases made on your phone, but you can always pop onto the website to do that. I'm actually really glad that Kobo just did that, even if Google is taking a ridiculous cut. Anecdotally I'm buying way more impulse books on Kobo (i.e. a book on sale for $2.99 or less) since they got the app working with Google Wallet.
- jorvi 1y agoWhy not add your payment method to Kobo's app? It's very little effort for doing your part in fighting the oligopoly.
- mvdtnz 1y agoGoogle Play billing is the only option in the Kobo Android app.
- jorvi 1y agoOh, I misunderstood. I thought Kobo added the Google Pay (Wallet Pay? Google Wallet? God knows with the constant name changes) button / system to the app in addition to their own payment flow. Damn.
- glitchc 1y agoThat does seem odd given that Google is liable to take a 30% cut of each purchase.
- mvdtnz 1y agoIt isn't "odd" it's the only way they are permitted by Google to sell their product. Yes, it's farcical and should be illegal. https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answer/10281818 https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answ...
- iLoveOncall 1y ago> With its own one-click e-book and audiobook purchases in Android apps, Amazon doesn’t seem to be paying Google a fee. That gives Amazon a rare privilege among digital booksellers: It can turn a profit from selling e-books and audiobooks in a smartphone app. So, an article entirely built on speculation. Speculations refuted by Google: "Google said Amazon doesn’t have a special deal.". What's more likely is that the share of users who buy books exclusively from the mobile Kindle app is extremely low, and that therefore it's worth selling at a loss or no profit for Amazon, to retain the customer experience. It's also likely that Amazon doesn't have a special deal with Google, but has a special deal with book publishers, which means it's able to turn a profit even with the 30% app store cut.
- xp84 1y agoWhy do you cling to this idea despite the evidence contrary? If they were happy giving 30% to Google and thus likely losing money on every sale, why wouldn't they have been happy to do the same with Apple? Instead we saw for a decade plus that they weren't willing to, to the extent of having a bad user experience.
- criddell 1y agoI'm guessing Amazon is large enough that they qualify for the Google Play Media Experience Program and pay far less than 30%. I believe they are paying at most a 10% fee to Google.
- lern_too_spel 1y ago> So, an article entirely built on speculation. The purchases happen completely within the Amazon App, billed to your Amazon payment method, without Google Pay. That is clear evidence that they have special treatment. Google is lying here.
- oldpersonintx2 1y agoAnna's Archive still charges what it always has
- SoftTalker 1y agoSeems pretty safe to assume that all the big platforms are colluding and scamming at this point. Why not, nobody is going to stop them.
- davidw 1y agoI have gone back to using the local library a bunch. They have a 'request a book' feature that usually gets me the book in a reasonable time frame.
- kjkjadksj 1y agoAnd the book publishers tried to ruin that too. Get people to buy ereaders -> let massive libraries only have 5 “copies” of an ebook -> people shrug and pay $5 from the kindle store instead of waiting. Basically priming a generation against libraries. And then the ebook readers have these invented gripes why paper books no longer work for them and they must engage with the walled garden system in order to read. Some of it is truly pedantic stuff like “book too heavy.”
- bluGill 1y agoIf I'm going on vacation a book is too heavy. But most of the time I'm not carrying a weeks worth of books that hopefully it isn't raining and thus I never open those books. Even when that is a real worry, I find that there are more free books around such that I don't need to buy them anyway.
- fn-mote 1y ago> Basically priming a generation against libraries. You have left off the abusive terms under which the ebooks are leased to the libraries.
- breakingcups 1y ago$550 for perpetual access to 1 copy which may only be lent to 1 person at a time.. Yep, abusive.
- black_13 1y ago[dead]
- thepryz 1y agoPerhaps a bit off topic, but we really need to stop referring to digital books obtained through Google, Amazon, and other publishers as sold. Amazon has made it very clear in recent months that you do not purchase kindle books you purchase a license. It's a nuanced difference, but one I know this audience will appreciate.
- MrResearcher 1y agoThere are well-known ways to extract Amazon books as PDFs, iTunes videos as DRM-free video files (with subtitles and audio tracks!), download youtube videos and movies, etc. Plenty of instructions on certain popular web sites that shall not be listed. So, there's an opinion that the audience you're referring to is, in fact, "buying" the books and movies, and not renting them, for as long as you are willing to exercise your technical "prowess".
- wredcoll 1y agoThat's not really the point. The point is that by repeating the lie about buying books you bolster their position/power.
- MrResearcher 1y agoAnd I'm telling you that your position is suboptimal and in the long term will lead you nowhere. You won't be able to switch any noticeable number of consumers away from Amazon by telling them that they lie, nor would anyone listen to you. However, if you teach people how they can obtain DRM-free material, store it, and consume it in that format, that and only that can make the difference. Amazon is effectively a monopoly at this point. Many books are available exclusively through them. I doubt that the US court system would look into this segment of market any time soon. They still can't decide what to do with Google, and that took them how many years? I doubt we will be able to resolve this problem in our lifetime.
- thepryz 1y agoI disagree. Amazon disabled the ability to download and transfer kindle books in February of this year, adding an additional barrier for individuals who commonly download and strip the DRM from the kindle books they "buy" from Amazon. When that news was communicated within a number of online communities, there were a lot of people who learned for the first time that they didn't "own" their kindle books. More importantly, they also learned about the tools to help them strip DRM and regain the ownership they thought they had. People are slowly beginning to learn that their perception of digital content licensing and ownership is wrong. The more it is called out that they are licensing rather than purchasing content, the more we're able to explain why that is a bad things, the sooner people exert pressure to change the business or enact laws to do so.