4 ms·
Every Shuttle in the fleet has had one or several extremely close scrapes with death. To look at the Shuttle record and see the history of calamity it's easy to
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Every Shuttle in the fleet has had one or several extremely close scrapes with death. To look at the Shuttle record and see the history of calamity it's easy to think that we just had bad luck, but quite the opposite was the case. We were enormously lucky with the Shuttle, in a fairer world we would have lost more of them, and sooner. The Shuttle was plagued by many fundamental design flaws which combined to make it an inherently unsafe system. Within the last years of the program that knowledge finally started to sink in, which is why the Shuttle was essentially restricted to missions to the ISS.
Some of the achievements of the Shuttle program have been inspiring, and the vehicle itself is pretty to look at, but we should have canned that program long, long ago.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThis is an important point and one which many overlook. I don't blame the shuttle designers, it was a new kind space craft. The truth was that the more folks looked, the more questions they asked, the more problems were uncovered that could only be fixed by 'a complete redesign of that subsystem.' And ultimately there were few places where a complete redesign could be undertaken.
- aaronblohowiak 14y agoIt was a 30-year design. Not too bad for our first reusable space plane.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoAt the risk of being a negative nelly, the Soyuz design is even older, and overall probably fundamentally safer. Also, the Shuttle is only ostensibly "reusable", in reality every single flight required months of refurbishment which included meticulous inspections of the TPS tiles, complete replacement of the payload bay liner, complete purging of all fuel in the system, and even replacement of the engines. We certainly learned a lot from Shuttle operations but in terms of spacecraft design mostly we learned what not to do.
- masklinn 14y agoIn that, the Shuttle was very much like the Concorde: a unique and complex system beyond the edge of knowledge (at its creation), full of flaws and working through a combination of sheer luck and heroic efforts.
- vladd 14y agoActually the space shuttle is the safest launch vehicle to date. From the ones that have at least 100 launches (in order to be able to properly compute stats for them), here are their failure rates as taken from http://www.ontonix.com/Blog/Outliers_-_understanding_Nature_throught_her_anomalies http://www.ontonix.com/Blog/Outliers_-_understanding_Nature_... : 2% US Space Shuttle 5% R-7 (Russian Soyuz) 5% Ariane 1-4 (European) 6% Tsyklon (Russian) 7% Kosmos (Russian) 10% Thor/Delta/N1/N2/H1 (US) 11% Titan 2/3/4 (US) 12% Proton (Russian) 13% Kosmos 2 (Russian R-12) 14% Atlas (US)
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThose figures are a bit misleading because they include a lot of the early development phase of a vehicle in the operational history. Is it fair to include, say, the safety record of the Model-T when considering the safety of a 2012 model Ford Focus?
- vladd 14y agoI've tried to find other stats but I couldn't easily find more recent numbers. 2% is the lowest fatality rate I found. There are some statements at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_accidents_and_incidents#Percentage_of_fatal_spaceflights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_spaceflight-related_acc... but they're not changing the picture by much: >> About five percent of the people that have been launched have died doing so. [..] About two percent of the manned launch/reentry attempts have killed their crew, with Soyuz and the Shuttle having almost the same death percentage rates.
- InclinedPlane 14y ago