4 ms·
It seems odd to me that in other countries individuals can't bring criminal cases - leaving everything to the "official" prosecutor (e.g the Procurator Fiscal h
by arethuza 14y ago
It seems odd to me that in other countries individuals can't bring criminal cases - leaving everything to the "official" prosecutor (e.g the Procurator Fiscal here in Scotland).
- tptacek 14y agoHow, exactly, do pleas and charge reductions work when the person conducting the prosecution has none of the incentives for leniency that the state does?
- arethuza 14y agoGood question - it is perhaps worth noticing that private prosecutions are rather rare and typically only happen when the "official" prosecutor appears to have made an error of judgement and appear to be taken by victims (or their families) as an act of desperation. For example: http://www.firmmagazine.com/features/155/When_worlds_collide.html http://www.firmmagazine.com/features/155/When_worlds_collide... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Stephen_Lawrence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Stephen_Lawrence What happens in other countries if the "official" prosecutor chooses not to prosecute a crime? NB I'm not intending to imply that I think the various approaches to private prosecutions that we have in the UK are a good thing - this case brought by FACT does look a bit worrying.
- tptacek 14y agoIn the US, if the prosecutor with authority over the offense chooses not to prosecute, and no other venue exists to prosecute the offense (for instance, there's no federal angle to the offense that would get the FBI involved), that's where the matter ends. And that's exactly how things do end, all the time. This is mostly a good thing. If anything, we need more discretion over charging cases.
- vacri 14y agoThere are similar incentives - a 'not guilty' plea lengthens the case, which increases the cost to the prosecutor. I also understand that the if the prosecution loses, they pay the defendant's court costs, and a guilty plea means they win with no risk of that payout.
- waqf 14y agoAre you talking about plea bargains, that American system for bullying people into forgoing their right to be tried on the evidence?
- tptacek 14y agoIt seems like you either think we should eliminate the ability for defendants to negotiate lesser sentences, or you want to make an entirely orthogonal point about the US criminal justice system. Which is it? Prosecutors routinely have to decide between pressing an ambitious charge with a higher risk of acquittal, or settling for a lesser charge. This happens all the way up and down the spectrum of offenses; for instance, there's something like 4 different things a mugger in Chicago can get charged with. How exactly do this balance get handled when the prosecutor is by charter acting in their own interests and not the interests of the community?
- waqf 14y agopara 2: I don't understand the issue. Surely the prosecutor should throw everything s/he's got and the judge and jury, who are charged with protecting the interests of the community, decide what sticks? For the prosecutor to be involved in that decision seems a conflict of interest/incentive to corruption (this is the point you are making about private prosecutions, but I would argue that even a public prosecutor is rewarded for convictions). para 1: yes, I want to eliminate the ability for defendants to negotiate lesser sentences. Like many practices we like to despise governments for tolerating (bribery, corruption, torture), it's convenient, practical and even successful in many cases, but it's totally unjust.
- tptacek 14y agoIt's totally unjust if the world is a computer simulation in which arbiters have perfect information and there's a binary right/wrong answer to every problem. Since that's not the world we live in, I am very glad prosecutors are allowed the discretion to follow human intuition about the grade of offense to charge. Like most other government interventions, there are checks and balances regulation that discretion.