3 ms·
Is that because of innovation? Or is that because of Google’s antitrust activity the US government is currently busting? Safari default search engine deal, etc.
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Is that because of innovation? Or is that because of Google’s antitrust activity the US government is currently busting? Safari default search engine deal, etc.
- bobxmax 2y ago"Antitrust" is just lawyer-talk for winning strategies that we later arbitrarily decide is not good for capitalism. They weren't a bunch of gremlins in a cave conspiring to commit "anti-trust violations" in 2005. They were smart as hell and invested in the right areas. Microsoft would get hit with the same anti-trust Google is being hit with if Bing and Windows Phone were successful - they're getting away with it because they're terrible.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 2y ago> "Antitrust" is just lawyer-talk for winning strategies that we later arbitrarily decide is not good for capitalism. “I don’t like the law and its application” isn’t an argument.
- tqi 2y agoThese aren't like the laws of physics, there's obviously a lot of post hoc interpretation that happens.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoCertainly, when a law that wasn’t applied begins to be applied again, I can see certain mental models taking issue with that. Regardless, the law and its historical application and consequences didn’t change, only a politically driven low enforcement period. That was the anomaly.
- echelon 2y agoThere are models that are close enough. If you allow one company to achieve market dominance, it suffocates the ecosystem and stifles evolutionary growth pressures. It's concentrated malinvestment into a local maxima that salts the playing field so thoroughly that escape velocity is unattainable by anyone else. There are models of this. And historical anecdotes and evidence.
- KerrAvon 2y agoThe meaning of “antitrust” is very clearly defined. You’re allowed not to like it or to think that laws against it should be struck down, or whatever, but you can’t say it’s something it’s not.
- tqi 2y agoIs it? IANAL, but it seems like the concept is actually quite ambiguously defined[1], by design. [1] https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/guide-antitrust-laws/antitrust-laws#:~:text=The%20Sherman%20Act%20outlaws,or%20justification%20is%20allowed. https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui...
- tossandthrow 2y ago> They weren't a bunch of gremlins in a cave conspiring to commit "anti-trust violations" in 2005. They were smart as hell and invested in the right areas. You still killed the man regardless of intention.
- nottorp 2y ago> winning strategies Winning for who? Not for society as a whole, that's certain. To put it in money terms so even you can understand it, how much time has been wasted globally because Google is peddling ads and spam sites instead of pointing people to useful results? Is that free? We should substract it from the GDP calculations if you ask me...
- intended 2y agoAnti Trust is not lawyer speak for winning strategies. It’s a specific term, and theres a time and place to use it. Anti trust is what people, especially programmers, have been saying from time immemorial when these firms became this big. Inefficient markets are bad for humans and are bad markets. The allocate resources inefficiently. The google graveyard is (arguably) a case in point. The reason Khan reached the FTC was because her thesis at college, made the case that amazon’s actions reduced customer welfare. A fact that was covered here, on HN. This isn’t something a community notices unless it matters to them.
- wavemode 2y agoYou seem to possess the (very common) misconception that monopolies are illegal. They are not. Rather, it is illegal to intentionally use one's monopolistic position to make it difficult or impossible for others to compete.