3 ms·
> Except in this case, we already have the equivalent of "laws about oxygen consumption": copyright. Copyright laws were themselves created by the printing pre
by ben_w 2y ago
> Except in this case, we already have the equivalent of "laws about oxygen consumption": copyright.
Copyright laws were themselves created by the printing press making it easy to duplicate works, whereas previously if you half-remembered something that was just "inspiration".
But that only gave the impression of helping creative people: today, any new creative person has to compete with the entire reproducible cannon of all of humanity before them — can you write fantasy so well that new readers pick you up over Pratchett or Tolkien?
Now we have AI which are "inspired" (perhaps) by what they read, and half-remember it, in a way that seems similar to pre-printing-press humans sharing stories even if the mechanism is different.
How this is seen according to current law likely varies by jurisdiction; but the law as it is today matters less than what the law will be when the new ones are drafted to account for GenAI.
What that will look like, I am unsure. Could be that for training purposes, copyright becomes eternal… but it's also possible that copyright may cease to exist entirely — laws to protect the entire creative industry may seem good, but if AI displaces all humans from economic activity, will it continue to matter?
- Jensson 2y ago> But that only gave the impression of helping creative people: today, any new creative person has to compete with the entire reproducible cannon of all of humanity before them — can you write fantasy so well that new readers pick you up over Pratchett or Tolkien? That is even worse without copyright, as then every previous work would be free and you would have to compete with better works that are also free for people.
- Suppafly 2y ago>that are also free for people sounds like a good deal if you're people.
- palmotea 2y ago> Copyright laws were themselves created by the printing press making it easy to duplicate works, whereas previously if you half-remembered something that was just "inspiration". Eh. I don't know the history, but my understanding was they were created because the printing press allowed others to deny the original creators the profits to their work, and direct those profits to others who had no hand in it. After all, in market terms: a publisher that pays its authors can't compete with another that publisher that publishes the same works but without paying any authors. A word without copyright is one where some publisher still makes money, but it's a race to the bottom for authors. > But that only gave the impression of helping creative people: today, any new creative person has to compete with the entire reproducible cannon of all of humanity before them — can you write fantasy so well that new readers pick you up over Pratchett or Tolkien? Here's a hole in your thinking: if you like fantasy, would you be content to just re-read Tolkien over and over, forever? Don't you think that'd get boring no matter how good he was? And empirically, "new creative [people]" manage to complete with Pratchett or Tolkien all the time, as new fantasy works are still being published and read. Do you remember that "Game of Thrones" was a mass cultural phenomenon not too long ago?
- ben_w 2y ago> A word without copyright is one where some publisher still makes money, but it's a race to the bottom for authors. This is the case anyway; there are many writers competing for the opportunity to be published, so the publishers have a massive advantage, and it is the technology of printing (and cheap paper) that makes this a one-sided relationship — if every story teller had to be heard in person, with no recordings or reproductions possible, then story tellers would be found in every community, and they would be valued by their community. > Here's a hole in your thinking: if you like fantasy, would you be content to just re-read Tolkien over and over, forever? Don't you think that'd get boring no matter how good he was? The examples aren't meant to be exclusive, and Pratchett has a lot of books. There's far more books on the market right now than a human can read in a lifetime. At some point, we may have already passed it, there will be far more good books on the market than a human can read in a lifetime, at which point it's not quality, it's fashion. > And empirically, "new creative [people]" manage to complete with Pratchett or Tolkien all the time, as new fantasy works are still being published and read. At some point, there will be more books at least as good as Pratchett, Tolkien, Le Guin, McCaffrey, Martin, Heinlein, Niven etc. in each genre, than anyone can read. > Do you remember that "Game of Thrones" was a mass cultural phenomenon not too long ago? Published: August 1, 1996 — concurrently with Pratchett. Better example would have been The Expanse — worth noting that SciFi has a natural advantage over (high) fantasy or romance, as the nature of speculative science fiction means it keeps considering futures that are rendered as obsolete as the worn-down buttons on the calculator that Hari Seldon was rumoured to keep under his pillow.