50 ms·
But benefits have a lot to do with utilization
by fauigerzigerk 18y ago
But benefits have a lot to do with utilization
- anamax 18y agoBenefits are value received. The value that I get from a home computer do not depend on how little time it spends in its idle loop (or even turned on). The value also doesn't necessarily depend on how often I use it. (A home defibrillator is extremely valuable even if it's only used once, and fairly valuable even if it's never used.)
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoThere are opportunity costs. If I buy a hard drive that I never use I could have bought shares of amazon instead. By your definition, money could never be wasted or used inefficiently. If I waste money and my competitor does not, then it's not economically sustainable for me.
- anamax 18y agoOpportunity costs have nothing to do with utilization. Moreover, they're covered in my initial comment "Economic sustainability is a function of cost and benefits, not utilization." Low utilization may imply "waste" but cost and benefit is what matters. Benefits that I get for the costs I incur determine whether buying a new PC is a good idea, not how idle it is. In fact, trying to drive to maximum utilization frequently results in higher costs and lower benefits.
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoIf you deny any link between benefits and utilization, then I understand your argument. But I think your argument is wrong because it contradicts the very purpose of buying capital goods. You buy capital goods because utilizing them makes you a profit. Just owning them does not. But I agree that this is just a general rule which is not true in all situations, particularly not in economic downturns. If I buy 3 TB of hard disk space expecting to serve 300000 customers and then only 100 customers turn up, I have wasted much of my expenditure because it's useless. If I buy a dynamic amount of hard disk space from a cloud service on demand, then I have not wasted that money. So, clearly, opportunity cost has a lot to do with utilization if you assume a positive connection between utilization and profit, which you apparently don't. Go ask any airline about it :)
- anamax 18y ago> If you deny any link between benefits and utilization, then I understand your argument. I deny it because there isn't any link - "excess" resources don't reduce benefits. > But I think your argument is wrong because it contradicts the very purpose of buying capital goods. The purpose of buying capital goods is to receive more benefits than the costs incurred, the metric being benefits-costs/costs. (Note - benefits are not profit.) Benefits don't depend on utilization. (While the amount of money that 100 people will pay me to fly them from NYC to LA might depend on how full their plane is, it isn't affected by me having 1 vs 1e6 planes parked in AZ.) Utilization can affect costs, but the connection isn't always strong. For example, my PC could usually get by with 400MB of ram. However, several times a year, I get significant benefit from having 1GBy. That benefit easily exceeds the cost of 500MBy of ram, even the "utilization" of said extra ram is low. (And no, the cost of renting ram when I need it isn't less.) Note that the "utilization is key" argument would suggest that I'd be better off with 400MB of RAM than 500MB. That's clearly absurd because 400MB costs more than 500MB. And then there's the difibrillator example. If I only use it once, is it useless?
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoYou're misunderstanding me. The link between benefits and utilization is that in order to gain future benefits you spend a certain amount on capital goods, based on your expectation of utilization. You must have an idea of utilization because that's what determines cost and hence profit. That's the link I was talking about and it doesn't contradict your parked airplanes example at all. The original question we were discussing was whether buying excess resources was economically sustainable. I think we can agree that economic sustainability depends on profits. Higher costs reduce profits and therefore threaten economic sustainability. Now, you say the connection between utilization and costs is not always strong. No, it's not always strong, but it is strong enough for entire industries to focus on exactly that issue. People are fired right now because they cannot be "utilized". Planes are rented away so they do not rot in AZ hangars. It's because machines lose value over time. Owning them without being able to make money out of them means you lose money every month. So spare capacity becomes a huge problem if growth doesn't meet expectations. Paying only for the resources you actually use increases flexibility and reduces costs. If your expectations are wrong, you haven't spent the money buying the hardware either. Many dot coms would've been very happy to accept that logic in 2000. But of course you pay a premium for that flexibility and if it turns out your growth expectations were right, you may have been better off not paying that flexibility premium. It's an insurance contract against the risk of wrong expectations.