2 ms·
No, it's about uncertainty. You have a stated problem "the foam that came off didn't come off because of the reasons we thought it did." Now you have no other
by HeyLaughingBoy 14y ago
No, it's about uncertainty.
You have a stated problem "the foam that came off didn't come off because of the reasons we thought it did." Now you have no other ideas besides what you've already considered and tested for 26 months. What do you do? Possibly spend another 2 years investigating and find nothing? Or conclude that the risk is small enough to fly while being vigilant about the problem and looking for more data to lead you in the right direction?
Sometimes the only way to get more data to solve the problem is to do the very thing that causes it, while hoping that you've mitigated its effects well enough that the system is still safe.
- danso 14y agoI'm not saying that this isn't the case, I was hoping for more clarification. The way that the OP writes it is that this "side note" was included in the final briefing pointing out the flawed hypothesis. The OP doesn't say how conclusive this "side note" was, or if it was one such note among many others. If it is the latter situation, then yes, it's understandable that it was seen as an acceptable blind spot. But the situation, as the OP describes it, sounds pretty clear cut: The foam issues could come from poor installation procedures. But testing found that the defective foam "could not have been liberated from an internal installation defect"... So I'm just interested in knowing the level of conclusiveness in that sidenote.