4 ms·
The internet cannot be made safe. For as long as you consider information a hazard to it's users, the internet will enable people to freely spread ideas harmful
by bigyabai 2y ago
The internet cannot be made safe. For as long as you consider information a hazard to it's users, the internet will enable people to freely spread ideas harmful or intelligent. This happens today, it happened in the past, and it will continue into the future barring some radical redesign of the internet's protocols.
Legislature like this puts the tiny side-effects first ("think of the kids!") while conveniently neglecting to acknowledge the ways it stifles democratic process and individual rights. If a similar law was passed regulating libraries this way, voters would universally agree that it's a pants-on-head stupid decision.
- alganet 2y agoSo, it's unfeasible to either prove or disprove its safety. Claiming there is no scientific basis then is doubly irrelevant, in addition to laws often not requiring scientific studies to be passed. It sounds like it's trying to fool people, specially "science defenders". I think it's dishonest, and people will notice. "Think of the kids" is used by a lot of media articles hammering the "big tech is bad" anvil. It poses a contradiction. They're trying to justify it by saying it will harm only small businesses ("think of the poor small businesses!"). However, there is the contradiction of the same media articles having had created the very same hysteria that pushes people to support the act. It is not helping to sell why one would vote against it. I said it bluntly: it opens a loophole for US Great Firewall. That argument will sell to both the right and the left, and it will be untouchable. It is also rooted in truth. I also provided solid questions that, if made in opposition to the act, will stop it. But there needs to be a stop to the sensationalist media too (everybody wins, media conglomerates lose a very small, already known to be ineffective tabloid thematic). I am trying to help the poorly written article to be better written.
- bigyabai 2y ago> it's unfeasible to either prove or disprove its safety. Upload the designs of a Teller-Ulam device right now, and phone me from jail once you're finished. I am very willing to prove it, if you have sufficiently disruptive information to test with.
- alganet 2y agoI am glad we agree on the unfeasibility of the issue. Now, catch up on the remaining of the argument. You only touched my first paragraph. I expected more.