4 ms·
The company behind this invention has been talking about the roll out of these cars for many, many years (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_Development_Interna
by jgrahamc 14y ago
The company behind this invention has been talking about the roll out of these cars for many, many years (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_Development_International http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_Development_International). And this particular blog post doesn't give any details of when Tata is going to actually produce a car. I recall a long time ago that these cars were going to be introduced in Mexico (that was one of many things that didn't happen).
Wikipedia has good articles on compressed-air engines and cars. Here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_engine#Automotive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Air_engine#Automotive and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressed-air_vehicle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compressed-air_vehicle
Tata has been a licensee of the technology since 2007 (http://www.gizmag.com/tata-motors-air-car-mdi/22447/ http://www.gizmag.com/tata-motors-air-car-mdi/22447/). When they go into production it will be interesting news.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThis. So back in 2007 I saw that Tata had licensed the technology for using the air-motor in its cars. As an infrastructure guy I thought "Hmmm, if this stuff works, I could use it in a data center." So I tried to do that. Here was the plan, using a windmill you could compress air, it's a pretty simple mechanical linkage, run a pump off the rotating vanes, has been done for hundreds if not thousands of years. But instead of water, you pump air into tanks. This generates heat because you are compressing the air of course but its windy so you've got heat sink vanes in the air flow being cooled by convection. Now at some point your data center wants a bit more juice, so you dump air through these MDI engines, which are running electrical generators. But here is the thing, when you dump the air it gets colder, a lot colder and the pipes can freeze up, but this is a datacenter and you run the pipes through the data center and cool it epic win! Power and cooling for free, the more power you use the more cooling you get, how neat is that?! Except there was no amount of money I could give MDI in exchange for engines. They don't make the engines, they don't have a plan to make the engines, they won't let someone build the engines and sell them at a profit because they won't license them to do so. I was a classic case of an inventor being so unrealistic about what the value of their invention is, they prohibit the creation of a market around it. The trick is that markets have choices, and an air engine would be a good choice, but not if it is not cost competitive with high efficiency diesel, or cheap (and dirty) two stroke gas engines. After I gave up (by mid 2008) trying to get them to see the error of their ways I figured it would be 20 years until we saw a credible use of this technology because all the patents would finally expire, and people would start to make them, and probably curse the folks at MDI for their short sightedness.
- Moto7451 14y agoTaking your idea a step further... When I did an internship at an architecture studio, the design of the central plants that provide hot/cold water/air to their surrounding buildings would use the exhaust heat of say, a water chiller for the air conditioning unit, to help heat the hot water flow, taking load off of the water heaters. In one case, they had enough "excess" heat available from doing this that a school got a heated pool for "free." You could do the same thing with the exhaust heat from the compressor to heat the restroom water for the data center's bathrooms. Not exactly super exciting to most, but for whatever reason I think stuff like this is the coolest thing ever.
- ars 14y ago> Power and cooling for free It's not in the slightest free. If you attached your windmill to a regular electrical generator, then used the electrical power as needed, plus a standard A/C you would come out ahead vs first compressing air, which is very wasteful. The reason it's so wasteful is the "you've got heat sink vanes in the air flow being cooled by convection". You are throwing away energy there.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoYou are pedantically correct sir, but there is a larger context. So in that larger context I was working on this plan when working for a company that had a data center near the Columbia River and 'industry leading' PUE numbers. Generally when the wind was blowing (and it blows a lot along the Columbia River Gorge) there is no need for additional cooling. When there is no air movement and the outside temperature is high, the demand for cooling increases requiring a more 'active' engagement (sorry but I can't be more specific than that). So realistically I was looking to time shift the excess cooling capacity that was available during windy times to the times when there was little wind and excess heat. Compressing air has some advantages in that the amount of energy you can get out vs the amount you put in is comparatively efficient to battery power, and using / exploiting the cooling effect of the expanding air, and the kinetic energy of its expansion to generate electricity, was actually more efficient than other methods. Maintenance burdens were also lower and municipal permitting was made easier by the lack of 'dangerous' chemicals or catalysts. These advantages are perhaps uniquely suited to data centers. Of course I didn't get to actually build it because MDI wouldn't participate. That was too bad but certainly well within their rights.