50 ms·
Fun fact: That slogan is only half of the story. Smuggling was prolific in those days, with John Hancock and Samuel Adams were among them. They were involved wi
by fragmede 2y ago
Fun fact: That slogan is only half of the story. Smuggling was prolific in those days, with John Hancock and Samuel Adams were among them. They were involved with smuggling cheaper Dutch tea and the Sons of Liberty were protecting their own economic interests. Aka those taxes would ruin their smuggling business because the Tea Act of 1773 would let the British sell their tea for cheaper than the smugglers, and the protests were because that threatened their ability to sell their smuggled, but more expensive Dutch Tea.
- bloppe 2y agoI don't think it's called smuggling if you're paying taxes on it. If anything, actual smugglers would've supported the taxes because it gives them an edge over legal importers
- ceejayoz 2y agoThey weren't paying taxes on it. They worried the legal (and taxed, and higher quality) British tea would be, despite the tax, cheaper than the smuggled (untaxed) Dutch tea, which would destroy their smuggling businesses. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Act > A related objective was to undercut the price of illegal tea, smuggled into Britain's North American colonies. > Reducing or eliminating the duties paid when the tea was landed in Britain (if it was shipped onward to the colonies) would further lower the final cost of tea in the colonies, undercutting the prices charged for smuggled tea. Colonists would willingly pay for cheaper Company tea, on which the Townshend tax was still collected, thus legitimizing Parliament's ability to tax the colonies.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoHow was smuggled tea more expensive? The shipping costs for both products would be the same (right?), so the price differentiator should be the presence/absence of additional government charges. Unless smuggled tea had to accept more losses due to…piracy?
- ceejayoz 2y ago> How was smuggled tea more expensive? Smuggling adds costs, and the Dutch/British product weren't identical in quality either. The Tax Act reduced the tax/cost burden (removing a requirement to go through London-based middlemen first, and lessening import duties) on legitimate tea. > The shipping costs for both products would be the same (right?) Not at all. The risk of seizure (of both cargo and ship) drives it way up.
- ramesh31 2y agoEconomies of scale can make a legal product much cheaper even with heavy taxation. See cigarettes for example. No one runs an illicit tobacco farm in the US because you just can't match the scale to make it profitable. Similar things happening with cannabis now; in parts of the west coast supply is so high that it would be more profitable for small time operators to grow heirloom tomatoes at this point.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoCigarettes is exactly what I was thinking of for comparison. Most of the price is sin taxes. Remove those and the actual product costs nearly nothing to make. Sales of loose cigarettes is still a thing today where people are moving them from reservations or foreign countries.
- ceejayoz 2y agoSmuggled Dutch tea was something like 80% of the tea on the market. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tea_Act > Smuggled tea was a large issue for Britain and the East India Company, since approximately 86% of all the tea in America at the time was smuggled Dutch tea. That's not the case for cigarettes. If it were anything like that percentage, you can bet the Feds would care more.
- Hilift 2y agoThe owner of two of the three ships was William Rotch, a Nantucket-born colonist and merchant. "the British Parliament decreed that any American vessel selling goods in London had to purchase tea as part of its return freight to the colonies. Thus, the captains of the Rotch-owned Dartmouth and Beaver dutifully loaded consignments of tea for their journeys back to Boston." The Rotches absorbed the loss of 2/3 of the £10,000 cargo, however due to their position in the whale oil monopoly, they were unpopular in the colonies and received little sympathy. The war destroyed much of their business and wealth, and they weren't welcome back home in Nantucket, where the community felt they were abandoned. The colonies were Crown businesses. A clearer reason for the war was the Royal Proclamation of 1763. It reserved land west of the Appalachians for native peoples. https://nha.org/research/nantucket-history/history-topics/rotch-family/ https://nha.org/research/nantucket-history/history-topics/ro...
- 0xbadcafebee 2y agoReally the cause was the Indemnity Act and the Townshend Acts of 1766/67. Before '67, England paid very high taxes on tea imported from China (>25%). So tea smuggling was rampant - mostly in England. But the Dutch government didn't charge any tax on the imported tea sold in the Netherlands, so that was smuggled into America. Then in '67, the Indemnity Acts basically removed the high taxes on the tea sold in Britain. But this was followed up by the Townshend Acts, which added more taxes - specifically to the Colonies. As you can imagine, this seems a little fucked up.... except the Colonies were already paying practically zero taxes. To the British, it was the Colonies who had been getting away with highway robbery, and these new taxes leveled the playing field. But of course the Colonists didn't want to pay taxes. So they claimed this was unfair because they had no representation. The representation wasn't really the crux of the issue though... it was just that they wanted to weasel out of paying taxes. Only a representative in Parliament could levy taxes. The thing is.... by this time, the Colonists had already set up a sort of shadow-Parliament. They had British representatives who were supposed to be telling the Colonists what to do.... but the Colonists basically just ignored them. By the time of the Tea Party, the British had already lost control of governance. After several years of boycotting tea to protest the Townshend Acts, the acts were repealed in 1770, except for taxes on Tea. Yet they began importing tea again, mostly to Boston, as New York and Philadelphia were still mostly smuggling tea. The East India Company was undergoing severe hardship during this time, for a couple different reasons. But basically they had too much tea and not enough people were buying it. So in Britain they returned the duty to the company that had been charged to them. They still needed a way to get the Colonies to buy this tea, rather than the smuggled tea. So in 1773, the Tea Act was passed. It granted the Company a monopoly on imported tea, cut out the middlemen, and added a tax due on delivery. This made the tea cheaper than smuggled tea, but added a 3 pence surcharge for each pound of tea. One of the big purposes of all these taxes was actually for the Colonial Governors to receive their pay from British Parliament, so that they'd be loyal to Britain instead of the Colonists. Several Parliamentarians warned that these extra taxes wouldn't be accepted by the Colonists, but they were overruled. Without Lord North being a dickhead and insisting on the taxes, we wouldn't have our own country now. So basically the reason for the Tea Party was 1) years of resistance to taxes (even though Colonists basically hadn't been paying any tax), 2) they wanted to have more Colonial control over Governors, 3) it took away money from both smugglers and legal colonial importers. But there were other reasons too, like the fact that at this time in history, the British army was incredibly weak, with something like 40,000 soldiers total, due to recent wars nearly bankrupting the country and diminishing their fighting force. The Colonists had been calling the Empire's bluff for years, doing largely whatever they wanted. The Tea Party was a big middle finger, and the British had to respond, and so led to the eventual confrontation.