4 ms·
> Is LTXV-13B open source? > Yes, LTXV-13B is available under the LTXV Open Weights License. The model and its tools are open source, allowing for community de
by simonw 2y ago
> Is LTXV-13B open source?
> Yes, LTXV-13B is available under the LTXV Open Weights License. The model and its tools are open source, allowing for community development and customization.
UPDATE: This is text on an unofficial website unaffiliated with the project. BUT https://www.lightricks.com/ https://www.lightricks.com/ has "LTXV open source video model" in a big header at the top of my page so my complaint still stands, even though the FAQ copy I'm critiquing here is likely not the fault of Lightricks themselves.
So it's open weights, not open source.
Open weights is great! No need to use the wrong term for it.
From https://static.lightricks.com/legal/LTXV-2B-Distilled-04-25-Open-Weights-License.pdf https://static.lightricks.com/legal/LTXV-2B-Distilled-04-25-... it looks like the key non-open-source terms (by the OSI definition which I consider to be canon) are:
- Section 2: entities with annual revenues of at least $10,000,000 (the “Commercial
Entities”) are eligible to obtain a paid commercial use license, subject to the terms and provisions of a
different license (the “Commercial Use Agreement”)
- Section 6: To the maximum extent permitted by law, Licensor reserves the right to restrict (remotely or otherwise) usage of the Model in violation of this Agreement, update the Model through electronic means, or modify the Output of the Model based on updates
This is an easy fix: change that FAQ entry to:
> Is LTXV-13B open weights?
> Yes, LTXV-13B is available under the LTXV Open Weights License. The model is open weights and the underlying code is open source (Apache 2.0), allowing for community development and customization.
Here's where the code became Apache 2.0 6 months ago: https://github.com/Lightricks/LTX-Video/commit/cfbb059629b9971b97a23fd876288130ec68d3fd https://github.com/Lightricks/LTX-Video/commit/cfbb059629b99...
- jeroenhd 2y agoAre weights even copyrightable? I'm not sure what these licenses do, other than placate corporate legal or pretend to have some kind of open source equivalent for AI stuff.
- badsectoracula 2y agoDepends on how they're made. If they're fully automated and copyrights do not transfer from training data to trained weights (which is what everyone assumes at the moment) then they're the same as any machine output: not copyrightable, just like AI output isn't copyrightable. However if there is any active human involvement during training, one could claim that this makes it human work so they're copyrightable. For example not too long ago i wrote a simple upscaler for gamescope when i was learning how to implement neural networks and i did it in a somewhat "manual" manner by running the training for a bit, testing output, modifying a bit the code, adding/changing training data, then picking up from where the training stopped and continuing from there, etc, so one could claim that the weights i ended up with are the result of my own creative process (though TBH i wouldn't nor i am comfortable with the idea myself since we're talking about a few hundred numbers).