3 ms·
Every time there's a report about Curiosity doing something that overlaps with software or hardware that we at HN are familiar with comments like this appear.
by jgrahamc 14y ago
Every time there's a report about Curiosity doing something that overlaps with software or hardware that we at HN are familiar with comments like this appear.
The bottom line is: (a) Curiosity was designed 8 years ago so the tech. on board is old (b) everything that's on board has to be radiation hardened and (c) NASA are conservative about 'new stuff' because they need it to work (e.g. the thrusters on the skycrane were derived from the Viking landers).
- papalalu 14y agopresumably the 8 year old design would use already-proven tech too..
- ballooney 14y agoIndeed, their shopping list 8 years ago was not from Newegg with whatever Intel had at the time, it was whatever BAE had spent many years rad hardening and qualifying by that point, which would itself have been based on an already proven CPU (read: older) when BAE first started looking. All of a sudden it's 1993.
- robryan 14y agoI wonder whether it will get to the point where they just send processors was a large amount of redundancy, multicore/ multiprocessor, and just not trust any one result but probabilistically across operations in parallel.
- harrywincup 14y agoIt must be unbearably frustrating building this stuff to work around the limitations of 10+ year-old technologies when the superior tech inside even the phone in your pocket could achieve so much more.
- mturmon 14y agoAlmost all of the radiation effects appear to be single event upsets (SEUs). So in principle, it should be possible to design robust software to detect and recover from faults (SEUs do no permanent damage to hardware). There have been efforts within NASA to design robust OS extensions -- redundancy, watchdogs, heartbeats, checkpoints, etc. -- so that fast/cheap COTS hardware could be used, at least for some functions like image processing. This has never reached critical mass and been carried to completion, however. So yes, as you guessed, there is significant pain and heartburn that computational capabilities are so far behind. Engineers have to spend a lot of time and cleverness squeezing, say, stereo vision processing, or image compression, into the hardware available.
- facorreia 14y agoMaybe there's a lesson for us right there.
- angstrom 14y agoNow tack on the fact that it has an initial 2 year mission powered by an RTG. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_gen... ...but not just any RTG, a MMRTG: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-Mission_Radioisotope_Thermoelectric_Generator http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multi-Mission_Radioisotope_Ther... It's able to supply a steady 125 W of power for 14 years, before dropping to 100W. The technology has been used reliably on multiple projects. Based on the longevity of the previous rovers that have safely made it to Mars it's worth considering that barring mechanical malfunctions and hardware failures (it has two main computers) the rover could turn power off to non critical components after 14 years and continue to run on 100W. It might not be far fetched to think that this rover could still be running if/when humans arrive in the 2030s. That's far cooler than what you would get running on the latest and greatest for convenience.
- felipemnoa 14y ago>> the rover could turn power off to non critical components after 14 years and continue to run on 100W That constant source is charging a battery. As long as the battery is still working it would just take longer to charge the battery.
- sp332 14y agoHow does the radiation from the power supply not screw with the electronics?