3 ms·

> IMO data should be radioactive for companies, especially if it approaches PII It's pretty much the idea of GDPR. The wording of the GPDR is "You should make

by phh 1y ago

> IMO data should be radioactive for companies, especially if it approaches PII It's pretty much the idea of GDPR. The wording of the GPDR is "You should make your systems private by design", which they explain as "Store PII only you really have no choice" In this case, the legal ruling means that even if they somehow fix their consent, they have to remove all the data they currently have! Also all their clients need to remove all the data. Having to tell your customers they have to remove all their data ought to completely kill their business. That being said, it will likely not happen: It's not the first time they lose a ruling and I'm pretty sure no-one removed any data, despite being required to...

spwa4 1y ago
I hate that people don't look up the details on laws. GPDR says that all governments are the ones judging whether the GDPR is violated (meaning not the courts), for example the https://ico.org.uk/ https://ico.org.uk/ and they even formalized an exception process. You cannot sue a company for GPDR violation, you can report it to a government department that may or may not decide to action your report, that's it. GDPR only allows for the government to intervene directly in the private sector. Needless to say, all governments have used the exception process to carve out blanket wide-ranging exceptions for themselves, for state owned or partially state owned enterprises (police, government departments, police, justice, banks, insurance, hospitals, doctors, incumbent telco's, ... exactly the people where GDPR protection would be critically important) that seem to grow in scope over time. For example the tax offices in the EU now have exceptions that allows them to mandate companies store PII as part of their regulations (meaning without an actual law). And, in any case, if anyone violates your rights, there's nothing you can do with the GDPR. Try to get a hospital to empty your patient record and tell me how it goes (I wanted to do that after the hospital charged the insurance for an -embarassing- assessment they didn't actually do (it allowed them to charge a lot because it involves staying a few days at the hospital, I was in there about 2 hours). So I wanted it cleared of my medical record, which is one of the core things the GDPR allows for, it's given as an example in the law! Nope. Not allowed, and the government doesn't pick up the report)

by phh 1y ago

spwa4 1y ago

I hate that people don't look up the details on laws. GPDR says that all governments are the ones judging whether the GDPR is violated (meaning not the courts), for example the https://ico.org.uk/ https://ico.org.uk/ and they even formalized an exception process. You cannot sue a company for GPDR violation, you can report it to a government department that may or may not decide to action your report, that's it. GDPR only allows for the government to intervene directly in the private sector. Needless to say, all governments have used the exception process to carve out blanket wide-ranging exceptions for themselves, for state owned or partially state owned enterprises (police, government departments, police, justice, banks, insurance, hospitals, doctors, incumbent telco's, ... exactly the people where GDPR protection would be critically important) that seem to grow in scope over time. For example the tax offices in the EU now have exceptions that allows them to mandate companies store PII as part of their regulations (meaning without an actual law). And, in any case, if anyone violates your rights, there's nothing you can do with the GDPR. Try to get a hospital to empty your patient record and tell me how it goes (I wanted to do that after the hospital charged the insurance for an -embarassing- assessment they didn't actually do (it allowed them to charge a lot because it involves staying a few days at the hospital, I was in there about 2 hours). So I wanted it cleared of my medical record, which is one of the core things the GDPR allows for, it's given as an example in the law! Nope. Not allowed, and the government doesn't pick up the report)