3 ms·
What is your ISP doing, if not "making things available". Let's stop arguing about whether or not torrents are copyright infringement, and move on to the secon
by jrockway 14y ago
What is your ISP doing, if not "making things available".
Let's stop arguing about whether or not torrents are copyright infringement, and move on to the second point: can one be expected to show remorse for what amounts to computing a mathematical function over an encoded movie file? Even if it's wrong, my human emotions aren't programmed to respond to that.
- vacri 14y agoDo you support the eradication of 'accessory to' crimes, like my getaway driver example below? Intent is an important part of the law. Drive into a pedestrian, killing them - if you didn't intend to, it was an accident, a sad event. If you did intend to, it was murder. The ISP is providing me with access to the internet, and is not providing me with a list of links to copyright-infringing material, constantly updated for my convenience. If instead of the .torrent file, it was a list of stolen credit card numbers, the situation would be much clearer. It would be stupid to hold the ISP as equally accountable as the website owner. To hold ISPs as having the same intent as every website owner in the world would make them legally liable for all online fraud. Clearly there's a difference.