4 ms·
Why bad philosophy is stopping progress in physics
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/jxnrh https://archive.ph/jxnrh
- ajjenkins 2y agoI’m not an expert in physics, but this seems like a misguided critique to me. My understanding is that physicists aren’t looking for “new” physics because they’re trying to upend established physics, but because they’re trying to reconcile “inconsistencies” in the standard model. Like reconciling quantum physics with general relativity. We need new physics because we know there are gaps in our current understanding of the universe. I haven’t heard about many attempts to disprove established physics. Theoretical physicists aren’t looking just trying to fill the gaps in the model.
- pfdietz 2y ago> I haven’t heard about many attempts to disprove established physics. Every experiment that tests the standard model is an attempt to disprove established physics. There is no great expectation these attempts will succeed, but it only takes on ugly experiment to kill a beautiful theory.
- beloch 2y agoPeople frequently misunderstand what motivates physicists. They aren't tiptoeing around orthodox theory like it's a precious house of cards that they're desperately afraid will fall apart. At every opportunity, they take sledgehammers to it. It's every physicist's dream to invalidate accepted theory. The more fundamental and important it is, the more work it creates for other physicists, the better. Because it's so hard and rare, physicists are often quite skeptical of claims that cards have been sent tumbling. This skepticism has delayed progress at times.
- ashoeafoot 2y agoThis is a very idealized view. Whole careers and schools have been built around disproven models, yet they linger for the grants still flow and they please sone sense of beauty and symmetry .
- pfdietz 2y agoNone of that contradicts what he wrote.
- r721 2y ago>By Carlo Rovelli https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_Rovelli https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carlo_Rovelli
- verzali 2y agoI believe physicists would benefit from studying at least some of the underlying philosophy. I managed to make it through a four year degree in physics without ever being taught anything about the ideas of Popper or Kuhn other than vague mentions in random lectures. It was only later when I looked into them out of my own interest that I realised they had something relevant to say - and I reckon many physicists never get to that point at all.
- richardatlarge 2y agoDon’t forget P Feyerabend, Against Method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Against_Method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Against_Method
- K0balt 2y agoDid this guy just propose a new theory of epistemological trajectories in theoretical physics, beyond the current paradigm of theoretical physicists liking shiny mathematical objects?
- gus_massa 2y agoDoesn't the mass of neutrinos make this argument fall apart? It looks like they are just ignoring new discoveries.