3 ms·
.torrent files make that content available. The simplest counterargument is that if his actions didn't make that content available, what were all the visitors t
by vacri 14y ago
.torrent files make that content available. The simplest counterargument is that if his actions didn't make that content available, what were all the visitors to his site doing?
Should a person be able to successfully defend with "What's the problem, I was only giving copies of the vault key to the people who I knew would burgle it. I never handled any of the vault contents myself!"?
- smokeyj 14y agoTotally right. Google makes copyrighted material available too.. Lock 'em up!
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- carlio 14y agoHerein lies the problem. While your vault example makes sense, you can also say that someone selling knives or guns can't be responsible for people using them to murder someone else. Where do you draw the line? If you are merely providing something, where is the line where suddenly it's my fault instead of the fault of the user? I think the difference here is that information and objects have an intended purpose - a knife is usually for chopping food, a gun is usually for... erm - however a vault key clearly can't have a use outside of using it to get into the valut. Where to .torrents fall in this? It's not the vault key situation, because there are definite good uses for them (linux distros, I believe Blizzard uses bittorrent to distribute updates?). However, the majority of torrent usage is for piracy [citation needed]. So I guess what I'm saying is that all objects have a potential for negative usage and a potential for positive usage, and we're trying to draw the line somewhere in a rather undefined way. To me, it seems unfair and harsh to be imprisoned for something that by another interpretation seems okay. I have a reasonable expectation not to be imprisoned for creating a site where people can post content. If it's coopted by the community into a place where people post torrents, it seems that right now I could be sent to jail for that. The problem here isn't the intention of the owner of the site, just like it isn't about Kim Dotcom's intention. I don't disagree that they were completely aware that they were profiting from other people's desire to pirate. My problem is that all of these legal cases against these people seem to be brought in a way that doesn't feel 'just'.
- vacri 14y agoThe key part of my analogy is "that I knew would burgle it". It's exactly like being an accessory to a crime. Drive a getaway car and you're not going to be able to use "hey, driving is completely legal, you can't charge me!" .torrents themselves are perfectly fine, just like knives. I'm not making the argument that the object should be banned. But if a frothing hooligan runs up and asks for your knife because he's going to stab that guy over there, it's pretty clear that if you hand it over you've facilitated a crime. So it's not the innate nature of the .torrents themselves, but the use of them as a nexus to set people up with illegal content. Like being a middleman selling stolen property, perhaps. You didn't steal it, but you did make it available.
- jrockway 14y agoWhat is your ISP doing, if not "making things available". Let's stop arguing about whether or not torrents are copyright infringement, and move on to the second point: can one be expected to show remorse for what amounts to computing a mathematical function over an encoded movie file? Even if it's wrong, my human emotions aren't programmed to respond to that.
- vacri 14y agoDo you support the eradication of 'accessory to' crimes, like my getaway driver example below? Intent is an important part of the law. Drive into a pedestrian, killing them - if you didn't intend to, it was an accident, a sad event. If you did intend to, it was murder. The ISP is providing me with access to the internet, and is not providing me with a list of links to copyright-infringing material, constantly updated for my convenience. If instead of the .torrent file, it was a list of stolen credit card numbers, the situation would be much clearer. It would be stupid to hold the ISP as equally accountable as the website owner. To hold ISPs as having the same intent as every website owner in the world would make them legally liable for all online fraud. Clearly there's a difference.