3 ms·
> This list could be much longer—most “experts”, in every industry, say some amount of bullshit Gordon Ramsay is perhaps a perfect example of an entertainer th
by Aurornis 2y ago
> This list could be much longer—most “experts”, in every industry, say some amount of bullshit
Gordon Ramsay is perhaps a perfect example of an entertainer that people mistake for an expert.
His job first and foremost is to entertain. That’s what he does.
Many people will jump to defend entertainer “experts” like this because they are actually good in their field and they share a lot of accurate advice. They’re making an effort to do the right thing and share the correct advice most of the time because doing anything too obviously bad too frequently would shatter the illusion.
But entertainment comes first. If it comes down to being pointedly correct and consistent versus being entertaining, they’ll choose the latter when they can get away with it. Praising a terrible grilled cheese is a perfect example.
This happens a lot in the workplace, too. Every company I’ve worked for has accumulated a few people who were very charismatic, loud, and entertaining, but everyone who knew the subject could see they didn’t know what they were doing. These people can persist for a remarkably long time, coasting on charisma alone. My clue that it’s time to leave a company is when those people start getting promoted and put in charge even after a year or two of consistent underperformance. Fortunately the better companies I’ve worked for have eventually caught on to the bullshitters and pushed them out, but it can take a painfully long time.
- bad_username 2y agoWhich is why "infotainment" is usually all entertainment and no info.
- jackphilson 2y agothe answer is of course not to somehow convince society to devalue entertainment, but it is the responsibility of the educators to become more entertaining.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoRamsay really knows how to cook. Ramsay has managed restaurants and studied his craft and perfected his technique in the kitchen. He thereafter became an entertainer to share his love of cuisine with others. So yes, his expertise does often take a backseat to the entertainment value of whatever he's doing. But I believe that this is part of the thesis of the article we're discussing here: that Ramsay's extensive expertise does not prevent him from conveying bad information. I would say that a lot of these examples fall under the category of "cargo culting". There is a lot of cargo culting in the culinary arts. Since a kitchen is basically a chemistry lab where biological miracles happen several times a day, no housewife or chef can be fully versed in the actual biochemical sciences that are governing what they do every day. There is so much "institutional knowledge" and "traditional know-how" that can't be written down or codified; it's merely handed on from one expert to the next. It's like Zen Buddhism, which has no formalized doctrine, but there's a lot of expertise to transmit from one master to the next! Therefore a lot of cargo-culting intervenes here. Everyone has their idea of how to make perfect hard-boiled eggs. Everyone wants to show you exactly how to season a cast-iron pan. Everyone has one weird trick that will make the perfect roasted vegetables. And I've found that nearly all these recipes online leave out vital information. If you don't already know how to cook, don't try learning by following online recipes. You'll fail bigtime. Also, any recipe on the side of a container, like the ones which come with your spice bottles or a box of yeast or something. They're omitting valuable expertise that only a seasoned chef will know. You'll always need to re-inject your experience when following someone else's instructions, because even if they intend to comprehensively explain the process, they'll always assume that you know how to get from Point A to Point B. Not everybody does. I don't know the motives for passing along bullshit like that "room temperature steak" tidbit. Perhaps it's just to honor the people who taught him how to do it. Perhaps it's better safe than sorry. But oftentimes it's just cargo culting -- they've done it before this way, it turned out great, don't mess with perfection, just keep following the ritual correctly.