3 ms·
Is this comment part of the grift?
by gardnr 1y ago
Is this comment part of the grift?
- pc86 1y agoI don't think it's a grift in the negative sense but this is absolutely a marketing comment. They're doing exactly what they say to do in the comment. They're on HN where at least some of their target market is. They have a product that is relevant (right down to the headline/CTA). They didn't just post the link but put it at the end of an informational comment. 10/10 meta-promotion IMO
- conductr 1y agoThey also likely were involved in the the original question getting posted so they could provide that answer which is what makes it an entirely fabricated grift
- nicooo 1y agoI was not involved in the original comment and not planning to publicly talk about my service until it's live, but the opportunity was too perfect to miss.
- pc86 1y agoYou need evidence to reasonably say they were "likely involved" and I don't think "it's conceivable that it happened that way" really counts as evidence.
- conductr 1y agoDebatable I suppose but I don't feel I do. That's what likely means - I feel I have enough suspicion, the coincidence is too strong, the stars too much in alignment... Hard to recreate but at the time I commented it was also the top comment with only a few others and it was on the front page. I've been a HN'er for a while and this is a rare situation to say the least if it's not a setup. I'm not willing to die on the hill and would gladly admit I'm wrong, I just see it as very suspicious forum spam as the most likely scenario
- morkalork 1y agoMaybe, maybe amanchanda is too.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]